5 ms·
Next
- Apocryphon 10y agoRegarding the civic engagements point, isn't that what Brigade is trying to do? (http://nationswell.com/brigade-voter-network-for-politically-minded/ http://nationswell.com/brigade-voter-network-for-politically...)
- reustle 10y agoCould this title (currently "Next") be classified as clickbait? I'm on the fence.
- scribu 10y agoNot sure about being clickbait, but it's definitely not informative. My suggestion, after reading it: "From Software To Permaculture"
- ranit 10y ago> "From Software To Permaculture" You might have missed the last part of the blog-post.
- throwanem 10y agoNo. Clickbait is overblown and vaguely deceptive titles, not short and cryptic ones. Based on the title and the domain name, and on zero prior familiarity with the writer, I figured it for one of those "we're moving on/what an amazing trip it's been/next stage in our journey" Valley-style bankruptcy announcements. In a cockeyed way, that's actually more or less what it is.
- foobarchu 10y agoClickbait is a headline that gives you all the information except one key part, along the lines of "thing happened, you'll never guess end result". It literally baits you into clicking by giving you just enough to make you want more, taking advantage of human psychology to maximize headline efficiency. Almost like a more refined version of soundbites. This headline is just undescriptive. It's not baiting anyone, though, it's just what the author felt was the most applicable title.
- zellyn 10y agoI saw "Next" and figured it was a company or individual blogging about their next move. Which it was. Seems fine.
- coldtea 10y agoLet's put it this way: posts are not made for you. They are not created for HN either. The author can use whatever title they want. They can make it funny, suspenseful, etc. Maybe stick with "clickbait" where it originated and applies: to online media (especially news/gossip etc websites) making money off eyeballs, instead of some random person's blog?
- lemming 10y agoSeveral things in this article resonated with me. One of the great things about our industry is that most of us do have a choice, as long as you're willing to leave some money on the table. Advertising, finance or commerce will always pay more than advancing the state of science, or other noble goals. What happened to the idea of building great stuff that people are happy to pay for? I'm very happily doing this now, making developer tools. My users are very happy to pay for the software I build, and I find building it very satisfying. I'm lucky, but it's not like I'm some super-developer - I'm good at what I do, but so are most people here. I'm lucky with my circumstances, but I think I'd be doing something like this even if my circumstances were different. Since I've lately been more concerned than previously about climate change, I'm now investigating how I can help with that, despite having no background in physical sciences. In my case, tooling for scientists is an obvious option, but Bret has more ideas: http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange.
- crusso 10y agoWhat happened to the idea of building great stuff that people are happy to pay for? What happened to the idea of treating employees as people and not legal entities to extort? Having owned and run my own service-oriented business that employed a few people: For many of your customers and many of your employees, the naive and sunny approach works great. You can provide great service and have happy customers willing to pay you. You can have employees who are really friends just helping you to provide that great service with whom you split the proceeds. You can treat those customers and employees like everyday people. All is wonderful. Then you come across the bad apples. You come across the customers here and there who don't want to pay you for great service, they want it for free. Even worse are the customers for whom you provide great service, but they want you to pay for some imagined problem that you caused for them because their expectations for your service were completely different than what you clearly provide. Then on the employee side, there are those employees who thought that just because I started the business that I was somehow wealthy and living the high life. They didn't appreciate the year that I went without a salary or the risk that entailed. They didn't appreciate that I was overall making much less money than I could have if I had just gotten a regular day job. They didn't care about the loans with my name on them that would ruin my finances if the business went south. When you come across a few of those bad apples, that's when all the rules and lawyers come into place. Your nirvana of work and customer environment can turn to crap if you don't have a little protection against the jerks. The phrase "this is why we can't have nice things" surfaces time and again in the face of those 1 in 20 sociopaths who interact with you as a business owner.
