10 ms·
Arturo Di Modica has a point
- Prego 10y agoJust like Ghostbusters, women ruin art.
- CalChris 10y agoExactly how large of a safe space does Di Modica need for his art?
- StavrosK 10y agoHow large of a safe space would the creator of the Fearless Girl need if someone installed a statue of a table with a butcher's implements, or a bullfighter's swords, in front of her statue?
- steanne 10y agoin order for his meaning to have been co-opted, he would have had to be communicating it in the first place. he says it's "the strength and power fo the american people", but i always saw pursuit of a financial goal without concern for collateral damage, like a bull in a china shop.
- ACow_Adonis 10y agoIndeed. I too found it kinda funny, since I'd always interpreted that particular sculpture as a symbol of the damage done when bankers and finance types get out of control. I actually thought it was a reproduction of photos of the running of the bulls. Specifically, that moment in time where the fool in front and the bull both go round a corner. The bull tries to turn on the cobble stones of pamplona, but as a result, its hoofs begin to slide out from underneath it, and you tend to get photos like this one: http://theday.co.uk/images/stories/2012/2012-07/2012-07-10_bullrun.jpg http://theday.co.uk/images/stories/2012/2012-07/2012-07-10_b... Which is to say, the bull (market) has gotten out of control, and that statue represents the classical view you see of a bull that gotten out of control in the split second before everyone gets really hurt. Honestly, i like my interpretation better :P
- Para2016 10y agoI like it! That's the exact stance. Thanks for sharing
- dnautics 10y agoI didn't know that Di Modica still owns it. I suppose if he disagreed with what SHE has done, he could simply arrange to have the bull point the other way.
- jbmorgado 10y agoIt's a question of principle. Just because Picasso (or some living author if you prefer for the example) doesn't own one of his paintings anymore, it's not artistically acceptable (arguably even culturally acceptable) for the owner of the painting to go there and just paint something over it that totally changes the meaning of the original painting. Just because you are legally entitled to do something, it doesn't mean you should do something. As a recent example, just look at the United Airlines example for instance.
- dnautics 10y agoHave you been to the site? Pointing the bull the other way wouldn't affect the artistic expression. Most people wouldn't even notice. On the other hand it might be tacit acknowledgement of the power of the other statue.
- jbmorgado 10y agoPointing the bull the other way would make it look like it was running away from the girl. How is that not changing its artistic meaning?
- voidz 10y agoIt makes it look like the girl is taunting the bull. Which is exactly what is happening. To me it represents a symbol in the war against men.
- Sacho 10y agoWhich power is that, that corporations are good at advertising themselves by playing to our emotional biases? I believe that was established before this arrangement.
- StavrosK 10y agoWouldn't everything be solved by simply turning the bull to face in a different direction?
- jbmorgado 10y agoAnd why not solve it by turning the girl to face in a different direction?
- StavrosK 10y agoBecause the girl is facing exactly where the creator meant it to be facing.
- jbmorgado 10y agoWhich if the bull turned away it wouldn't anymore. So the difference in the end would be just who has to turn: - The statue that is there for decades. - The statue that is there for less than one year. If people where not doing this about (what they think in their heads is) some politically correct argument but about art (which is the point of the author of the article) than the answer would be obvious.
- icebraining 10y agoInteresting. I'm actually ambiguous on the political perspective, but I fully disagree that the answer is obvious. Why should longevity protect a work of art from being subverted? On the contrary; to paraphrase Stroustrup, I'd say there are only two kinds of monuments: the ones that have been subverted and the ones nobody cares about. Fighting that is tilting at windmills.
- StavrosK 10y agoI don't know, if you wrote a sentence saying "America is great" and someone came and appended "but women aren't afraid of it", that would change your sentence in ways you didn't intend. It's not longevity that drives you to defend your sentence, but the fact that you didn't intend it to read that way.
- Kenji 10y agoShe looks more like sassy entitled girl imho. So, in this sense, I think the statue is a beautiful display of what is going on. "If you don't like it, you're a sexist."
- atomwaffel 10y agoIt depends on the reasons for your dislike, as the article explains beautifully. If you don't like the statue because you disagree that women should have the same entitlements as men, then you may need to open yourself to the possibility of being called sexist.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- beaconstudios 10y agothat seems like an uncharitable interpretation of Kenji's comment. Perhaps one can dislike the statue because it's a vapid statement, a girl standing up to something that isn't trying to keep her down in the first place. It's not like the bull had become a symbol of women being oppressed - and the fact that the original artwork was genuinely created by a street artist (and immigrant) and the new addition has been created by a multi-billion-dollar firm to attempt to profit from a political trend is telling.
- marvin 10y agoBut if you don't like it because it appropriates the power of declaring someone a sexist in order to undermine the original artist's intent...you're still a sexist! That's the beauty of it. I'm not convinced that this sort of dishonest communication is what's required to give women a more even playing field in business. If that was the commissioners' intent, of which I am also not convinced.
- Kenji 10y agoYes, indeed I do disagree that women should have the same entitlements as men. I think women should have the same rights and opportunities, but not the same entitlements. I think everyone should work for what they've got, thus earning their entitlements. In that sense, I am for as pure a meritocracy as possible. More power to those who are able, irrespective of their (physical) nature. I open myself to the possibility of being called sexist every single day for my opinions, but I know that what I believe is right and fair and has nothing to do with gender.
