6 ms·
The Command-And-Control Mindset Is Killing Companies
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoStruggling with this one a bit. "The outcome of Gallup’s study clearly shows the strong correlation between employee engagement and business performance. " Good, the author says it's a correlation. But the supporting graphic is titled: "Employee engagement affects key business outcomes" Which implies causality. I can easily image a company that runs through early success, growth and profitability and the sense of prestige that would bring to the employees. Absenteeism, accidents, defects could be low because employees are engaged: They are winning in the market, everyone's getting bonuses, their acquaintances say, 'oh, wow!' when they mention where they are working. Then, turn that company down, with the same employees, and you'd have the opposite effect. A scandal such as a LendingClub, Uber, Theranos, that changes the fortune suddenly, over night, with the same employee base, and I'd not be surprised if absenteeism, accidents and defects surged. In that scenario, it's business performance affecting employee engagement.
- mattzito 10y agoI share some of your concerns about the article, though the one quibble I'd have: > In that scenario, it's business performance affecting employee engagement. All of the examples that you gave aren't really business performance, they all represent some combination of fraud or terrible behavior. Sure, it could be fraud hiding negative business results, but the fundamental issues in all of those are managerial misbehavior.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoYou are correct. I was looking for a stark contrast in business performance that would be assured of having the same employee base. I think it is still true in companies where the business has run its course and sales are declining over time that the business performance can reduce engagement. The more time that passes, the more employee turnover and it's therefore less direct in causation.
- candiodari 10y agoThe bottom of the article, and About - Team tells you all you need to know. "If you’re interested to learn more about how to reach The Promised Land, don’t hesitate to contact us for an inspiring talk, rebellious workshop, or practical support during your organization’s transformation." These are management consultants. Their statistics are about as good as those from psychologists, except they are usually directly paid for getting particular outcomes with their statistics. In this case, their case is that there is a major problem in every organisation ! And they can help ! For $xxxxx they'll "solve this problem" (with a one-time talk about it, in case you were wondering), and for $xxxxxx they'll give a workshop, which will surely allow any manager to prove to his director how engaged he is, while (hardly worth mentioning, really) also allowing him to go home earlier for a whole week and probably get a free, really fancy, dinner or two. Keep this in mind when judging the value of what they're saying. Of course, I do think they have a point, but they're part of the problem, not the solution. There was a survey I read which asked the question "would you prevent your employer from gaining a million dollar in profit if you personally got $500 out of it ?". Apparently 86% would, and a further 10% was undecided.
- brianwawok 10y ago> There was a survey I read which asked the question "would you prevent your employer from gaining a million dollar in profit if you personally got $500 out of it ?". Apparently 86% would, and a further 10% was undecided. Hah citation? I wonder what that survey would look like with a strong profit sharing setup?
- TuringNYC 10y agoI good example of Management Consulting efficacy is the observation on how some well-respected consultancies have been failing businesses. DiamondCluster and A.T. Kearney would be at the top of the list, though dated examples from my consulting days. If they offer such good strategy, why is their company doing so poorly? I once asked some outright, they explained that they are so busy helping clients they don't have any time to help themselves.
- douche 10y ago
- jt2190 10y agoI'm curious if the European context of corporate "command and control" differs from the North American one. (edit: The authors are European. edit 2: I've heard anecdotes that European labor laws make management more "strict" with workers.) I also wonder if the profession and industry make a huge difference. In my limited experience in North America as a software developer, there has been little "command and control", and far more "chaos", i.e. the businesses didn't seem to have any kind of control over their software development, and would tolerate a surprisingly low amount of predictability. This was almost always because non-technical types were in charge. (edit: Non-technical types often view software management as intractable, and tend to utilize vague approaches like "we'll ship something on this date".)
- dasil003 10y agoBeing a startup guy I come from the opposite side: one of the biggest challenges I've faced in growing startups is alignment. When you're 5 people in a room you can just kind of shout out what you're doing and everything is cool. When you get to 50 this leads to a lot of redundant effort and toe-stepping. If the culture is not evolved by 500 there's very little strategic direction at all. I agree about the engagement part, but given that I've always worked in places where people were highly engaged, the next challenge is how to direct that engagement towards a common vision and purpose with efficient execution.