- bshimmin 10y agoThe really depressing thing is that this applies to all walks of life - landlords and tenants, estate agents, even recruiters. From my own experience of running a micro-agency, the "1 in 20 sociopaths" rule absolutely applies. I had three or four joyous years where I had nothing but satisfied customers who were happy to pay (not, it must be said, in a particularly timely fashion for the most part, but they paid without griping, which is the main thing); sometimes they were demanding and wanted an awful lot for very little money, but even in the worst cases, we got there in the end, and the relationships were good enough that they persisted regardless (and a lot of the time, the really great clients - who were not demanding and paid well - balanced out the other ones, so it all seemed good enough on the whole). Then I had two awful clients in the space of three months - we did exactly what we always did, but they were, to be frank, just terrible people who didn't want to be helped, demanded the impossible, and then refused to pay when - unsurprisingly - we failed to deliver; with one, we ended up splitting the bill, and the other remains a bitter ongoing dispute. (There were actually useful lessons to be learnt in both cases, so every cloud...) Speaking to other people in a similar situation to me, the consensus is that I was just incredibly lucky for those halcyon years where it all just worked: one guy in particular said that his general expectation, based on his experience, is that at least one client will try to screw him every year; another guy I know builds a remote kill-switch into everything he delivers for precisely that reason (which I have always thought is horribly unprofessional and unethical, but I can now at least see where he's coming from). Many people are good; a surprisingly large proportion of people will, even if they are good, try to get away with as much as they can regardless; and some people are just very, very bad.
- ranit 10y agoI admire the author's motivations and effort. Very well written indeed. Just one thing: > There’s also the unfortunate culture in technology that devalues everything unrelated to militant capitalism. Please don't forget the myriad open-source contributors. I don't think the culture in technology devalues them ... although do not appreciate enough.
- coldtea 10y ago>I don't think the culture in technology devalues them ... Why would it? They provide for free (or close) 90% of the infrastructure everybody uses to make money. The companies are glad those suckers exist -- but of course wont pitch in, except rarely...
- twic 10y ago> There’s also the unfortunate culture in technology that devalues everything unrelated to militant capitalism. > To work or participate in the technology industry is an exercise in minimizing manipulation (or, if you’d like to be rich, maximizing it). This feels shitty in a tremendously heavy way. I wonder if Kyle has considered working somewhere that isn't Silicon Valley. I'm in London, and i don't recognise this description in the companies i worked with in my last few years of consulting, or interviewed with when i got out of it. I doubt very much that London is any kind of shangri-la of corporate enlightenment, so i would guess it's like that in most places.
- mxuribe 10y agoVery inspirational!
- optimuspaul 10y agoI'm probably reading too much or not enough into this but this left a bad taste in my mouth. It stuck me as the rantings of a hermit, disconnected from reality, ranting about "end of the times" and things "have to change." A lot of people are doing the things proposed in many different ways, but this is written in a way that completely discounts their efforts. I would have preferred to read about someone connecting with some of these efforts other than the "out of touch" zealot on a soapbox.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoThe "end of times" is very real. The only permanent thing is change, right? This time is coming to a close, and a new one is beginning. And it is reasonable to think certain things "have to change". Unconscionable violence is everywhere. Many of us see it and continue to do our jobs, but have lost faith in our social structures. We are still here, but our bags are packed ready to try something else when the time comes. In the African/American community (to the extent there is such a thing) there has been an understanding for some time that "a change is gonna come". A lot of us still anticipate that and I don't think think that's out of touch with reality. We know it will be a struggle to get there, but that doesn't mean we're not going. And one last point, on hermits and reality... Many of the tools you rely on were built by hermits out of touch with "reality". Node.js was built by Ryan Dahl, who thought a browser engine could be used to power I/O bound servers. Linux was built by a guy who thought he'd just turn a student OS into a production environment in his spare time. I heard Heroku's routing layer got built when Orion Henry disappeared into the woods with it for a month. His job title was "Mad Scientist". These are not normal, plugged in people. But they have an important and very real connection to reality.
- optimuspaul 10y agoI guess my point was completely missed. I meant only to say that maybe the message could have been more positive and highlighted solutions and how people are already trying to affect real change for the better and not just ready for when someone else does something. I don't think it fair to say that Linus or Ryan where Hermits or out of tech with reality. They saw an opportunity and acted. Let's be solution based, not problem based.
- jaclaz 10y agoIt is a bit "Waldeninsh", but I did enjoy reading it, very interesting points, about life and computing, about the latter I appreciated the doubt expressed in: >It feels as though we’ve embraced the cloud a little too much the past decade or so.