- shoo 10y agothe appropriate way to settle this debate is more guerilla art
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoAgreed. It's time someone added a bear.
- crawfordcomeaux 10y agoIdeally, the bear would have her head in its mouth. The three pieces would become a single work warning about Wall Street threatening our future.
- Grue3 10y agoThey have both the bull and the bear at Frankfurt-am-Main stock exchange. [1] [1] https://www.frankfurt-tourismus.de/en/Media/Attractions/Bull-and-Bear https://www.frankfurt-tourismus.de/en/Media/Attractions/Bull...
- DonHopkins 10y agoBerlin has bears: https://creamskyeyes.wordpress.com/2013/10/21/bear-hunting-in-berlin/ https://creamskyeyes.wordpress.com/2013/10/21/bear-hunting-i... and cows: http://www.atlasobscura.com/places/dott-return-cows-kuhunst http://www.atlasobscura.com/places/dott-return-cows-kuhunst And Prague has babies: https://www.tonyeveling.com/blog/baby-sculptures-in-prague/ https://www.tonyeveling.com/blog/baby-sculptures-in-prague/ Not to mention giant anuses you can stick your head in, and public urinating sculptures writing text messages with their penises: http://www.boredpanda.com/bizzare-sculptures-by-david-cerny/ http://www.boredpanda.com/bizzare-sculptures-by-david-cerny/ You can climb a ladder and stick your head in the sculpture’s arse to see a video of two Czech politicians feeding each other slop to a soundtrack of "We are the Champions" [...] The idea is disarmingly simple. Two bronze sculptures pee into their oddly-shaped enclosure (Update: actually it’s the shape of the Czech Republic – thanks Cirrat). While they are peeing, the two figures move realistically. An electric mechanism driven by a couple of microprocessors swivels the upper part of the body, while the penis goes up and down. The stream of water writes quotes from famous Prague residents. Visitor can interrupt them by sending SMS message from mobile phone to a number, displayed next to the sculptures. The living statue then "writes" the text of the message, before carrying on as before.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI think the bull, standing alone, is reflective of a bygone era. Maybe some folks want to go back. I certainly never really got the meaning, it was just a bull in a public space. It could have been an elk, an explorer, or something abstract. To me, the girl improved the bull - and the other way around. The bull improves the girl. I don't think it matters what the artists intent was. The public's interpretation changes, and if he'd really like, he can ask for a plaque describing his original intent.
- zamalek 10y agoThat still misses the core point. The reason the intent is important is because the girl is an advertisement. > It could have been an elk, an explorer, or something abstract. So we can hang billboards from the statue of liberty, then?
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoSo this art is advertisement. It isn't like we don't look back and marvel at the glory of old movie posters or anything... Those were advertisements. It doesn't matter if it started as an advert. I'd have been offended if they did shitty art, but in this case, they took care and did an actual piece.
- bambax 10y agoWow, I'm glad I read this! I knew the bull was guerilla art (put there without permission), and I knew (thought) that the girl was, too. And as such I thought it was a brilliant work of appropriation, and should stay. But it turns out the girl is the result of a marketing campaign by a global advertising corporation for a giant investment fund. That changes everything. Companies should not be let to use individual artists' work for their own corporate agenda. That's not right, whatever the message. Di Modica, who still owns the bull, should put it somewhere else -- maybe in a different city.
- narag 10y agoDi Modica, who still owns the bull, should put it somewhere else Doing that could be an even bigger act of subversion than placing the girl there. What would become the meaning of the girl then?
- ludicast 10y agoNot his problem.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- voidz 10y agoHe should turn it around, to make it obvious that the girl is taunting the bull.
- Spooky23 10y agoFollow much of the industry sick of NY nonsense and move it to Jersey City.
- m-j-fox 10y agoI love it. There was an article about how the stock exchange actually lives in a nondescript warehouse-looking data center. Put the bull there.
- 10y ago
- stestagg 10y agoIf someone were to add a board of advisors, makeup crew and branding group just behind the girl, that would make the whole piece perfect, in my opinion
- DonHopkins 10y agoPerhaps if the girl were to offer the bull a Pepsi?
- dqv 10y agoSeeing as the index has shares in Pepsi, that would make sense.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoHe abandoned his work in a public place, therefore he has no ownership claims.
- masklinn 10y ago> It’s been almost thirty years, and Charging Bull is still owned by Di Modica, still on temporary loan to the city, still one of the most recognizable symbols of New York City.
- microcolonel 10y agoMaybe Really Quite Confident Girl could be turned around and placed rather close next to the bull, so that she's not shitting on the very soul of the American people.
- krapp 10y ago>so that she's not shitting on the very soul of the American people. Don't be so melodramatic. No one cares that much about a bull statue, except perhaps Arturo Di Modica.
- true_religion 10y agoWell not no one. The op cares that much. I care a bit too because I always knew the history and intent of the statue thanks to a little Google search I did the first time I saw it.
