5 ms·
As usual, people don't know their own desires. Ask people what makes them choose an airline and they'll probably tell you a tale about reputation, service, leg
by mikeash 10y ago
As usual, people don't know their own desires.
Ask people what makes them choose an airline and they'll probably tell you a tale about reputation, service, legroom, amenities, what have you.
Now stick them in front of a computer and tell them to buy a ticket with their own money and watch them pick the cheapest option regardless of the rest.
It's a race to the bottom because that's what people really want. When the rubber meets the road, most people want a horrible, cheap experience.
Why do airlines overbook flights? Because people would rather save $5 with a chance of being bumped than pay a little extra.
Obviously, we'd all love direct flights with sixteen feet of legroom, a hundred free checked bags, gourmet meals, free access to a library of every movie and TV show ever made, and for a price of $3.50. But that's not going to happen, because amenities cost money. When we're faced with the tradeoff, we favor low prices.
Once I truly realized this, I became a lot less annoyed with many airline shenanigans. Yeah, it's pretty annoying that as a tall guy I barely fit into the seat. But it's what I paid for. If it was that important to me, I could pay extra for more space. I don't, because, like most people, I prefer cheapness above all else.
You can get a much nicer experience if you pay for it. If you don't feel like paying for it, then what are you complaining about?
Not particularly related, but this line from the article caught my eye:
"It makes no sense to allow airlines to charge an astronomical fare just because a flight is nearly full, and a dirt-cheap fare for an advance booking."
What planet is this guy from? Of course it makes sense to charge high fares for a scarce product in high demand, and low fares for an abundant product in low demand.
- rconti 10y agoThe irony of the last line is, if the airline DIDN'T jack up the fares just before the flight sold out, it would be even more oversold than the airline that jacks up prices but fails to sell those last couple of seats at high cost. In fact, that high price is one way they keep a flight from being overbooked (or TOO overbooked). (though, on further reflection, if they overbook 5 seats on extremely expensive fares, then 'bump' the lowest-utility (==poorest) passengers for $200 in flight credit, they've managed to raise the fare for already-paid-for-seats)
- mikeash 10y agoRegarding your parenthetical, if the bumping is voluntary then, at least in theory, everyone comes out ahead. The airline makes more money, the person in a hurry who is willing to pay more money gets to his destination more quickly, and the person who isn't in much of a hurry gets to pay even less for their flight than they originally thought. It's like an auction for the seat after the fact. Of course, this is only a good thing if the airlines are transparent about it, and offer enough compensation to bumped passengers for them to take it voluntarily.
- closeparen 10y agoBut we aren't given the option to pay a proportionally higher fare for proportionally higher quality. Higher fare classes aren't +20%, +30%, they're 3x, 4x, 10x. There are "I only shop on price" seats and "money is no object" seats. I wish we had more of a middle, beyond the usual +$150 for an exit row or +$100 for a regular economy seat, but in the forward half of the plane.
- mikeash 10y agoWhat would you want that would be beyond the premium for a nicer seat, but less than business class?
- ashark 10y agoSeriously, show me where I can pay an almost-reasonable (say, 10-15%) upgrade fee for 3-4" more legroom over whatever the lowest is they can get away with (so, what they actually use in economy ordinarily) and I'll pay it every single time I fly, and I'm not even that tall. AFAIK leg room and other space considerations aren't even presented to me when shopping for tickets, but too little of it is my #1 complaint about flying, which is saying something because most things about flying are complaint-worthy.
- maxerickson 10y agoUnited calls that "Economy Plus". Not sure the price structure matches what you say: https://www.united.com/CMS/en-US/products/travelproducts/Pages/EconomyPlus.aspx https://www.united.com/CMS/en-US/products/travelproducts/Pag... Exit row seats are also often first available to members of various frequent flyer programs and usually have a modest amount of extra legroom.
