3 ms·
I'm not sure what logical fallacy I'm committing (perhaps genetic fallacy?), but whenever Tim Bray talks about photography, images, typography, or really anythi
by KirinDave 16y ago
I'm not sure what logical fallacy I'm committing (perhaps genetic fallacy?), but whenever Tim Bray talks about photography, images, typography, or really anything involving visual appeal I close the window.
Look at his blog. Look at his photography. Look at his outputs. He is a competent writer with technical knowledge , but when he starts making aesthetic arguments I think he's out of his depth. Especially when he uses other people's informed decisions to justify his uninformed ones (e.g., JDD's choice of monitor being good enough for him).
That'd be fine if this article was a researched technical argument, but it's not. This article is a "120ish seeems good enough for me, and I got this stuff from JDD and I seem to remember old printers being good at..."
- jacobolus 16y agoSeriously. Where does he come up with nonsense like: > I suspect that unless you’re preparing high-quality print work, there’s no appreciable benefit for a photographer, and perhaps some downside, in an ultra-high-res display. Count me among (amateur) photographers who would just love to have a 300 DPI display on which to work on photographs. Here for example is one quite obvious appreciable benefit: I can see at full resolution what my prints will look like with varying amounts of sharpening applied, in a roughly accurate simulation. Previously, if I opened an image up at 100%, the proper amount of sharpening for print would make an image look extremely “crunchy” on screen, because 100% on screen has pixels three times as big as a 300 PPI print resolution. If instead I looked at the image scaled to 50% on a typical display, I could no longer notice any difference from fine-resolution sharpening, because the screen display would be interpolated. More than that though, I’d love to have a 300 DPI tablet-scale device to show off work on. Photographs would be absolutely gorgeous.
- sesqu 16y agoSo your argument is that 300 PPI displays are great for processing photos you intend to have printed at 300 DPI. I have no problem with this claim, and I'll extrapolate to "better for >= 300 DPI prints". So, I guess the obvious question is, how much DPI do various prints come out with? And since almost all electronic displays have far less than 300 PPI, would you agree that web designers do themselves a disservice if they get a high-resolution display?
- jacobolus 16y agoWell, personally I send a lot of prints to http://whcc.com/ http://whcc.com/, which involves uploading a 300 PPI image to an ftp server and filling out a web form, and then receiving a nice quality print by UPS 2-day ground a couple days later. If I was printing on an inkjet, I might print at even higher resolution, but after 300 PPI the improvements get harder and harder to notice. As for web designers: (a) they presumably aren’t the same as “photographers” that Tim Bray was explicitly talking about so I’m not sure they’re really relevant to my comment, but (b) it’s a lot easier to simulate lower-resolution displays than higher-resolution displays. That is, if you had a 300+ DPI monitor, you could approximate the appearance of both a traditional (say, 100 DPI) computer screen, and an iPhone, Android Phone, high-resolution netbook, or whatever else.