8 ms·
So the hotel industry's plan revolves solely around more legislation and regulation? How about competing by innovating and providing the consumer with a better
by bogomipz 10y ago
So the hotel industry's plan revolves solely around more legislation and regulation?
How about competing by innovating and providing the consumer with a better or improved experience?
Does the industry really believe that theres nothing they can do to improve on the consumer experience? It feels like its changed very little if at all over the years.
How about stop charging $15.00 a day for internet. It's 2017 charging for internet like charging for power in the room.
How about getting rid of inflexible checkin/checkout times?
How about lobbying local governments to reduce the exorbitant double digit taxes and fees consumers pay on hotels stays instead.[1]
Example tax rates:
18.27% New York City
17.76% Nashville
17% Houston and Indianapolis
16.75% San Antonio, TX and Columbus, OH
[1] http://www.travelandleisure.com/articles/understanding-hotel-taxes http://www.travelandleisure.com/articles/understanding-hotel...
- kilroy123 10y agoAgreed. I find it utter insulting when they charge for internet.
- eps 10y agoIs this an US thing? I travel a lot and I can't remember the last time I had a hotel to charge for the Internet access separately.
- mixedCase 10y agoMy parents went on a trip to Europe a few years ago and we used Skype on every location they stayed at. The only place where they didn't have to pay separately for Internet access and where the connection wasn't dogcrap was Austria. And I don't remember where it happened, but in one case it was so outrageously expensive they just waited until their following destination to call. But indeed, they later traveled to the US and had to pay as well. Nowhere I have stayed at in our third world country (Uruguay) this is a thing.
- hellofunk 10y agoI've stayed in hotels all over Europe and never once paid for internet. I did pay in India, however.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"Is this an US thing?" I think its mostly a big corporate hotel chain thing as I have also experienced this in the EU as well(although it might have been an American hotel chain) at times but it's definitely a common practice in the US yes. Equally annoying is that these hotels will use some horrible third party captive portal that you need to re-log in to at regular intervals. I've often been disconnected because some arbitrary timer expired while I was in the middle of something important. You will almost never see a small boutique hotel in the U.S charge for internet access or have a captive port however.
- irrational 10y agoMore precisely, it is a big corporate hotel chain thing for those properties that are more likely to host business people who can expense the cost.
- ghaff 10y agoIt's less common than it used to be but it still happens in the US. As someone else said, mostly business chain type places although it's often waived if you belong to their loyalty club, book directly with the hotel, have a corporate rate, have a conference rate, etc. So it's nominally there for a fair number of hotels but I'm not sure the last time I actually ended up paying.
- dragonwriter 10y agoA lot also have a free base level and a additional-charge premium internet service that allows higher speed and/or more devices.
- ghaff 10y agoFair enough. Though I find the base-level service has generally improved over the past few years. Personally, I never upgrade. If streaming video doesn't work, I always have local-stored video with me when I travel anyway.
- fredophile 10y agoIt's a market segmentation thing. Hotels that cater to business travelers can charge extra because the employer will pay for it. Hotels that cater to families usually have free internet.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Hotels that cater to business travelers can charge extra because the employer will pay for it. More likely, IMO, hotels that cater to businesses have separate charges for internet because business (especially government) travel offices often have fixed (sometimes location-sensitive) caps on reimbursable lodging rates (but may, or may not, separately reimburse for other services during the stay with appropriate justification), so pulling non-core services out of the core rate means that more travellers will stay there. Families, conversely—while price sensitive—will compare amenities and rarely have strict caps for the base lodging rate irrespective of what other services are included.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"It's a market segmentation thing. Hotels that cater to business travelers can charge extra because the employer will pay for it." What does this actually mean any more though to "cater to business travelers"? Once upon a time a hotel that catered to business travelers had a "business center" which meant there was an auxiliary room with a fax machine, a photo copier and a couple of PCs", that is largely anachronistic now though. And I think this kind of illustrates how stuck in a different era most of these hotels are.
- tbihl 10y agoAnother response below correctly answers your question. In business hotels, rates are set to be eligible for corporate booking. Expensing the internet separately is a non-issue for these customers.
- 77pt77 10y agoDefinitely not only US thing. I've seen this in many other places.
- dagw 10y agoHappens quite often in Germany and I've also run across it in Spain.
- ithinkinstereo 10y agoMost of the major hotel chains in the US have phased out this practice. You only find it nowadays in the top tier chains, and even then, they usually offer free internet to members of their frequent traveller programs.
- prklmn 10y agoThe hotels would find more success in lobbying city governments to levy a tax on airbnb stays rather than trying to get the hotel stay taxes reduced.
