5 ms·
Pre-WWI Britain harbored many of the preconditions for fascism
- aaron695 10y agoHow did Slate lose the plot? They used to have good articles that seemed quite moderate?
- hprotagonist 10y agoThus characters such as Roderick Spode in P.G. Wodehouse's works.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoAnd the same was true of the United States, pre-WWII. While I certainly heard a lot in school about our victorious rescue of Europe from the claws of the Nazis, little was I told about our cultivation of eugenics and scientific racism. Or anti-Semitic industrialists like Henry Ford allying themselves with Hitler. The turning away of Jewish refugees. Charles Lindbergh and the American Nazi Party. How would the US be different today if we understood our own complicity in fomenting fascism ideology in the aftermath of WWII?
- digi_owl 10y agoThere are times it feels like outside of the USSR's involvement, WW2 was a battle between various fascist interpretations.
- flexie 10y agoCommunism shared the totalitarianism, militarism and racism (incl antisemitism) of fascism. Communist art looked a lot like nazist art. Flags and banners too. So did the way their soldiers marched. The way individuals just didn't matter. When you go to the far right you end up at the far left, and vice versa.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoYes, for example the far left "anti-fascists" in the US are the ones that are assaulting people for their beliefs and using violence to suppress free speech. However, because they are leftists, the left has not unconditionally condemned their actions. Remember, that both the far left and the far right are dangerous. For all the talk currently about fascism, it was Communism in the 20th century that produced the most death, suffering, and misery.
- mannykannot 10y agoThe count of bodies and misery on both sides - if there were really two distinct ideological sides - is so appalling that making an issue of the difference ends up looking like you are excusing the side with the lesser.
- mnyary 10y agoThe Great War (WWI) was a 20th century event?
- jt2190 10y agoYes. Confusing as it is, the first digits of the current year (2017) don't align with the current century (21st) because we started counting centuries at one, not zero. e.g. 1 A.D. / 1st, 100 A.D. / 2nd, 1000 A.D. / 11th, etc.
- ue_ 10y ago>Remember, that both the far left and the far right are dangerous. For all the talk currently about fascism, it was Communism in the 20th century that produced the most death, suffering, and misery. The idea that regimes claiming to be Communist or even Socialist killed many does not lend credibility to your claim that the far-left is dangerous; you seem to be taking issue more with the tactics that were employed, and furthermore teetering on the edge of a 'golden middle' fallacy - of course the extremes are dangerous, we should just stay in the middle which has always been fine, right? Centrism has this strange tendency to throw out valid complaints from either "side" (if we really must classify political thought into left and right) in favor of maintaining the status quo. Centrism supports capitalism, which is why as a Communist I'm against it.
- krona 10y agoWhich pre-war countries with advanced societies didn't have, say, entire scientific communities beating the drum of eugenics? It was an entire academic discipline in the universities of many countries, and there were 3 international conferences in the early 20th century. I don't see how you could write a balanced article on this topic without even mentioning the rise and fall of Sir Oswald Mosley, because therein lies the major difference. British fascism died once people realized what was happening in Germany, most notably the Night of the Long Knives in 1934. The BUF didn't even have enough support to run in the subsequent election in 1935.
- mannykannot 10y agoMoseley's black-shirts were certainly the closest Britain came to overt fascism, but this article informed me about lesser-known (at least to me) issues prior to WW1. The title of the author's book suggests that it does indeed cover Mosley. I imagine one will find fascism has always had its appeal to some portion of the global population wherever there is dissatisfaction - and particularly among people who think they are not getting what they believe they are entitled to, rather than those who are in extremely dire straits, such as refugees and oppressed ethnic groups.
- notahacker 10y agoPerhaps the book does a better job (or argues a different point entirely) but I'm not sure the article does a particularly good job of justifying its headline. Most of the things it describes (ambivalence towards democracy, mostly latent racism) were the rule rather than the exception in most historical societies; lack of mass democracy was if anything a bulwark against populist movements like fascism. It was the liberals the middle classes favoured rather than socialists they feared that were driving changes, and the Right's preoccupation with vestiges of monarchical tradition and belief their "racial superiority" could best be demonstrated by the Empire were the polar opposite of the fascist fondness for radical new social contracts and demonstrating superiority through self-reliance and military might Above all, the early twentieth century UK didn't have the sort of massive sense of grievance that fascists built their movement arount or a charismatic far-right figure to lead a fascist movement.
