7 ms·
There's a fine line here. The world will never be just. But that's not germane -- doesn't matter what the world is to you anyway. It's not like you have to pow
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
There's a fine line here.
The world will never be just. But that's not germane -- doesn't matter what the world is to you anyway. It's not like you have to power to change or complain about it. It's like complaining about the spectrum of certain stars because you can't get a good tan from them.
The key question is how do you act in the world. I think many people confuse acting as if the world is a just place with actually believing that the world is a just place. When young, you may start out thinking the world is a meritocracy. Then, perhaps in school, you finally figure out that life's a bitch and then you die. Perhaps some smartass with a website or a teacher or some other authority figure takes you aside and tells you that life is shit.
What comes next is very interesting. Some folks internalize the unfairness of the world and chew on it. They hold grievances, complain about those who succeed, and feel oppressed and victimized. Other folks act as if the world is a fair place because they have decided that acting in such a way is the kind of person they want to be. They are happy, optimistic, and always looking for the good in life.
Perhaps these people always view people in pain or suffering as in some way deserving it. Perhaps the other people always view people in pain and suffering as never deserving it. Perhaps both groups secretly think of life as a meritocracy. This would be an interesting hypothesis to test.
But in either case, the world sucking is no reason for you to change your attitude one way or the other. In fact, once you figure out that you own your emotional responses to events, you move past whether the world sucks or not, because it's really not that important.
And then you find articles like this pointless or worse.
- okmjuhb 16y agoThe just world fallacy isn't bad because of how it changes your motivation or happiness or anything like that. It's bad because of how it causes you to act towards those around you. People don't respond to homelessness when they've convinced themselves that homeless people deserve it. "the world sucking is no reason for you to change your attitude one way or the other" is of course absurd. If the world sucks, there's a reason to change it.
- anamax 16y ago> People don't respond to homelessness when they've convinced themselves that homeless people deserve it. Stereotype much? "Deserve" is a loaded term. Homelessness is often a consequence of choices made by the homeless person. For example, SF has both homeless and shelters that go unused. In other words, there are folks who prefer to be homeless to living in those shelters. Is it really unreasonable/wrong/immoral for folks to respond with "okay - I've done enough" wrt those homeless? If it is U/W/I, what do you want said folks to do? Build nicer shelters? Force those homeless into the shelters? Be precise - what will it take for you to be happy with the response to those homeless?
- Qz 16y agoYou're misinterpreting the sentence. It's not a statement that people (in general) think homeless people deserve it, it's a statement about people who think that.
- anamax 16y agoActually, I'm inferring that the sentence was written by someone who is assuming the reason why folks don't do as he'd like wrt the homeless and responding to that reason. The reason that I say that he's assuming (in most cases) is that people typically don't explain themselves, they just do. More to the point, that sentence expresses a dissatisfaction with said "do", regardless of reason. Is it beyond the pale to question that dissatisfaction?
- Qz 16y agoI understand what you're saying but it seems like you're looking for a place to pick a particular argument rather than actually responding to the comment. I agree with what was said in the comment, but I don't have a dissatisfaction with how people do or do not respond to homelessness, so I would question the justification for making the inference that the other would -- maybe he does, maybe he doesn't.
- kiba 16y agoWell, my belief is that the world is fair, most of the time. Otherwise, we cannot have a functional civilization and a reality that can be controlled by humans to some extent. Human are pretty fair and don't engaged in criminal behaviors much or otherwise society would disintegrate. But the world can also be totally unfair at a moment notice or in some major ways. Voters being irrational in elections, quite often assuming politicians are benevolent, and politicians themselves have no incentive to think through problems. People being afraid of airplane accidents when they should focus more of their energy on car accidents. Major negative externalities that is not internalized. Unreliable eyewitness being used as court evidence and various parts of forensic science being total pesudoscience. However, the world is not totally unfair to the point that problems like these can't be solved. But there is one kind of unfairness that I couldn't shake. Sometime people support or do things that I find morally bankrupt but I knew these people to be otherwise good people. They have blood on their hands but yet have their own reasons.(Reasons that I find misguided nonetheless)
- lukifer 16y agoIt's fallacious to think your fate has nothing to do with your actions, yet it's also fallacious to think that your fate is determined solely by your actions. The real fallacy in action is the unspoken assumption that every effect has a singular cause, when the vast majority of the time there are a multitude of causes and contributing factors. Robert Anton Wilson called it "quantum causality": http://blog.est.im/archives/1158 http://blog.est.im/archives/1158 While this outlook is seemingly more difficult to manage, it becomes a lot easier when one begins to think in terms of probabilities rather than certainties. In the example of the drunk woman in the bad part of town, she is responsible only for increasing the probability that that she would be raped, but she is not responsible for the rape itself.