- blizkreeg 10y agoI've been thinking of and recently started working on this exact problem most companies that cross the 40-50 person mark face. Can we get coffee sometime? I'd love to exchange thoughts and ideas and just learn your perspective as well. I'm in SF (moving to Oakland soon - looked up your twitter).
- mr_tristan 10y agoYeah, leading 500 is a pretty different animal then 50. New hires are probably not going to expect to be "changing the course" and more focused on stepping in and keeping it. Turns of phrase from the leadership can frequently bewilder people unintentionally.
- fiatjaf 10y agoWhy do you have to go past the 50? Or even past the 5 people in the room? Isn't it just better to keep companies small? Maybe have/work on multiple companies, have companies interact better with other ones so they can accomplish more, but keep them smaller.
- brudgers 10y agoIn the connotation of 'startup' used in Silicon Valley and among venture capitalists (as opposed to how 'startup' is used in other places and/or by other types of investors), a startup is a company designed and striving to grow to a large size. In that context, startups are a well defined subset of new businesses.
- sobinator 10y agoI agree with the sentiment, but let's be honest with ourselves; there aren't that many type-A people bumping around in most organizations whose talents are going untapped. Regardless, Engagement, in my view, is like a double-edged sword--it cuts both ways. On one hand, getting employees to "pull the wagon" can immensely add value to the organization. On the other hand, employees attaching too much of their self-worth to their work (a consequence of being highly engaged) can lead to employees' egos being of greater importance than the results. Low engagement is probably just a symptom of some other organizational ill.
- bediger4000 10y agoI'm going to suggest that in my experience with both smaller and larger companies, management (from those managing grunts to C-level) have more of what they consider fun in a low-engagement company, and the low employee engagement is a symptom of management having their version of fun.
- isostatic 10y agoWe should just use Shift and Option
- twic 10y agoShift yourself to a new job where you get options! Or if you can't find an opportunity like that, some kind of meta escape?
- Asooka 10y agoHow about lowering CEO pay by about 90% and distributing that to employees, i.e. paying a fair wage adjusted for gains in productivity?
- bskap 10y agoIf you lowered the CEO of McDonalds's pay by 90% and distributed it to all the employees, they'd get less than $20 each. It doesn't exactly bump them up to a living wage.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoCompanies like Toyota have long understood that a more democratic workplace leads to better outcomes overall. But the reality is, barring a major cultural change or wide-scale labor organization, this kind of management system will never take hold in America. We're a fundamentally authoritarian society who organizes all our systems like their mini-fiefdoms. I've never understood why a society that prides itself so much on its tradition of democracy would build within itself an economy of autocratic rulers, but I guess these kind of contradictions are as much a part of our culture as anything else.
- baursak 10y agoLack of "employee engagement" is not a new insight by far. It's just that implications of what it takes to address the root cause of it go down quite a deep rabbit hole. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation
- shouldbworking 10y agoThis sounds great and all, but I've seen corporate rebels and how often they get fired. The most dangerous thing you can do at most companies is to disagree with your boss and be right. I was a rebel myself until I realized the risks. The safe path to promotion is sucking up to the level of management right above your manager. Always show up early, look nice and busy, and make sure you're always presenting at meetings. The true rebels will be seen contracting or running their own businesses. Or defeated and working in the dark corners of the corporate world just waiting for the day they can escape, real or imagined.
- iamacynic 10y agooftentimes in companies, a consultant will be brought in to create controlled rebellion - a consultant is basically a mercenary who will operate at the direction of one of the bosses inside the company, and the results of the consulting or research/development efforts can be discussed in terms of political strategy as well as actual results. of course, the trade-off for being a consultant is that you're very well compensated but can be fired for any reason, or no reason at all, without any of the legal protections afforded an employee. this is a business model for management consulting firms but i've seen plenty of smaller outfits or individuals do this as well.
