3 ms·
I disagree. The current atmosphere has more to do with having too much money in policing where prosecutors hold a leading role. Many district attorney offices
by Spooky23 10y ago
I disagree.
The current atmosphere has more to do with having too much money in policing where prosecutors hold a leading role. Many district attorney offices are dependent on seized property to function, so a cozy relationships and keeping the vote from rocking become important.
Personally, I prefer elected judges and prosecutors. Leaving things in the hands of the people will always be a better outcome than letting political hacks decide.
- narag 10y agoThose are not the only possible options. In many countries judges get their positions by a technical competition. Also in my country the case is built by a judge, even if there is a DA during the trial. I think they're going to change that, unfortunately... we suspect the reason is putting political corruption cases in more friendly hands. Climbing the career ladder is managed by an entity formed by judges... in theory. In practice Constitution is ignored and politicians chose a good number of its members. Seized property seems like total madness.
- synchronise 10y ago>Leaving things in the hands of the people will always be a better outcome than letting political hacks decide. In most parliamentary countries this is not the case. In Australia, specifically the state of NSW, the judges are appointed by the Governor who goes with the suggestion of the Attorney General (by convention, not requirement), and while the position of Attorney General is not directly elected each member of cabinet has to be elected by the public. To make sure allegations of corruption are independently assessed, there is an Independent Commission Against Corruption, or ICAC, that can investigate individuals for corruption in a public office. The checks and balances are pretty broad in that model, and there's no risk of appealing to fallacies which can happen in the direct election model e.g. appealing to 'common sense'.
- scardine 10y agoIn Brazil there is a technical competition to ingress the career (both for judges and prosecutors). Often there are 100 or more candidates for each available chair. The problem here is that judges are unaccountable: a judge can have 100% of his decisions reformed in an upper court and keep working. In a sane system he would be fired.