4 ms·
"iPhones then create a direct peer to peer connection over the internet. The iPhones deal with all IP addresses, firewalls, NAT issues automatically." Isn't th
by Tichy 16y ago
"iPhones then create a direct peer to peer connection over the internet. The iPhones deal with all IP addresses, firewalls, NAT issues automatically."
Isn't that impossible without an intermediate server?
Edit: OK, thinking a bit, I never looked into the Skype trick much, but I would guess, send a request to a server (that doesn't respond). Then you have an open connection/port listening to the response from the server. If you can tell the other party about that "hole", it can send a packet across the firewall.
While for Skype that is done by a server (if necessary), the iPhone could send the information via the phone line?
As I said, no idea how the details work, just a rough idea. Or maybe they just use a server.
- swombat 16y agoIntermediate servers don't require an account.
- Tichy 16y agoSure - it's just that they said they will make it an open protocol. So will they provide the intermediate servers for everyone?
- alex1 16y agoIf there is an intermediate server involved (probably a STUN server), it just helps set up the connection. The actual UDP packets don't go through any middle man. This is how residential VoIP services have been working without requiring any firewall/router configuration by the customer. It's also the same thing when you set up an iChat or Skype video call with both parties being behind a NAT.
- astrange 16y agoYes, it uses STUN - you can see it on the keynote slides when he listed the standards used. By the way, this article makes it sound like Posterous invented the concept of not having accounts? Even though it was obviously invented by 2channel.