2 ms·
I am...not a fan of Golang, as I have made pretty clear around here on occasion. But I'll give credit where credit's due, and this is a good decision on the par
by eropple 10y ago
I am...not a fan of Golang, as I have made pretty clear around here on occasion. But I'll give credit where credit's due, and this is a good decision on the part of the people maintaining x/crypto/ssh. Not the tooling vendor's awful response--I'm pretty sure I know who it is, and if not there's two of 'em because I've had these conversations before--but the maintainers are doing the right thing. This probably shouldn't have gotten out the door without host key verification in the first place (and that ties back into the reasons why I do not like or trust Golang or its community when it comes to tools that I have to consume), but it's better to bite the bullet and fix this now instead of letting it fester.
(The "PGP is too hard for discussing security issues" thing, though, is total nonsense. Can't be doing that.)
- grey-area 10y agoDoesn't the writer call out hashicorp specifically by name in the article? I used to respect this vendor and recommend their tools to others. I am having to rethink this a lot. I am no longer happy to recommend Hashicorp products to others.
- eropple 10y agoOh, ha, I glazed over that paragraph! But yeah, it was totally Hashicorp I was thinking about; this sort of reliability-thoroughly-optional thing shoots through a lot of their tools and keeps me pretty far away from any of the ones that might touch live environments. (Packer and Vagrant are fine.)
- RRRA 10y agoWhich one of their tools are we talking about here? Terraform?
- syscomet 10y agoblog-post author here: all of them written in Golang which use SSH. Packer, Terraform, Vault, all of them. Using a bastion host in your configurations doesn't help if you invoke the tooling on your laptop, since the connection to the bastion host is done with the SSH package, again with no host-key verification.
- Piphe 10y agoAnd Vault is supposed to be a super secure root of trust. Hmm...
- canes123456 10y agoDamn, I was planning on using Vault eventually. This attitude towards security gives me pause about put all my secrets into it. Is there any alternatives?
- mitchellh 10y agoI posted the exact affected software (and how) here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14122973 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14122973 I go into detail so I'd rather not repeat it here :)