- Gigablah 10y agoSounds like someone's done a bit of appropriation themselves :p
- true_religion 10y agoHeh, if you mean that I might have gotten my ideas from the article then claimed that I always had it.... Wikipedia has had this link about the Wall Street bull being a celebration of the strength and power of the American people, since 2008. Link to 1989 NY Times Article: http://www.nytimes.com/1989/12/16/nyregion/soho-gift-to-wall-st-a-3-1-2-ton-bronze-bull.html http://www.nytimes.com/1989/12/16/nyregion/soho-gift-to-wall... Link to old wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Charging_Bull&oldid=227139317 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Charging_Bull&old... The guy really hasn't made a secret about his artistic intent, he handed out fliers about it and probably likes mentioning it in every interview.
- SFJulie 10y agoIsn't the bull also the symbol of a impoverishment of workers? In financial jargon: Bulls are peoples betting in growth saying buy, and betting on more dividends given to share holders vs work costs. Bears are the one selling. (Bad news too to be honest, but more for share holders than workers) A long trend in bullish behaviour is related to the richs getting richers. Since it is in the financial district and they were pissed, it looks indeed the girl can be seen as a counter guerilla meaning finance is a symbol of countering the excess of finance. Which, if it were the meaning would be kind of a strong alteration of one of the meaning of the oeuvre. Knowing that among the undeniable moral right of the author there is right to prevent distortion, mutilation, or modification that would prejudice the author's honor or reputation, the guy do not have a point, he is in his lawfull right! Denying his point is just undermining the very few protection of authors. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights#In_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights#In_the_United_Sta... As a coder whose work is protected by Author's rights I strictly see as dangerous to fight against hardly claimed rights that makes our value. I do free software and I do not give up on my moral rights and I think as a worker protected by these rights we should be educated in author's right and whether or not we like his point of view, we should stand for his claim because that is a fair right. Imagine you make a software or an essay saying HN is full of interesting bright mind, and someone defaces it adding contents to mean HN is full of pedantic idiots. Would you like this?
- icebraining 10y agoHe probably doesn't actually have any legal claim; the purpose of those laws is to protect the physical integrity of artworks, not the conceptual integrity.
- bonzini 10y agoNo, moral rights go beyond physical integrity, but at the same time they only protect "the author's honor or reputation". I don't think they apply in this case.
- bigtimeidiot 10y agoI can't wait for people to start extrapolating conclusions about gender diversity based on the financial success of the SHE fund.
- ams6110 10y agoWell it's like most other funds that are managed on social principles -- it underperforms its category peers.
- Applejinx 10y agoAt which point the question becomes: does it react like the Girl, and just stare you down going 'I don't care because this is important on a whole other level'? Pretty much the whole concept and the intended message of the artwork is 'falling back on power alone is not good enough', or indeed 'justice matters'. In that context, it doesn't matter if the fund underperforms its peers or a simple index fund, it matters whether people can be persuaded to support it on other grounds.
- hoorayimhelping 10y agoSo if I read the article correctly, the bull originally represented the strength of the American people. The girl is sold as representing the strength of women, but in fact it's a secret ad campaign that was put in front of the symbol representing American strength by a global fund. And people (unknowingly) support the ad campaign and react very aggressively to people questioning the ad and call anyone who questions the ad a woman hater. And people who want to remove the ad don't care about the symbolism, they think things are fine or they don't like uppity women. Seems like the perfect representation of 2016.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pvg 10y agothe bull originally represented the strength of the American people No, that's just what Di Modica told people, presumably to better garner public support. It comes up in the original NYT reporting: http://www.nytimes.com/1989/12/16/nyregion/soho-gift-to-wall-st-a-3-1-2-ton-bronze-bull.html http://www.nytimes.com/1989/12/16/nyregion/soho-gift-to-wall... You don't plop a massive bull in the middle of the Manhattan Financial District soon after a market crash to generally represent the "strength and power of the American people." It represents exactly what everyone who sees it thinks it represents.
- derrickdirge 10y agoI wish this kind of stuff was being resurfaced more aggressively in the face of all of this absurd backlash about 'the meaning' of a piece of public art.
- mc32 10y agoTrue enough. But while that's the meaning he put into the bull. I would say the bull was the strength of the American people in the face of a market that said otherwise. The girl was put there by an advertising firm --and some people have interpreted it as a native form of women's strength in the face of male dominance (which requires the bull transform from representing America to only representing men and the girl not representing a marketing campaign but all women facing patriarchal oppression). As the article mentions, the bull without the girl retains its strength, the girl without the bull becomes "really confident girl".
- dqv 10y agoIt's a form of pinkwashing. The superficial effect is empowerment of women, the underlying intent is to bolster an investment fund's image. Edit: https://www.ssga.com/global/en/about-us/who-we-are/team.html https://www.ssga.com/global/en/about-us/who-we-are/team.html - at least there are some women on their team I guess. That makes it less pinkwashy.
- untangle 10y ago> at least there are some women on their team But mostly in staff, not investment, roles. So don't give up your bucket of pink just yet.