- ashark 10y agoFirst: thanks for the link, interesting to know that there's kind-of something out there for this. From the FAQ on the linked page: > Who can purchase Economy Plus seating? All customers who are not traveling on a Basic Economy ticket may purchase Economy Plus seating subject to availability. Advance complimentary access to Economy Plus is available to Premier® Platinum members and higher (for themselves and up to eight companions), and Premier Gold members (for themselves and one companion). Premier Silver members and one companion enjoy complimentary access to Economy Plus seating, when available, upon check-in. I just... what is this even? How about just putting the legroom on ticket sale data—including for sales on 3rd party sites—and selling different ones at different prices? I don't want to become an expert on all this weird tricking-you-into-spending-more-money-with-us-than-you-should-if-you're-not-super-careful crap for every airline I might fly with, I just want to buy a ticket and fly every now and then, and I'm willing to pay for more legroom. How would I even begin to comparison shop for this upgrade vs. other airlines? I know the answer is "you're not supposed to because they're trying to screw you" but that's an awful answer. This is precisely where regulation is useful: transparency in WTF you're buying and standards in how it's presented so competition can work its magic without consumers having to learn a bunch of otherwise-useless junk (the worst of which is "how to navigate systems and jargon that are specific to one vendor") in order to confidently make a simple transaction.
- gist 10y ago> What planet is this guy from? Of course it makes sense to charge high fares for a scarce product in high demand, and low fares for an abundant product in low demand. Agree. Not to mention spoken by a person who almost certainly has never run a business. And make no mistake 'charging high fares' when you can allows you to lower the price of other seats and fees. Eliminate that excess profit and it will be made up somewhere else in the pricing scheme. No different than concerts or alcohol or premium water in restaurants.
- mayneack 10y agoSome airline shenanigans still demonstrate contradictory incentives. On each of the ~20 jetblue flights I've been on in the last few years. They ask for volunteers to gate check carry on bags to the final destination for free because there isn't enough overhead space. But they're the ones that force us to try to get into a carry on by charging for normally checked bags. I've tried asking outside security if I can check my carry on since I'll eventually be asked to voluntarily gate check it, and they don't let me. Instead we make boarding this competitive experience that takes longer than it needs to as passengers fight for overhead bin space.
- mikeash 10y agoThat sounds like good old-fashioned market segmentation to me. People who aren't price sensitive will pay to check their bags. People who would rather save their money and have more hassle will cart it through security and then gate check it when the bins fill up. I am puzzled by the various choices that airlines make that seem to dramatically increase their aircraft's turnaround time at the gate. I can only assume that either it doesn't do as much harm as it seems to, or short turnaround isn't as valuable as I think it is.
- cardiffspaceman 10y agoThe TSA restrictions on carry-on luggage caused me to quit checking my main bag even though I use a bag that is designed for the typical domestic overhead bin. Relevant to what seems to be your local optimization, if you are trying to get your bag checked for free, you are combining all the possible inconveniences: carry the bag to the gate, have its contents qualify as carry-on contents, and wait for it at the carousel when you land. It does seem like a better idea to waive the fee at times, in order to streamline operations. But I pay the fee 24 hours in advance (when online checkin opens). How would they implement a waiver fairly?
- zippergz 10y agoSome people who fly for business are FORCED to choose the cheapest option (sometimes cheapest "logical" option, but the definition of "logical" is about no ridiculous routing, not legroom or seat comfort). The classic disconnect between the buyer (my company) and the user (me)...
- lutorm 10y agoPartially, I agree. But the current way of selling airline tickets also push price as the variable to base your choice on. Travel time is maybe a distant second. (I often buy the not-cheapest ticket to get a better routing, a 10% premium often gets you a significantly shorter trip if we're talking e.g. Hawaii to Europe.) These are all very easily quantifiable variables. Maybe you can find out how on-time that flight normally is. You have to do a lot of research to figure out how much legroom you'll have on a specific flight. And knowing what your risk of getting denied boarding is almost impossible, so I'd argue that is in fact not priced into the current model. Right now it's also not possible to choose based on these variables since the choice of airline is so strongly correlated with travel time, unless you are travelling between one airline's hub and another's.
- mikeash 10y agoI'm pretty sure that the current way of selling things is because that what people want, rather than the other way around. This race to the bottom was in full force long before people routinely purchased tickets online.