- mburney 16y agothe example of the drunk woman in the bad part of town, she is responsible only for increasing the probability that that she would be raped, but she is not responsible for the rape itself. This assumes that it is easy to measure the probability of possible risk vs. possible benefit for every action that an individual makes. I'd say that something like that is very difficult to do, given that our desires don't always coincide with what is objectively rational. Of course we could decrease the probability of bad things happening to us if we stay at home most of the time and don't break any rules/norms, but that would rule out acting on many of our desires.
- mseebach 16y agoThe problem with the rape-example is that it's overly idealized - it's a tautology: If you're asking to get raped, then, yes, you're asking to get raped. But you're not. The majority of street-rapes (the actual majority of rapes are between people who already know each other) aren't of people "asking for it", it's of people who maybe didn't take all the precautions they could have, but all-in-all were just in the wrong place in the wrong time. And then it's not so simple - I don't think very many would think that a girl who walked three blocks alone deserved to get raped, even if it could have been avoided by taking a taxi or walking with a friend.
- sigstoat 16y agoOther folks act as if the world is a fair place because they have decided that acting in such a way is the kind of person they want to be. They are happy, optimistic, and always looking for the good in life. In my experience, they're generally confused and miserable, because they have an incorrect mental model of the world, so they mispredict the behaviors of others, and the outcomes of situations. If you want to believe that the world should be fair, and would be better if it were fair, that's fine. You can believe that, and simultaneously recognize that the world is not, as it currently exists, fair. Only then can you attempt to change things. (Whether or not success is possible is a completely different question.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI am continually amazed at how easy it is to be misunderstood. It's almost not worth commenting. People act in such a way as if the world is fair -- they are fair to others. They expect others to be fair to them. They do not think the world is fair. When others act unfairly, or life reminds them that it sucks, this is nothing new for them. There is no gap in the model. In fact, they have a better grasp of the model than others. These are the people lobbying for change, because they know that lobbying for change is the right thing to do in a fair world when presented with something that needs changing. NOT that the world is fair. You are confusing actually believing the world is fair with understanding that it is not and still acting in good faith and with common decency and courtesy towards others.
- asr 16y agoYour advice reminded me of the Solidarity movement in Poland under communism, and the movement to act "as if" they were already free. "As soon as they started to act 'as if,' the 'as if' started to melt away." (http://tinyurl.com/2a9l7b8 http://tinyurl.com/2a9l7b8) In that case, the argument is that acting as if the thing were present will encourage it. I think, although you may disagree, that the same argument applies here--act like the world is just, and act in a just manner yourself, and you may make the world a more just place. (Or is that naive?)
- Qz 16y agoIt's the difference between thinking about moving your arm and moving your arm.
- Aetius 16y agoAnd, in some rare cases, you find the mental fortitude to embrace your inner psychopath and bend the world to your will. You find a way to cast aside morality, while at the same time convincing the rest of the world that you haven't. You do, or do not find happiness by doing this, but you know that you would have never been happy by not trying. http://www.cassiopaea.com/cassiopaea/psychopath.htm http://www.cassiopaea.com/cassiopaea/psychopath.htm
- Aetius 16y agoTo the (I assume) idealist that downvoted me; can you provide your rationale? The above is an actual response of rare people facing a moral dilemma. I did not mean to encourage anyone to do this, I was merely providing an antithesis to the parent.
- endtime 16y ago>I did not mean to encourage anyone to do this "embrace your moral fortitude" is a pretty positive way of putting something you claim not to advocate.
- dejb 16y agoAny world view that doesn't account for what you describe is certainly lacking. Edit: Actually I read the whole article and it does seem to get a bit weird and certainly seems somewhat less than a completely scholarly work.
- lars512 16y agoYou've missed the point of the article. The world sucking makes people change their attitudes and err on the side of believing that people who are unfortunate are in their situation due to character flaws (rather than bad luck or bad starting conditions). A more objective evaluation of these individuals should take instead into account these additional features. I've noticed a different dichotomy between people than what you describe. Some really pretend that the world is a meritocracy, and really go to extreme lengths to attempt to explain away differences from this position. They may be personally very compassionate to their close circle of friends and family, but have no "intellectual compassion" for third parties in bad situations. They do not contribute to charities, and feel cheated that "their money" is being "stolen" in tax dollars and redistributed to others. On the other hand, others realise that the world is not a strict meritocracy, and can extend at least "intellectual compassion" to third parties in bad situations, recognising that bad luck and unfair starting conditions are the biggest part of how they're in these situations. They're more likely to treat these people as individuals, are more socially progressive, and favour redistributive social policy. This article explains a fundamental bias that many people use in their judgements of others, especially the disadvantaged. As with other biases, if we are at least aware of it we can attempt to use this awareness to recalibrate our thinking slightly on social issues.