4 ms·
Well if you look at it from a Govt's perspective it makes sense. Even though you are US citizen living outside US you still part of the club for which you have
by sumedh 10y ago
Well if you look at it from a Govt's perspective it makes sense. Even though you are US citizen living outside US you still part of the club for which you have to pay membership fees. If you dont like that you are free to leave the club and take some other citizenship.
- aoeuasdf1 10y agoNo, because you don't cost the govt anything. You don't use any public services in the USA, you use the public services where you live. You're paying for literally nothing but a passport.
- sumedh 10y ago> You're paying for literally nothing but a passport. Which is exactly what I meant, you are paying the membership fees whether you use the services or not. The US govt knows that, if you dont like you are free to give up that passport which I am sure you wont.
- X-Istence 10y agoRenouncing US citizenship is not something you do by filing in a form and sending it along with your passport to the US embassy. It can take years, plus many lawyers, and in the mean time you have to continue paying taxes, and pay for the process thereof. It's not that simple.
- C4K3 10y agoand it even costs a fixed fee to get a passport.
- yehi 10y agoI am a citizen of a foreign country, I have a job in that country, I store my money in that country, I buy practically all of my products in that country. Why should the fact that when I was a baby, the US government decided to give me citizenship cause me to pay more taxes (or at least pay more to file) than my neighbor who is not a US citizen?
- sumedh 10y agoSo why dont you renounce your US citizenship? The US govt knows that most non resident US citizens even if they dont like paying taxes are still going to pay it because those citizens still want to be part of club US.
- morgante 10y agoRenouncing citizenship is expensive and non-trivial. The US global taxation regime is a trap.
- sumedh 10y agoYes I know its convoluted but do want to keep paying taxes every year or just renounce citizenship , it's your choice.
- yehi 10y agoJust renouncing US citizenship costs several thousand dollars in legal fees and could take up to 5 years. What you are suggesting is similar to telling someone who is complaining about rent prices to just buy a house.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoWell why doesn't the US government just decide to tax its citizens the same as nearly every other country in the world? You're saying that the solution to a bad system is to move, rather than just making the system less terrible.
- sumedh 10y agoI am talking about realistic scenarios, that person can renounce US citizenship, changing the US tax code is not in his hands, is it?
- Joeri 10y agoIf switching citizenship was on the level of ease like switching rental apartments, complex but doable, then you'd have a point, but you generally don't have that much choice in your citizenship. It is one of the last bastions of socially accepted generational discrimination. Countries try to keep you in their club and try to keep others out of it, even if discriminating between people based on where they were born is objectively morally wrong. Not that I think it's a good idea to get rid of borders today, just that a natural extrapolation of western morality, which favors choice over birth, leads you down a path to a borderless world.