- koolba 10y agoBonus points if it's the same tax rate as us charged to hotels. Extra bonus points if it's more than the regular hotel tax rates to compensate the municipality for the zoning changes caused by transients staying in residential areas.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- philrapo 10y agoAirBnb is also collecting occupancy tax in many cities [0]. I don't have a view on whether this tax is well justified, but it does seem like if hotels are required to charge it, then full time airbnb hosts should be required to charge it as well. [0] https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/653/in-what-areas-is-occupancy-tax-collection-and-remittance-by-airbnb-available https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/653/in-what-areas-is-occ...
- bogomipz 10y agoI understand that AirBnB is now collecting an Transient Occupancy Tax on a county by county or city by city basis. I'm not arguing that whether AirBnB should be required to charge it. But when you stay in a hotel you as a guest get hit with both an occupancy tax and a sales tax. The PDF here is a few years old but its a good overview of the tax regimes: https://www.hvs.com/article/6856/the-2013-hvs-us-lodging-tax-study/ https://www.hvs.com/article/6856/the-2013-hvs-us-lodging-tax...
- transfire 10y agoSo fking sick of Corporatism.
- transfire 10y agoBeen waiting for someone to open a direct to door check in too. Just insert ID and credit card in a door that says Vacant, and boom you are in.
- cmurf 10y agoLocal governments always charge these kinds of rates, it's easy to get "doesn't cost me" taxes to help make up budget shortfalls. Same with sin taxes.
- BearGoesChirp 10y agoMaybe it isn't that they can't innovate, but that it is more cost effective to lobby than to innovate. The return on investment for getting new regulations passed that helps them is higher than the return on investment for providing a better service that attracts customers. Maybe paying the government to ban your competitor is the wiser business move.
- ithinkinstereo 10y ago> Does the industry really believe that theres nothing they can do to improve on the consumer experience? It feels like its changed very little if at all over the years. You must not travel alot, or at least not in the US. There has actually been a lot of innovation amongst the big brand chains in recent years. Hilton for example allows online/app check-in/check-out and they've been aggressively rolling out digital room key compatibility across their properties (via bluetooth in the app). This has allowed me in recent stays to completely avoid the front desk / human interaction - from check-in to check-out. > How about stop charging $15.00 a day for internet. It's 2017 charging for internet like charging for power in the room. WiFi is mostly free for most of major chains in the US (Hilton, Marriott, IHG) - especially their secondary brands (Hampton Inns, Springfield Suites, Courtyard, etc.). Those that charge usually offer it for free to members of their loyalty/points programs. These days, I mostly see paid-internet in the top tier hotel brands in tier-one cities. Think the Ritz in NYC, etc. Again the internet is usually free for members of their frequent traveller programs. > How about getting rid of inflexible checkin/checkout times? All the major brands have check-in / check-out flexibility. I've never been denied late check-out requests, especially with advance notice. Most hotels will allow early check-ins no problem and most chains allow you to request this via the web / app. Early check-in / late check-out is also typically _guaranteed_ for elite members of their frequent travel programs (at least this is the case for Hilton and Marriott). > How about lobbying local governments to reduce the exorbitant double digit taxes and fees consumers pay on hotels stays instead.[1] It's worth remembering that those taxes go towards meeting various regulatory requirements, like ensuring safety standards, etc.... things it's important to remember that AirBnB lacks. If all AirBnBs are required to have working fire alarms for example, I'm sure AirBnB will tack on a "safety" fee, just like Uber did when they had to do driver background checks. As a frequent traveler (so far over 40 hotel stays this year), I always prefer a hotel to an AirBnB. It is 100x more convenient for mostly a marginal difference. Pro-tip: for hilton properties use hiltonfamilymvp.com for 10-30% off the rack rates.
- bogomipz 10y ago>You must not travel alot, or at least not in the US." I spend a little over half a year on the road. I've recently been charged for internet at an Omni, a Wyndham, and a Westin hotel in the U.S. >"All the major brands have check-in / check-out flexibility. I've never been denied late check-out requests, especially with advance notice. Most hotels will allow early check-ins no problem and most chains allow you to request this via the web / app." I am referring to being able to specify my checkin and checkout time when I book. All of the online reservations systems I have used still mandate 3:00PM check in. I am not talking about picking up the phone and calling the front desk after I am already in the room. >"It's worth remembering that those taxes go towards meeting various regulatory requirements, like ensuring safety standards, etc.... things it's important to remember that AirBnB lacks." Really 15% of a $300 dollar a night hotel for 3 days(roughly $135) goes to meeting safety inspections? None of the $300 a night goes towards meeting that? I'm sorry but I don't think that a hotel having an app for your smartphone is some great innovation in the industry.
- yeahsure777 10y agoThey need to capitalism harder!