4 ms·
How is this anywhere close to the same as Alien species using humans? We differentiate treatment by intelligence of species for a good reason. We allow courts t
by dmix 10y ago
How is this anywhere close to the same as Alien species using humans? We differentiate treatment by intelligence of species for a good reason. We allow courts to deal with the subtleties of what is considered cruel and unusual punishment for humans as well from this rational perspective, allowing certain degrees depending on context.
I'm against whales and dolphins being kept in small area confinement. But I could hardly care about a crab being bled.
The only concern is on the survivability of the species and the effect on the greater ecosystem.
This is very rational and I don't see anything morally wrong with it. Nor do the vast majority of other scientists. Many of whom know much more about the species than I do.
The end result is we have a unique way to test for bacteria in a variety of applications that at most save lives, or at a minimum vastly improve the quality.
> Their distinctive blue blood is used to detect dangerous Gram-negative bacteria such as E. coli in injectable drugs such as insulin, implantable medical devices such as knee replacements, and hospital instruments such as scalpels and IVs.
- goldenkey 10y agoAt least kill the f'kin things if you are gonna drain them of their blood. Seems like its just a poor excuse to say 'we didnt kill them..they are just fine! *drops crab back into water with half of its blood supply' Based on what I read, these crabs are basically given a death sentence. I'd rather them be killed and harvested than bloodsucked tortured and thrown back into a predator ecosystem where they are too delirious and pretty much get butchered by whatever's out there.
- dmix 10y agoThat's a fair concern. This is why studying it is important. The scientists made some assumptions that the blood would regenerate and they would likely be fine. So agreed it's good they did this and they should find a way to do it more humanely, if possible. > The International Union for Conservation of Nature, which sets global standards for species extinction, created a horseshoe crab subcommittee in 2012 to monitor the issue. The group decided last year that the American horseshoe crab is "vulnerable" to extinction—a higher level of danger compared to the last Red List assessment in 1996. An artificial replacement might be the only long term solution. Or mass breeding, if it is indeed so expensive. > And then there's the pure damn necessity. While several companies have come up with synthetic alternatives for detecting the presence of endotoxins in vaccines, medicine, and medical instruments, LAL is still the only test that has received FDA approval.
- openasocket 10y agoIt isn't a death sentence: the overwhelming majority survive, and even go through the process again. If they killed them outright the species would go extinct. Of those two options, this is the environmentally friendly one.
- goldenkey 10y agoDid you read the article? The overwhelming majority die when released back into the ocean after being bloodsucked.
- poizan42 10y agoDid you read it? > And evidence is accumulating that the death rate of bled horseshoe crabs is much higher (more like 29 percent versus 15 percent) You do understand that a majority means more than 50% right? So 29 percent is not a majority, and certainly not an overwhelming majority
- logicallee 10y agowhile you're at math, one thing to note is that if the same crab is caught 4 times, with a 29% chance of dying each time, then the chances that they are still alive is (1-0.29)^4 which is about 25%. And the chance that they are dead is 75%. Granted I don't know how often crabs are re-caught, or if they would have the same chance of dying each time.
- novia 10y agoSeems like they should require the industry to mark crabs that have been caught with something that would last long enough to allow them to regenerate their blood supply.
- logicallee 10y agoBut even if we assume that if they survive they regenerate 100% so they're at the level as though they had never been caught, still, repeating the same 29% risk of dying four times results in an overall 75% chance of dying. (As calculated above.) If you don't want the population to deplete over time you have to make sure they are repopulating faster than this. (Assuming you accept the deaths to begin with.)
- poizan42 10y agoIt is not known for sure what the mortality rate is after draining them, but the worst estimate seems to be 30%, so not at all a death sentence
- martalist 10y agoIf it's a question of the level of intelligence of the sentient being be exploited in relation to the perpetrating species, precisely at what point would it be ok for a sufficiently intellectually superior alien species to exploit humans for their benefit?
- interfixus 10y agoWe differentiate treatment by intelligence of species for a good reason No we don't. We keep dogs, we* kill pigs and eat them. *) 'We' meaning a generalised 'you'. I don't.
- nojvek 10y agoThere's a great book called Homodeus they goes in depth about this for a chapter Basically it's come down to humans deciding the fate of so many animals. We keep our cows and pigs in very narrow places and just enough systems for their survival but no regard for their emotional needs. Because we are the dominant spicies we act according to our selfish interests. A smarter intelligent spices will probably do the same. If we somehow end up being useful for them, our fate might be the same as chickens, pigs and cows.
- literallycancer 10y agoYes, of course. I have extremely strong preference for a world where other humans will cause suffering and/or death of non-human life, if necessary, to cure me of a disease or improve my quality of life. Therefore, I support such measures to help any other humans, hoping that they would do the same for me. It's self preservation, plain and simple. Non-human life is useful and worthwhile only insofar as it improves human life. As it happens, that includes, some would say luckily, trying to preserve a whole lot of lifeforms because we don't yet know whether they will be needed in the future. I can't find any reason to consider this immoral or wrong in any way. I think it's beyond morality - merely an inevitable side-effect of existence.
- interfixus 10y agoOut of honest curiosity: What is your take on human life, then? A sittuation, let's say, where I cause you suffering in order to improve the quality of my life? Or vice versa?
- literallycancer 10y ago
- ZeroFries 10y agoThe metric shouldn't be intelligence, but ability to suffer (which intelligence affects).