- rl3 10y ago>He said he wanted the bull to represent “the strength and power of the American people”. Di Modica can't really remove the bull statue then since that would signify defeat. Likewise with facing it in another direction. As other commenters have said, doing either could potentially start a positioning war anyways. As far as symbology is concerned, I think the most forward-looking solution is to have the girl statue positioned slightly beside the bull, facing the same direction—signifying that America has her back and that everyone's on the same team. Obviously the United States has a history of repressing women, so I could see the intentional choice to face her in opposition—if it were a legit piece of guerrilla art, and not an advertisement. Commissioned corporate art hijacking classic guerilla art by twisting its meaning is, well... bullshit.
- wbillingsley 10y agoOf course he can remove the bull if he wants to. If he wants to send a particularly strong message, he can auction it and stipulation of the sale that the bull may not be positioned anywhere in New York City, and make the subsequent story his art. A corporate advertising campaign co-opts social media and a vacuous fawning politician into demanding its advert must stay and be worshipped, and the symbol of America's indomitable spirit and dynamism is packed into a shipping container and sent to Shanghai... I think it'd be hard to say Di Modica had been "defeated" as an artist if that all unfolded... and he'd probably have quite a few million from the sale to take solace in (plus being able to charge the city copyright royalties when it commissions a replica replacement).
- icebraining 10y agoOn the other hand, it could be argued that the statue commissioned by SHE is an example of the very dynamism he was extolling, by using a bull in Wall Street as a symbol of the American people.
- rl3 10y ago>I think it'd be hard to say Di Modica had been "defeated" as an artist if that all unfolded ... Defeat in context of the principles the statue represents, not Di Modica personally as an artist. Sorry, I should have been more clear. That said, I suppose the beauty of art is that it's open to interpretation, and even the scenario you outline could be construed as congruent with the principles the statue represents. Removal may not constitute defeat after all.
- christkv 10y agoSomebody should put a statue of a billionaire with his hand pushing the girl towards the bull.
- reitanqild 10y agoMonopoly man?
- ericflo 10y agoI don't think this makes a convincing case. Why, for example, is it wrong for a new piece of art to change the meaning of an older piece of art? To me, art should make us feel and think, and this does both.
- rocqua 10y agoThere is a lot of tension between advertising and art.
- stevewillows 10y agoI can appreciate the wishful statement of the 'Fearless Girl', but the fact that State Street Global Advisors ($2.4 trillion in assets under management) put it there dilutes the overall message. It's a brilliant ad campaign, but this was not intended for anything other than an opportunity to attract a lot of media attention for a specific investment group. In this case, the sooner its removed the better. However, I do hope that this inspires someone with good intentions to one-up the piece for the greater good and not a corporation's bottom line. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/14/fearless-girl-statue-whats-wrong-feminism-today https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/14/fearle...
- icebraining 10y agoCould the Charging Bull itself be viewed as an advertising campaign for the sculptor? After all, he was hoping to sell it and a few to various cities: http://www.nydailynews.com/archives/news/rock-solid-article-1.789714 http://www.nydailynews.com/archives/news/rock-solid-article-...
- spdionis 10y agoWell, much of the point of making a statue for a sculptor is to gain recognition. Not every artist wants to be a heremit. I don't see the problem of having one of your works publicizing how good you are at doing that kind of work.
- fnord123 10y agoSo art studios owned by one person are real art and art funded by corporations aren't real art? Is this like 'I only eat Italian food made by italians'?
- spdionis 10y agoWell, the goal of an art studio is to make art (and money by doing so, to be able to create more art). The goal of those dirty (/s) corporations is only marketing, or something else, but it isn't art.
- jacquesm 10y ago> the strength and power of the American people Such nationalistic bull-shit always irritates me. As if people from other countries are not equally strong and powerful and as if a statue of an animal could symbolize that in some way. On some level though it makes sense, American actions the world over often recall the bull-in-a-china-shop image. Art does not exist in a vacuum, it exists in the world around it and if you place a work of art in a public space you have to assume that that context can and will change over time. Deliberately or by accident. After all, the artist took a risk by placing the statue in a public space without permission, he can't now turn around and claim that others should not take similar rights. In this case it seems that 'the guy' has under-estimated the amount of empty space he would like to see around his art but he can solve that by simply taking his bull home and putting it in his garden. Fearless girl won't be able to follow and the bull will be safe from any further artistic intrusions.
- icebraining 10y agoAs if people from other countries are not equally strong This is unfair; while chauvinists obviously extol their country, one can celebrate it without declaring its superiority. As a non-American myself, I understand the antipathy against American Exceptionalism, but let's not put everything in the same bucket.
- jacquesm 10y agoIt irritates me because it is totally lacking introspection and this kind of statement make it into the media with great regularity, in fact, so frequently that it becomes a meme in its own right. Maybe it's my jealousy coming from a small country with puny and weak people. But I suspect that if some immigrant artist would put up the statue of a lion on Dam Square here to commemorate the strength and power of the Dutch he or she would likely be laughed out of town, statue included.
- aub3bhat 10y agoYou are just projecting your own inferiority complex. American people have several reasons to be proud of themselves. Even when you add up all the missteps the balance is undoubtedly a net positive effect on the world.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> [Fearless Girl is] an example of how commercialization can take something important and meaningful ... and shit all over it by turning it into a commodity. But it's doing that to a statue celebrating capitalism. The irony goes so deep.
