4 ms·
Is it though? DVD players conform to region code requirements. Edit to add: I think people like me, who aren't content creators (not to any degree that anyone
by TheSpiceIsLife 10y ago
Is it though? DVD players conform to region code requirements.
Edit to add: I think people like me, who aren't content creators (not to any degree that anyone should care about), need to be careful about telling people who are content creators what they should and shouldn't be allowed to do to protect their content.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoThey can do anything they like to protect their content, at their own expense. Again, that's an entirely different thing from trying to force a third party (who is receiving neither money nor the benefit of viewing the content) from going out of their way to enforce those protections (especially if it reduces the usefulness of their own product).
- eastWestMath 10y agoThere's a big difference between "we have a good relationship so I'll do X" and forcing third parties to enforce those protections. Those content provides aren't required to distribute their product and once a proper framework is set up for their situation there's no reason other people can't use it.
- aviraldg 10y agoContent creators should feel free to do as they please with their content. I, however, as a technologist am saying I will not do anything to help them build software that limits others freedoms, will encourage others not to do so as well, and to whatever degree possible, boycott them and those who help them. I do believe in licensing though, so your comment motivated me to add a (permissive) license to my website. That's the only good use for it.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoThat's a fair enough opinion to have. There was a time I believed something similar too, until I realised I haven't created anything worth protecting, so who am I to have an opinion on protecting content.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y ago> so who am I to have an opinion on protecting content. How does it make even the slightest sense to allow only those who profit from a norm to have an opinion on it? You've never owned a big chemical plant, so who are you to have an opinion on protecting chemical plants from environmental regulation? You've never had an income over 100 million, so who are you to have an opinion on how that income should be taxed? You've never had slaves, so who are you to have an opinion on protecting the property rights of slave owners?
- Silhouette 10y agoYou've never owned a big chemical plant, so who are you to have an opinion on protecting chemical plants from environmental regulation? Unless everyone is living on a different planet, some people will necessarily be affected by the consequences of the chemical plant's operations. Looking out for those people is reasonable. You've never had an income over 100 million, so who are you to have an opinion on how that income should be taxed? That's a different and actually quite a good question, from an ethical point of view. Answering it without resorting to arguments based on either greed or envy is surprisingly difficult, and almost certainly requires some exploration of both economics and philosophical views on the nature of modern society. You've never had slaves, so who are you to have an opinion on protecting the property rights of slave owners? That's more like the first question. The slaves are necessarily affected by that arrangement, and again looking out for them is reasonable. Given that in the sort of cases we're talking about probably no-one needs to have access to any given content, the situation we're considering is actually closer to your second example than your first and third. And I'm not sure exploring the economics of content creation more thoroughly rather than making a superficial analysis is going to lead to the conclusions you want it to.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y ago> That's a different and actually quite a good question, from an ethical point of view. Answering it without resorting to arguments based on either greed or envy is surprisingly difficult, and almost certainly requires some exploration of both economics and philosophical views on the nature of modern society. It's actually not that hard: The concept of property itself is a social construct, so without a social norm that establishes property, you having an income of 200 million doesn't mean anything. If you simply claim ownership of something, but noone agrees with you, then you don't actually own it. If society grants you the advantages of this norm and enforces it for you, it's just as valid to partially revoke it where that is to the advantage of society at large. It would be completely arbitrary to say that everyone is obligated to help enforcing a norm that's to their own disadvantage and they should not have any say in it because the person profiting from it says so. > Given that in the sort of cases we're talking about probably no-one needs to have access to any given content, the situation we're considering is actually closer to your second example than your first and third. What does "need" mean? Does a slave need freedom? Or is that just a preference? Is the ability to save and replay information sources under your own control (and as is explicitly exempted from copyright restrictions in quite a few places) just a luxury in a democracy? Does a human need participation in culture? In any case, you presenting those arguments already contradicts the idea that you only should be allowed to have an opinion on a norm if you profit from it. > And I'm not sure exploring the economics of content creation more thoroughly rather than making a superficial analysis is going to lead to the conclusions you want it to. What conclusion do I want it to lead to?
- dasmoth 10y agoIs it though? DVD players conform to region code requirements. And at the time DVDs were launched, many in hacker/geek/whatever circles were pretty horrified by this development. To me, it's more than a little alarming how rapidly we've normalised the idea that end users' devices should be obeying the wishes of content publishers rather than their owners.
- isostatic 10y agoOf course many DVD players could be region unlocked, so people didn't complain too much. Same with libdvdcss. Even in the vhs days, ntsc v pal, and the lack of international awareness that was common pre internet, provided region locking of a sort.
- syshum 10y agolibdvdcss is also consider to be illegal for distribution in the US as it is circumvention tool in violation of DMCA It is a legal gray area if a individual who obtains libdvdcss breaks the law by using it, however no software vendor can include it if they are a US Company This is why VLC, Handbrake, and many other organizations that distribute it are very very clear they are not US Organizations and exist outside the Jurisdiction of US Courts
- Silhouette 10y agoAnd at the time DVDs were launched, many in hacker/geek/whatever circles were pretty horrified by this development. And yet right here in this HN discussion there are numerous people openly defying the current legal and technological position, which is just going to promote more and stronger technical measures to limit how content can be consumed. For example, it's already hard to just buy a permanent copy of a lot of TV shows on disc any more. They're moving to online, streaming-only channels where it's harder to copy, and that's reducing choice even for legitimate paying customers. To me, it's more than a little alarming how rapidly we've normalised the idea that end users' devices should be obeying the wishes of content publishers rather than their owners. I agree, but it's also more than a little alarming how rapidly we've normalised knowingly breaking the law and/or explicit agreements with other parties and totally ignoring economics just because something is technically possible. In what other circumstances would it be OK to make an explicit deal with someone, then totally renege on that deal and just say "Well, I don't think you really deserved what we agreed anyway"? In what other circumstances would it be OK to knowingly break the law to someone else's cost and in the expectation of suffering no adverse consequences and just say "Well, I don't think this law is a good law so I'm not going to follow it"? The everything-should-be-free culture of Generation Me isn't sustainable. Maybe the laws and economic models we're using today aren't the best way forward, but that doesn't mean we should support or condone totally ignoring them until we've got a better idea.
- slrz 10y agoThe implementation of region code silliness is enforced by only licensing CSS/DRM-relevant patents to hardware vendors that agree to restrict their customers in that way. That's one of the reasons the industry insists on DRM technologies, even if broken, and tries to encumber them with as many patents as possible. It allows them to exercise control over the end-user experience.