- cjslep 10y agoKind of a "duh" headline to me. The headline of this article isn't that big a deal to me, because every country harbors some level of the preconditions for facism. So I found it more interesting to read about a country that did make the transition from a strong liberal democracy to a facist regeime. I just finished the book "The Coming of the Third Reich" by Richard J Evans which covers Germany from ~1880 to 1933, and does a great job of explaining how ordinary Germans at the time were living their lives and the greater cultural shifts that gave way to the minority-populist uprising that was the Nazi seizure of power. Way more insightful place to start, in my opinion.
- kristianc 10y agoAsking why Britain did not follow the same path as much of Europe in the early part of the 20th C is a worthy question but this is an oddly ahistorical article. The rise of the New Liberal government didn't happen by accident as the article seems to imply, it happened in response to social conditions. The fact that Britain took three years to win the Boer War (largely because the army was unfit to fight) was a national scandal, and gave birth to a national preoccupation with the condition of the working class. Independently of each other, two wealthy British industrialists, Booth and Rowntree, published two surveys into the state of working class life in Britain. These found that 30% of people were living in poverty, and that the conditions were such that people would be unable to pull themselves out of poverty alone. While the rest of Europe engaged in a great battle between Marxism and Imperialism, British politics set about trying to improve the condition of the working classes. Political revolution has also never really been the British way. Almost all of the major institutions of British society (including arguably the trade unions) are under the pall of political conservatism. One of the reasons why the recent Brexit has been such a surprise is that Britons have never been given to overthrow the whole system. Politics in Britain pre-war was also intensely local. Most people lived and died close to where they were born, people were even more parochial than they are now, and most people saw what was happening in Europe as completely distant from their lives. Politics in Britain pre war may have held some of the conditions for fascism, but it was never likely due to a multitude of reasons never addressed in this article. Also, it was a strange kind of crisis for conservatism - the Conservatives went on to dominate 20th Century politics in Britain.
- danmaz74 10y ago> While the rest of Europe engaged in a great battle between Marxism and Imperialism, British politics set about trying to improve the condition of the working classes. In all fairness, the UK could do that also because it had already developed the biggest and richest empire on Earth...
- jacobush 10y agoThis sounded fina to me at first but then I thought - why is this not a false dichotomy? (Honest question)
- hodgesrm 10y agoA far more interesting story is how Houston Stuart Chamberlain's writings influenced the Nazi movement in Germany. The Slate article omits the fact that Chamberlain married into the Wagner clan in Bayreuth, who were early and enthusiastic supporters of Hitler. The family was also deeply enmeshed in a nexus of virulent pro-Aryan and anti-semitic propaganda prior to WW I. Chamberlain left England in the late 1800s and settled permanently Germany where he became a citizen during WW I. This fact alone seems to indicate that conditions for Fascist philosophy in England were less than salutary. For a great read on the Wagner clan and their connections to Chamberlain, see Oliver Hilmes' outstanding biography of Cosima Wagner. ("Cosima Wagner: The Lady of Bayreuth", "Herrin des Huegels" in German).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- olivermarks 10y agoThe sub head "Edwardian Britain harbored many of the preconditions for fascism—including rampant anti-Semitism—before war broke out and united a divided nation" Doesn't sit well with me because that competitive european colonial era was a lot more complicated than Pugh describes. I hope Pugh's book discusses the realities of the global rentier classes and the origins of globalization, because I would argue this is at the root of much of subsequent events. England, Germany, Holland and France were all competing to colonize the globe in a militaristic fashion during this era, and their internal and external societies reflected that. The advent of fluid global capital unaligned to nation states - including the 1910 Jekyll Island 'Federal Reserve' invention in the USA - led to massive pressures on the parochial societies. The semitic ethnic cleansing to create the predominantly Ashkenazi state of Israel was largely the result of British capitulation to the global financiers who orchestrated the Sykes Picant and Balfor treaties that enabled the state of Israel to be reinvented. The punitive reparations on Germany after WW1 was largely seen as this same class extracting tribute from Germans ...and crucially the popular sentiment was that German society was being dominated and overrun with Jewish capital. These are obviously contentious issues but, just as the case now where the 1% who own the world's capital 'haven't taken out enough insurance to protect themselves from the rest' to paraphrase economist Mark Blyth, 'populism' ie people waking up unsatisfied with the way their societies are dominated and run, was a major motivator for change then and now. Well over 100 million people died in WWII and billions were made by those same stateless rentier classes (who are of all ethnicities and religions, this isn't uniquely about Judaism). The author's website http://www.martindpugh.com/page3.htm http://www.martindpugh.com/page3.htm
- jonyt 10y agoHmmm..."capitulation to global financiers", "stateless rentier classes", methinks I sense a common theme here. Not a supporter of David Irving by any chance are you?
- olivermarks 10y agono
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]