- psyc 10y agoIt's art. It wouldn't matter that much if it were paid for by a saudi monarch in order to promote violence against women, because absolutely nobody, except the special kind of people who write blog posts like this, would read it that way.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Piphe 10y agoImo: remove the plaque at least. No free advertising space. Maybe have a vote to keep the statue.
- rl3 10y agoArt and history are inexorable. Removing the plaque would merely change the asthetic.
- akvadrako 10y agoAnd your point is?
- rl3 10y agoThat the statue was still created as a corporate advertisement, regardless of whether the plaque is present.
- louisswiss 10y agoA lot of great art was originally sponsored/commissioned by wealthy corporate benefactors (for example the Catholic Church and nobility in 15th century Italy). I think it's important that the beholder/public in general is aware of the providence of a piece of art, yet I doubt banning corporate sponsorship of art would be a net positive for society.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rl3 10y agoIt certainly wouldn't be, though in this particular case it could be argued that corporate sponsorship renders the work tasteless.
- bostik 10y agoI like this way of thinking. Additonally, I would say that the bull statue has well and truly earned its place. It is now an established piece of art: it has been subverted.
- zuzun 10y agoI always thought the bull was a commissioned piece of art as for example Franfkurt stock exchange has similar bear and bull sculptures infront of their building. In the financial world the bull symbolizes market gains and the bear symbolizes market losses. [1] http://www.frankfurt-tourismus.de/en/Media/Attractions/Bull-and-Bear http://www.frankfurt-tourismus.de/en/Media/Attractions/Bull-...
- bboreham 10y agoBulls are people who believe the market is going up, and buy; bears believe it is about to go down, and sell. A sustained move in one direction over weeks is a "bull market" or "bear market".
- wav-part 10y agoCompletely agree with him. FG alone is for-women but FG in front of CB is against-men. CB alone is strength but CB in front of FG is against-women. Separtely both are great work of art even after considering source of funds. But they managed to ruin both of them.
- icebraining 10y agoWhy men? The bull was never supposed to represent men.
- akvadrako 10y agoMaybe not precisely and only "every male human", but what is a bull if not masculinity?
- lacampbell 10y agoDid you read the article? It represents a bull market. It was put there in the wake of the 1987 crash.
- Symmetry 10y agoIt was created to represent the bull market and, alone, that's its obvious reading. But now that it's faced off against the fearless girl obvious reading is as a masculine, destructive force. We can try to invest the symbols we create with meaning but in the end the meanings they end up having to people is largely based on things out of our control.
- cormacrelf 10y agoThat's essentially what OP said in their 3rd sentence. FG being there changes what the bull represents.
- icebraining 10y agoIt does, but why would it change to represent men?
- logicallee 10y agoWhere does this funny number come from? >by an investment fund called State Street Global Advisors, which has assets in excess of US$2.4 trillion. This doesn't seem like it can be correct. What does this number represent?
- icebraining 10y agoIt represents the money they manage on behalf of their clients. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assets_under_management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assets_under_management
- bboreham 10y agoIt should be "assets under management". Those assets are really owned by millions of ordinary people: they are savings, retirement funds, etc.
- logicallee 10y agoThanks. Perhaps a better way to put it is that it is fourth-largest fund in the word by assets managed (after BlackRock, Vanguard Group, and UBS), at least according to a quick search. It's not realy fair to call it their assets, though.
- mynewtb 10y agoBlackRock even has more than twice that. :/
- smsm42 10y agoThey hold huge indexes like SPY and are huge ETF vendor (in fact, Wikipedia says they invented the ETF), second only to BlackRock. So trillions under management (not to be confused with money they own!) entirely not surprising.
- hownottowrite 10y agoCharging Bull is one of the great hustles in art history. Over the years, Di Modica has made an enormous profit off the sale of replica bulls to cities and wealthy clients. Along the way, he's filed lawsuits and pulled stunts to keep the statue in the public eye, but the motive has always been profit. Is there anything wrong with profit? No, certainly not. I love the hustle and I love the hustle on top of the original hustle with the addition of Fearless Girl. It's fine art and a fine hustle. Just like all good art should be. Sit back and enjoy the show.
- Clubber 10y agoSpending $350K to build a statue to illegally place in front of a stock exchange is a horribly bad investment. He may have made profit, but it probably took a long time. It's unlikely that was his prime motivation. If it was, he got extremely lucky. Artists typically think in terms of making great art rather than making money. He should have taken that $350K and put it into stocks in 1987, he would be much better off. I suspect he had other motivations.
- hownottowrite 10y agoIt's a bad investment if the goal is an artistic statement. But spending $360K (in 1989 dollars) to advertise your art to the richest people on the planet - not to mention the entire world? Seems like pretty cheap marketing - and that's assuming he really did spend that much. Side note: this was the third time Di Modica tried the tactic of dropping off gift sculptures. So, if he had that kind of money to burn on "artistic statements", I'd say he was doing a-ok without investing in the market.
- coldtea 10y ago>Seems like pretty cheap marketing In retrospect, yes. The art could have just been permanently removed by the city, and nothing would have come out of it (except some extra fines).
- TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- amarant 10y agoTo me this seems to symbolise a different message: "Brave women stopping the progress of capitalism" think what you will of that message... Turn her 180 degrees on the other hand and it's clearly conveying the message "brave women lead the way of capitalist progress, and is backed up by the strength of the finance system" Personally I prefer the second version..
- Clubber 10y ago>Turn her 180 degrees on the other hand and it's clearly conveying the message "brave women lead the way of capitalist progress, and is backed up by the strength of the finance system" Or girl who isn't paying attention about to get wrecked by a bull.
- Para2016 10y agoMaybe 180 degree turn and put her side by side with the bull
- amarant 10y agoThat would probably be preferable and more difficult to missenterpret, as some users above pointed out my setting could be, however I don't know how/if it would fit the landscape they're placed on.. Wouldn't want the girl to face oncoming traffic instead of the bull...
- digi_owl 10y agoMore like "watch our fund" (that just happens to be wrapped to the eyeballs in nauseating marketing playing on gender politics) face down the dangers of the financial market. After all a "bull market" is slang for a market going up up up. In effect marketing is doing to feminism what it did to punk.
- Applejinx 10y agoBut if we're all being trampled by the finance system, then endorsing it is hardly the intended message here. I think it's legitimate to use art to represent shifts in the zeitgeist. It ain't the Eighties anymore, and the Bull sure as hell did not represent an end to financial crashes and catastrophes. Hell, the Bull predates Enron. I think it's wholly legitimate to re-examine notions like 'the strength of the finance system'. There's a saying that insanity is making the same mistake over and over. The Bull is in a sense the perfect artistic representation of this very mistake.
- ruleabidinguser 10y agoThe girls not so smart to be fearless in the face of a bull. The girls gonna get stomped. Not a good message.
- lacampbell 10y agoIf this diorama advanced in time a few seconds, the fearless girl would be dead.
- icebraining 10y agoTry going on YouTube and searching for "forcado", you may change your mind :)
- lacampbell 10y agoI guess I just don't see what's supposed to be empowering about it. "Deluded child moments away from being tragically gored to death".
- bfred_it 10y agoI hope they leave her and that Di Modica pulls the bull. Perhaps his point will come across better and the fearless fraud will be exposed.
- atemerev 10y agoI am as pro-capitalist as one can be (Ayn Rand admirer, work in prop trading), and I like the girl. She's beautiful, and should be left there. I am not in favor of "patriarchate oppression" interpretation that everybody seems to invoke. She's confident, and she looks at the bull with genuine curiosity, not resentment. I think it sends the right message.
- m-j-fox 10y agoHow did women get stuck with pink? Soldiers get yellow. Environment gets green. Anarchy gets black. Peace gets white. Coke gets red. Poor women. Have to share the worst color with cancer.
- dqv 10y agoIt's not exactly correct to call it pinkwashing, but it's the closest term that I could find to describe the art display.
- derrickdirge 10y agoIn what sense is pink the worst color? I rather like it. I like purple better—more regal—but pink is a fine color. And pink is only the color of breast cancer, not all cancer, since it's seen as a 'women's issue'.
- speeder 10y agoThat story is particularly curious. Originally people used to dress male babies in red, because it was the colour of blood, war, strength, etc... And female babies in blue, because it was the colour of peace, the sky, etc... Around the 1960s when the feminists started to push for gender neutral clothes among other things, some of them made a campaign asking major companies (for example Sears catalog) to instead use the colours inverted, red for girls, and blue for boys, just to force some 'equality' The campaign sort of worked, but flew way over people heads, they just started to assume red (and later pink as a softer tone of red for babies) and blue (and later light blue, for same reasons as pink) were the colours of female and male babies, without knowing why... The feminists that created the switch, wrote several articles and papers claiming these gendered baby clothes were oppressive and existed to control women... I wonder after the colours just switched, what they think.
- derrickdirge 10y agoThe thing is, once you put a piece of art out there, you give up control over what that piece 'means'. Di Modica's bull meant one thing to him when he made it. Now it means millions of different things to the people who consider it every day. If he wanted to maintain full control over the meaning of his work, he should have kept it in his private studio and not let anyone look at it without him standing by to explain the piece and answer any questions. Similarly, Fearless Girl meant something specific to the asset management company that commissioned it, and something else to the artist who sculpted it. But now it takes on new meaning to everyone who encounters it. What it means to any given individual may or may not incorporate any of the intended meaning, and that doesn't make it any more or less valid. If digging into the origins of the statues helps give them meaning to you, that's great. But most people who encounter them necessarily appreciate them at face value, and that's great too, because deriving meaning from art is intensely personal. And beyond taking on different meaning to each individual, as time progresses and the world continues to evolve, so too will the symbolic value of any work of art placed into the world. God knows the Charging Bull has taken on a lot of additional meaning to a lot of people since '08. How did Di Modica feel about how that event 'changed the meaning' of his work? If you don't like a work of art, that's fine. But no one has the authority to tell someone else what it should mean to them.