- known 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triarchy_%28theory%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triarchy_%28theory%29 promotes thinking out of the box
- leroy_masochist 10y agoI don't think the authors understand the term "command and control" as it is traditionally used. I'd infer from this article that they believe it means, "provide overly detailed instructions, then micromanage". In fact it's a military term of art describing how to manage large teams in a chaotic environment in which leaders never have all the information they'd like (e.g., combat). The "command" part is leaders telling the people who work for them what end state they need them to achieve -- not only at the outset of the mission, but periodically throughout operations as the situation changes. The "control" part is subordinate units/leaders providing real-time feedback. This might be something like, "we are carrying out the mission as planned" or it might be, "hey you told me to stay on the north side of the river but I need to cross it to accomplish the mission"; importantly, deviation from coordinating instructions in accomplishing the mission is a key feature of the mission orders-based warfighting doctrine currently in place in most major militaries. In the words of US doctrine (which uses the common abbreviation for command and control): > C2 is not a one-way, top-down process that imposes control on subordinates. C2 is multidirectional, with feedback influencing commanders from below, from above, and laterally.[0] 0: http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/policy/army/fm/6-0/chap1.htm http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/policy/army/f...
- jlarocco 10y agoI don't know if I agree that employee engagement is a great thing to optimize. I feel like engagement is a side effect of wanting to get work done. If I focus and engage and double my productivity, I don't get to spend half as much time at work, instead I get twice as much work. If I double my productivity and double my amount of work, I'm still not going to double my salary or double my PTO or anything like that. Not to mention that most corporations have no problem whatsoever laying people off when it'll save them enough money. "Sorry you dedicated 80 hours a week and weekends to this project, but the economy's bad so we're canceling it and laying off your division. Oh, and BTW if you try to work on something similar after we lay you off, we'll sue you. Bye." I think many people have realized at this point that corporations have very little respect for their employees and that spending significant mental energy being super engaged and efficient has mostly negative consequences (at most companies). I bet a company could improve productivity quite a bit if they let employees take the rest of the week off once they finished the week's work. But that would require management to have an understanding of the work being done and to plan well, so it won't happen.
- trhway 10y agosounds like the companies who get your soul in addition to your brain do better.
- Animats 10y agoThe graph showing that companies rated highly by Glassdoor outperform the S&P 500 by a factor of 2.4 is significant. Is there a fund which invests that way? Vanguard should have a Glassdoor Index Fund.
- justin66 10y agoWith that kind of money at stake, you could expect the integrity of Glassdoor reviews to tank pretty quickly.
- tjalfi 10y agoThe Parnassus Endeavour fund (https://www.parnassus.com/parnassus-mutual-funds/endeavor/investor-shares/ https://www.parnassus.com/parnassus-mutual-funds/endeavor/in...) is partially based on employee satisfaction. Here is an excerpt from an interview [0] with the portfolio manager. John Rotonti: How do you define a high-quality business? Jerome Dodson: Parnassus Investments defines high-quality companies as those with competitive advantages, quality management, and responsible business practices. I believe a high-quality workplace is one of the indicators of company quality. That's why the Endeavor Fund, which was originally named the Workplace Fund, focuses on investing in good workplaces. [0] (https://www.fool.com/investing/2016/12/19/interview-with-jerome-dodson-of-parnassus-investme.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/2016/12/19/interview-with-jer...)
- sgt101 10y agoThe engagement meme is a nightmare. 1) Measure engagement - surveys, more surveys. Targets for managers of the surveyed, dismissal, removal of bonus. Survey manipulated, rendered political tool. Lieing all round. Disaster. 2) Targeting of dissent. "we've finished debating, now we're executing" "boss, there's a brick wall" "you're fired" "oh" "bang" "oh". Anyone who disagrees or complains about some aspect of central function in anyway it immediately branded disengaged and targetted for removal. Here's a rule. No one can practices management consulting unless they have worked at a fortune 500 for 30 years. Here's another one. No one can have a chair at a business school unless they've worked in the C suite of a fortune 500 for 30 years. This would cut this rubbish right out.
- mnm1 10y agoWhat a fluff piece. It makes no points whatsoever, just pretends like it can make janitorial, secretarial, and waitering work fun and exciting but doesn't offer a single idea on how they plan to do so (because it's impossible). Talk about delusional! This reads like an ad because it is. No content whatsoever.
- microtherion 10y ago"Organizations like Kodak, Blackberry, Motorola, Lehman Brothers and Enron are but a few of the many companies that became overly comfortable and lost their battle." This can be argued for the first three of these, but Lehman and especially Enron were slaughtered by the relentless pursuit of (financial) innovation and absence of effective control.