6 ms·
It's so upsetting to me that they don't make bands like this available for general public use. If we had clearly defined rules about interoperability we could r
by TaylorAlexander 10y ago
It's so upsetting to me that they don't make bands like this available for general public use. If we had clearly defined rules about interoperability we could reserve a band for essentially free low bandwidth cell phone usage, at least for text and basic data.
I've imagined that the towers could be open hardware that sell minutes on the fly for bitcoin transferred by the user.
But no, instead these corporations pay billions with the expectation that they'll recover that and much more from us who have no free option for mobile wireless.
It's really frustrating to me.
- ajosh 10y agoThat is really the purpose of the amateur service. It is available to the general public with an inexpensive / free license. Business use is prohibited. There are a lot of other rules that you may or may not like but that is the purpose of amateur radio. There are allocations across the spectrum including some bands that are very valuable today (440MHz, 900MHz, 1.2GHz). There are also allocations in bands with interesting properties such as high microwave, MF and short wave. The ITU even recently approved use in long wave bands which hasn't been available for amateur use for over 80 years.
- mmagin 10y agoWhile that's great for some purposes, I think the GP is suggesting that there is a need for more accessible spectrum for businesses which do not have the financial capabilities or political capabilities as the large telecoms and broadcasters.
- ac29 10y agoHow much spectrum? Businesses and individuals can get non-exclusive FCC licences (you don't have exclusive usage rights, but in practice, you can operate 24/7 without interference) for small slices of spectrum (12.5 or 25kHz) for under $1000 for a 10 year licence. If you want 1MHz+ in a desirable band, with exclusive usage rights, well, there's a reason those auctions end up going for millions or billions of dollars.
- pdelbarba 10y agoThe most notable restriction being a prohibition on encryption of any kind.
- PaulHoule 10y agoActually a few years back there was this idea called "White Spaces" that was exactly that... If the TV airwaves were not in use in your area, you could use them for other purposes. Here's what happened. Out on the west coast, particularly in Los Angeles, there are no white spaces. In LA you can often get nearly 100 channels with just an indoor antenna. It is unlike any other TV market in the U.S. Well because there were not white spaces there, they managed to delay the introduction of "White Space" hardware and also the spectrum database needed to support this service. Then, of course, the cell phone companies came in to buy up a lot of spectrum. Because things are changing, the white space market got stunted. Now that the cell phone companies own the spectrum, there are no white spaces, or at least, much less of them than they used to be. It's a generally forgotten story that the spectrum situation on the west coast is entirely different from the rest of the country because of the "ring of fire" topography that focuses settlement along the coast. Out in the Northeast we find that the population is dispersed enough that there are not many transmitters near most sites, but that cities are close enough that there are not many transmitters near most cities. For instance, in Boston you have to worry about interference with Hartford and Portland, ME. Don't get me started about 900 MHz, which is a non-starter because of the concentration of the electronics industry in Palo Alto, where 900 MHz is crammed with half-baked gadgets made by Stanford kids.
- rayiner 10y agoThat's one part of the problem. The other part of the problem is that commercial deployment of white spaces and similar technology has been held to a pretty much impossible standard: https://www.techworld.com.au/article/261483/google_page_white_spaces_test_unfair https://www.techworld.com.au/article/261483/google_page_whit.... The idea is to take advantage of unused spectrum without ever bothering incumbent users. In many cases that's simply impossible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hidden_node_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hidden_node_problem. The problem becomes much more tractable when you ditch the requirement to protect legacy transmitters and receivers in the same band. Dynamic spectrum access technology existing today could work pretty well if you gave it a big chunk of its own spectrum, and used those technologies to mediate contention among themselves. When the FCC can get tens of billions of dollars auctioning spectrum, making the case for that becomes difficult.
- G3E9 10y agoI've imagined mesh networks across weaker frequencies, it'd probably require some new protocols but I haven't done that much research so I'm just not aware of any. If devices or modems/routers were accessible and marketed correctly, I think the niche would grow with passionate users. Just knowing you could hop off of your terrible ISP (or at least avoid them some) would be enough for many people.
- mtgx 10y agoAnd it's probably going to get worse with LTE-U. It will likely hurt 5GHz Wi-Fi performance for the benefit of carriers, which will overcrowd that band.
- jessaustin 10y agoIsn't 5GHz blocked by pretty much everything? So if you're in your house, the carriers won't be able to interfere with your WiFi?
- rhino369 10y agoPretty high attenuation but it does go through walls.
- sandworm101 10y agoSome things can be crowdsourced, but not cell towers. These are just gateways to an underlying infrastructure. Someone needs to manage the fiber to the towers. Someone needs to get the permits, hire the diggers and occasionally lobby various governments. That takes years and won't ever be done by a F/OSS volunteer backed by donations. There are things that corporations do well, or at least better than the general public.
- TaylorAlexander 10y agoFor a low data capacity network, I don't see why home data connections shouldn't work. I have a 130Mb connection at home, which would support plenty of voice calls simultaneously. The real issue here is the control ISPs have over the networks. In my imagined future where we have crowd sourced cell towers, the tower operators have their own fiber connection at home that is essentially unregulated. Because that's a future I want for other reasons.
- notdonspaulding 10y agoUnless you're paying for dedicated internet access, you likely don't "have a 130Mb connection at home". Or, at least you don't actually have full access to all 130Mbps all the time. Try using 100% of the capacity of your connection for an entire month and see if you don't get a call from your ISP. Your basic home internet package of anywhere from 10-200Mbps is priced at a level which is consistent with a usage profile typical of most home users. A fiber drop to a cell tower has a much different usage profile over the course of a month.
- olkid 10y agoPlease, check your service contract before running for a month at capacity. A call from your ISP may be preferable over a bill from a tiered residential plan.
- user5994461 10y agoOne of the first thing you learn in telecommunication is that frequencies are one of the most precious resources on the planet. There are only very few of those, you can't make more of it, you can't share one, if two things try to use the same they are both broken. By the way, there are free bands available to the general public for free use.
- madengr 10y agoThey do. It's amateur radio.