3 ms·
You assume: 1) Merit is an understood and measurable trait 2) Merit is measurable to a fairly fine degree 3) Diversity does not, in and of itself, increase
by smt88 10y ago
You assume:
1) Merit is an understood and measurable trait
2) Merit is measurable to a fairly fine degree
3) Diversity does not, in and of itself, increase chances of success
For #3, there's research showing you're assumption is wrong. You can also make an analogy to any other kind of investing, where if you do the same thing as everyone else, your results will be average.
- alehul 10y ago1) You're somewhat right; 'displayed capability' would likely be better. 2) It doesn't have to be perfectly or flawlessly measurable to be worth measuring and net a positive result. 3) There's definitely more measurable, tested validity behind typical 'meritocratic' factors used by employers for recruiting than there is for diversity. For example, does the average Stanford student vs NYU student have less differentiation than a Black vs White Stanford student? You're arguing against the 'measurability' and 'increased chance of success' of these factors (education, work experience) in favor of race or gender or sexual orientation. If you truly want diversity, you'd find much more of it from ten individuals of the same race who all originated from different countries with different cultures. The difference between Americans of different races, by comparison, is much, much smaller.