3 ms·
From my experience college is not so much about actual knowledge acquired but mostly about learning to learn and think. I could have studied civil engineering i
by scotty79 10y ago
From my experience college is not so much about actual knowledge acquired but mostly about learning to learn and think. I could have studied civil engineering instead of CS and be exactly as good software developer as I am, maybe even better.
Is college absolutely necessary to perform some jobs? Probably not. But I think I'd benefit if my hairdresser or tailor (I don't actually use services of any of those) attended some technical university during his/her career. Real shame is that not everybody has time and money to do that.
- martin1975 10y agohave known and worked with great programmers who majored in biology, english and film.. so I absolutely concur with this statement.
- andrewvc 10y agoThat's totally confirmation bias. Smart people are more likely to go to college. Almost everyone becomes wiser between the ages of 18 to 22. Why are you so sure that college is causative here? I don't doubt that college is where many people grow up more intellectually, but I have yet to see proof that it is the cause of that growth.
- scotty79 10y ago> I don't doubt that college is where many people grow up more intellectually, but I have yet to see proof that it is the cause of that growth. I can agree that it's not the sole cause. But I really have trouble believing that being exercised and lectured about the stuff you knew nothing about every working day and being strongly challenged at least semiannually has no effect on people.
- andrewvc 10y agoWell it's not as if people who don't go to college sit about twiddling their thumbs. There's an argument to be made that people who don't spend those years having their life structured and defined by a university learn other important lessons. There's particular irony to making the point that college is where you learn to think on HN. Many founders, like Bill Gates, dropped out of college to be hyper focused on their mission. Rather than thinking of college as a blanket solution for everybody I wish people viewed it as a tool. Some people need it, some people flat out don't.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- andrewvc 10y agoWell it's not as if people who don't go to college sit about twiddling their thumbs. Additionally there's an argument to be made that people who don't spend those years having their life structured and defined by a university learn other important lessons. There's particular irony to making the point that college is where you learn to think on HN. Many founders, like Bill gates dropped out of college to be hyper focused on their mission. Rather than thinking of college as a blanket solution for everybody I wish people viewed it as a tool. Some people need it, some people flat out don't.
- scotty79 10y ago> Well it's not as if people who don't go to college sit about twiddling their thumbs. If I never went to college I'd just play more computer games and probably get a job few years earlier. Jobs are easy so I don't expect them to develop and challenge me anywhere near as much as college did. > Bill gates dropped out of college to be hyper focused on their mission. As I said, shame that not everybody has the time or money do go through college. Bill didn't have time. > Some people need it, some people flat out don't. You don't exactly need much in life. Not starving and not dying in the cold on the streets is pretty much enough. The thing is that everything is better when people are doing some things they don't really need to do.
- nitwit005 10y agoThis kind of thing always sounds like an excuse to me. If learning to think was a thing, surely the content of the course should matter? After all, this argument implies that it's not included in what was taught before university. And why wasn't it taught in high school if it was so important?
- scotty79 10y ago> And why wasn't it taught in high school if it was so important? Sometimes it is taught earlier but that just requires a great teacher and only so few of great teachers want to deal with adolescent youth for disgraceful payment. College is a good time to start teaching people to think and to learn because it's the first time when most of the young people begin to understand that learning is just for their benefit and nobody else actually cares if they learn anything. > If learning to think was a thing, surely the content of the course should matter? It does matter to some degree. Learning to prove mathematical theorems teaches you to think better than analyzing poetry.