43 ms·
The reason these things aren't discussed is because they shouldn't have to be discussed. > their formative years of the internet happened when the entire Inter
by kuschku 10y ago
The reason these things aren't discussed is because they shouldn't have to be discussed.
> their formative years of the internet happened when the entire Internet was sponsored by the government and universities. So to them, it just seems like today's problem can be solved with "technology".
As it should be.
The internet mirrors our reality, and our reality mirrors the internet. If we let corporations control either, we've already lost. We have to ensure all data is owned by the people, or cooperatives, governments, etc they formed democratically.
If we let corporations control data, and access to it, and use it, then we have already lost.
I'll mention at this point Bundesdatenschutzgesetz §34, allowing a user to get the canonical representation of all data stored about them from any entity that has data on them, plus a list of all entities they gave data about the user to, plus info what data they gave to which entity, plus all data derived from this users data (including probabilistic models trained from the user's behaviour or choices, for example models for credit scores).
- jasode 10y ago>The reason these things aren't discussed is because they shouldn't have to be discussed. Whether one chooses to analyze the economics or ignore it, the fabric of monetary incentives is always there because harddrives and bandwidth are not $0.00. Even ephemeral things like "trust" and "reputation" are not zero cost to implement. Maintenance tasks such as "software installs" and "upgrades" are also not free. If those costs (which are never specified -- and can't be specified) in the technical protocols are not mentally accounted for, it will seem like "centralization" is some weird illogical phenomenon. One would incorrectly believe that the masses haven't adopted distributed protocol stacks like IPFS, sandstorm.io, Diaspora, GNUSocial etc because the "technology" is a problem. If you focus on technology like that, you'll just end up inventing another distributed protocol that non-geeks will not use. Put another way, you can write a paper specification that such & such protocol is designed for decentralized deployment. You can also draw out an architecture diagram that illustrates how peer-2-peer nodes can be federated, etc. However, all those intentions still have to be executed in the real world and the real world costs money. That is why decentralized protocols/tools like SMTP and Git coalesce into centralized entities like Gmail/Hotmail and Github. E.g. the Git specification about BLOBs, sha1 hashes, etc does not include a free $10/month VPS server. Therefore, if I want to post a public repo without having to use my credit-card to pay for bandwidth, I can just put it on Github. Thousands of people making that similar economic decision leads to a centralized Github.
- kuschku 10y agoBut this can not be solved. The only way to solve this is having a rich entity subsidize it. And those can only be either companies trying to abuse your data for their own profit, corporate and noncorporate entities that try to do good (foundations, NGOs, etc), universities, or governments. That's why I said what I said. The web can only work if we get rid of the corporations, or massively regulate them while subsidizing the independent projects. That’s why the Prototype Fund exists https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12200777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12200777, why the German government has previously funded GPG, why the German government and the EU have funded work on KDE several times https://www.cnet.com/news/germany-funded-linux-software-arriving/ https://www.cnet.com/news/germany-funded-linux-software-arri..., why universities fund open source work often, etc.