- RockyMcNuts 10y agoAll 100% true… that being said, it's also a little like "Your liberty to swing your fist ends just where my nose begins". Which is not completely true from all points of view, if I follow you around swinging my fist a millimeter from your nose, it's still an act of violence. If I paint a tag on the statue, it's vandalism. If I put up a giant dude swinging a croquet mallet next to the Arc de Triomphe, people who appreciated the monument will be upset. (Or Trump next to Mount Rushmore…or a man exposing himself to the girl between her and the bull) Sometimes art that is motivated by response to another piece of art is itself timeless, and transcends the original. Sometimes it's just crap. Recontextualizing is an occupational hazard, if you're a statue, or an artist. We can debate whether the girl elevates the bull, or disrespects and diminishes it. If it's fine art or crap. And if it falls into that grey area of recontextualizing or vandalism.
- 10y ago
- skrebbel 10y agoWhat I feel people are missing is that this is a quadruple win. Di Modico wins, because artists thrive on publicity. If you want people to buy or exhibit your work, they need to know your name. I live half a planet away from the New York Stock Exchange and I hadn't heard of Arturo Di Modica until today (and I think the scupture is amazing). If I read things correctly, this is just the latest in a series of publicity stunts surrounding Charging Bull so I suspect Di Modica knows what he's doing. The outcome (whether Fearless Girl is removed or not) does not impact this at all. The people of New York win, because now they doesn't have one artwork right out the NYSE that can be interpreted and explained in many ways and makes people think, but they have two, locked in symbiosis. Together with the history and controversy behind both works, possible interpretations of either work individually, and with respect to each other, this is a fantastic and enviable piece of public culture. I envy the tour guides who get to explain this stuff to tourists. Third wave feminists win, because a large financial organization publicizing a diversity fund in such a public and original way not only helps their cause, but shows how mainstream their cause has become. This is not a fringe movement anymore, and Fearless Girl makes this more apparent than anything recently. Finally, SSGA wins because their diversity fund gets the publicity they hoped for when commissioning Fearless Girl. Looks to me like there's no downside. (sidenote: I don't think what I love more: guerilla art right in investment bankers' faces, or guerilla marketing commissioned by investment banker masquerading as guerilla art right in investment bankers' faces)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- digi_owl 10y ago> but shows how mainstream their cause has become. A marketing gimmick alongside punk?
- BenoitEssiambre 10y agoI agree. Whatever happens this is great on so many levels. The antagonism between the owners just further heighten the symbolism.
- andmarios 10y agoIt is hard to make an absolute judgement because in doing so, you have to create a qualitative definition of art, which, unavoidably, will be abused in the future. Maybe the town could add a tall plate next to each statue, with information about the creator, the installment date, etc and let people who care enough, to judge themselves.
- sklivvz1971 10y agoI like the point the author makes about the incredible intolerance there is against different points of view online, usually from both sides of the spectrum. For example, it's impossible to talk about women's rights without having people take extreme sides are reject any form of intelligent communication. Unfortunately this has been leaking more and more towards real life. People in large part repeat slogans and take predefined stances instead of using their own heads. This case is no different: the world is not divided in good, left leaning, progressive people and bad, right leaning, conservative people. A more realistic spectrum is bigots, people who think religiously about things and don't accept uncertainty to people that embrace reasonable change and diversity of opinion. People that accept that art expresses emotions and people that don't accept art that does not conform to their philosophy (remember the Talibans defacing the Buddhas in Afghanistan?)
- grzm 10y agoWhile I think a spectrum is better than binary buckets, I also think it's more useful to think along multiple dimensions rather than a bipolar scale.
- untangle 10y agoWhile Fallis' analysis the origins of 'The Girl' was interesting, it did little to mar my opinion of the art. After all, the wealthy, the clergy, the knighthood, and worse have all sponsored great art. On another note... While on the gregfallis.com website, it would be a shame to miss his 'Faux Life' series: https://gregfallis.com/category/faux-life/ https://gregfallis.com/category/faux-life/ I love the series, and it further illustrates the idea of 'juxtaposition art' (and of 'appropriation art').
- vyodaiken 10y agoWhat a great story. I'm shocked, shocked by the commercialization of art. Jeff Koons should now create Balloon Fearless Girl on Trump tower to close the circle.
- vorotato 10y agoThe American public is obviously the young girl standing against the bulls of Wallstreet.
- al452 10y agoThis entire comment thread, more or less, imagines a much clearer distinction between advertising and art, and for that matter between the commercial world and art, than exists or has ever existed.
- digi_owl 10y ago"and for reasons I’ve never understood, some folks actively dislike history." Because all too often it demonstrates to us how little we have progressed as a species even though our tools have improved massively. The struggles of today are either directly attributed to historical events, or are basically the same ones that historical societies struggled with. This because no matter how much we try to claim otherwise, we are still apes. Our instincts today are largely the same ones that our shared ancestor with chimps and bonobos had.
