3 ms·
I abandoned an orthopedist last year because I felt that he was using hard-sell tactics on me to get me to agree to surgery for my broken ankle. Basically, he
by CydeWeys 10y ago
I abandoned an orthopedist last year because I felt that he was using hard-sell tactics on me to get me to agree to surgery for my broken ankle. Basically, he had a surgery slot open in a few days and it seemed like he wanted to book it, with increasing discounts (including exploding offers!) on the surgery as I kept demurring. He was a referral from the urgent care clinic that I went to immediately following the accident, and I think they recommended him solely because he was in the same doctor/hospital network (although he did not take my insurance!).
So I spent several hours doing research on orthopedic surgeons and went to visit one of the best ones at the best hospital in the city (who also happened to be in-network). He looked at my X-rays and recommended against surgery, saying that the break wasn't that bad and that it would heal fine with just the cast I was already in! He was not as personable and a bit more robotic than the other guy who was giving off the salesman vibes, but I trusted him because of my research rather than the first doc who was essentially just some random referral through happenstance.
A year has gone by now and I'm glad that I didn't get the surgery, because my ankle healed perfectly without it (the second doc was right). I would've been walking faster with the surgery, it's true, but I also would've had permanently implanted metal hardware (which can cause lifelong irritation issues), and which could have necessitated a second surgery for later removal. In hindsight I regret nothing, and of course not having the surgery was also much, much cheaper.
So if that first doctor were to ask me why I'd leave him, I'd just say that it seemed like he was placing profits above the best interests of the patient, or, more charitably, that since he's a surgeon he thinks of surgery as the solution to every problem, even when it's not necessary.
- HillaryBriss 10y agomaybe it goes without saying, but you also avoided the infection risks which come with surgery.
- CydeWeys 10y agoYeah, and the risk of spontaneous anesthesia death (it's rare, but some people simply don't ever wake up). There's always plenty of reasons not to get surgery, and the only reason to get it is if the outcome for the injury is better, which it wasn't in this case! The default should be to not get surgery unless it has a clearly better expected outcome, whereas the orthopedist seemed to default to surgery for any injury.
- HillaryBriss 10y ago> The default should be to not get surgery unless it has a clearly better expected outcome, whereas the orthopedist seemed to default to surgery for any injury i'm not a doctor, but that makes sense to me. i sometimes hear that medicine has entered the "post antibiotic" era. i can't help but wonder: are surgeons about to take a big financial hit because of that?
- mhneu 10y agoThings I have learned about orthopedists: - they have only one tool and it is surgery. If you don't need surgery, you need to see a physical therapist. PTs know far more about soft tissue injuries and rehab than orthopedists. - orthopedists make money from each surgery they do. Many orthos are honest, but some areas of US have orthos who run joint replacement factories to maximize profit. In the past few months I've gotten two junk mailings from orthos advertising joint replacement. If doctors are advertising, you know their financial incentives are wrong.
- arkades 10y agoPhysiatrists. Physical Medicine & Rehab doctors. They're the non-surgical equivalent of orthopedists. PT's... are fine folks. But if you want to avoid surgery and need a proper injury evaluation, you go to PM&R.
- mhneu 10y agoFor example on surgery advertising in a non-rich area of the US: http://www.scrantonhipandknee.com http://www.scrantonhipandknee.com Landing page is all about how great hip and knee replacements are.