- seneca 10y agoThis statue speaks volumes to me, but not in the way it's probably intended to. This is corporate marketing both adeptly using culture war tactics and manipulating them to its own end. They knew that they could put their ad there and appeal to feminists. They knew that anyone who disagreed with its placement, regardless of their actual reason for objection, would be shouted down as sexist, thereby reenforcing the supporters' convictions. They knew that that interaction would generate extensive buzz. You can either buy into their message or become a target for those that do, but no matter how you engage with it, you end up pushing their message. Whether you're a die hard feminist, or someone who finds this divisive, you are being manipulated by cynical marketers. They've correctly identified the mechanisms of a current social schism, and subverted them. Regardless of how you feel about the statue, the campaign is simply genius. This is truly art on a next level. The divide of American culture, the cynicism of corporate America and its willingness to stoop to any level, the furious fighting while blind to the real mechanisms at work. This statue may be the perfect representation of America in 2017.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kkhire 10y ago>no matter how you engage with it, you end up pushing their message. Whether you're a die hard feminist, or someone who finds this divisive, you are being manipulated by cynical marketers strikingly similar to the pepsi ad team strategy
- greenhatman 10y agoExcept I still don't know who put it there. Sure I could look it up, but it's probably stupid.
- undersuit 10y agoState Street Global Advisors.
- mythrwy 10y agoI've read what the statue is supposed to convey but what I see is a sassy looking girl that is just about to get gored and stomped by a charging bull. I guess it's nice she is standing up and all but given the situation she isn't going to win. Apparently this girl has very little understanding of proportional weights and forces. In short, I don't see brave but rather stupid. Not an admirable quality. Sassy girl needs a horse and a lasso or rocket launcher or something. Or else a plate and a knife and a bottle of A1 steak sauce. Then I'd get the point.
- MarkMc 10y agoI absolutely agree with Di Modica. The problem is that the old piece of art has in effect been destroyed. Imagine if I purchased Vincent van Gogh's painting 'The Starry Night' and painted over the sky to make it 'The Bright Day'. Imagine if the publisher of the Harry Potter books decided to rewrite the protagonist as a six inch alien in disguise - and did not publish the original work. The Fearless Girl artist should use a replica of the bull and place it in a different location.
- danmaz74 10y agoIf I were Di Modica, I would remove my statue just to spite the advertisers.
- MarkMc 10y agoIf I was Di Modica I'd place another statue between the girl and the bull. I wonder how the artist of Fearless Girl would react if someone placed a Bart Simpson statue directly in front of the girl like this: http://m.imgur.com/ZYVsopb http://m.imgur.com/ZYVsopb
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI have really enjoyed this discussion mostly because it explains art in a way that is much more tangible and visceral than one usually gets. It also shows how a art is more about person's internal viewpoint than the art itself. Ladybird Johnson said it best when she said "Art is the window to man's soul." It opens a window in people where you can peek in and see how they think on the inside. For some, like me, the pair of them, the Bull and the girl, are much more powerful art than either of them independently. That the girl was created in part as an advertising pitch was news to me, but the art stands by itself.
- mnm1 10y agoDi Modica does not have a monopoly on the meaning of his work. If he doesn't like the Fearless Girl, he can take his statue away or try to bring suit or whatever, but it's actually irrelevant to the meaning of his work. Nothing he can do can affix such meaning. The meaning he ascribed to it is but one of many meanings, all equally valid, none preferred. When I first took note of the bull, to me it represented everything that was wrong with Wall St. and America. It was a symbol of what Wall St. was doing to America: charging it down and trampling it to death. This is pretty much the opposite of what Di Modica meant but it's just as right an interpretation as his. After reading this and other articles and knowing the history of the piece, I still prefer my own interpretation and think Di Modica's quite lame. The girl even adds to that. The fact that she represents SHE just adds to the irony. Anyway, my interpretation is not important either, just like Di Modica's isn't. As far as relevance and meaningfulness, they are equal. Di Modica, as an artist, should understand that the best. Too bad he doesn't. The rest are just boring legal issues surrounding a confused artist.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 10y agoSo what is this global investment trying to say? "We specialize in profiting from misfortune when the market is tanking ... but we aren't scared of the bull, either: bring it on!"
- btbuildem 10y agoI think an interesting response by Di Modica would be to remove the bull statue. Without it, the Defiant Girl would be reinterpreted anew. Without a symbol to oppose, what would her presence mean?
- cies 10y agoThe bull is in public space, not a museum. Public space interacts back with your art piece. I consider that a given. And in this case the reaction on the piece was a great one.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hartator 10y agoIt's actually pretty accurate description of the reality. Mindless administration in the path of progress.
- coldcode 10y agoMaybe the right solution is to remove both. But it does make for an interesting dealing art piece despite the fact (I didn't realize) that the girl is just a ad for some company. Though I wonder what would happen if someone put a third piece right in the middle that made fun of both.
- smsm42 10y agoBTW looked at the performance of that SHE index being advertised[1]. 3.17% over the year - abysmal compared to SPY which it should be beating (11.9%) as both are large cap stock indexes. Looks like advertising the heck of of it the only hope here. (OK I know I year is not really a long term for a stock fund, but 1/4 of SPY performance is a fail IMHO) [1] http://finance.yahoo.com/chart/SHE http://finance.yahoo.com/chart/SHE
- frozenmangos 10y agoHilarious suggestion I've heard: Arturo Di Modica should simply rotate the bull by 180 degrees.