32 ms·
The problem is he's not technically wrong, but he is holistically wrong. You also don't have to use electricity, gas, water utilities or hospitals. However our
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
The problem is he's not technically wrong, but he is holistically wrong.
You also don't have to use electricity, gas, water utilities or hospitals. However our society has progressed to the point that these things are considered basic services now if you want to live inside of common society.
I'm not sure if he is intentionally ignoring this aspect or really is too disconnected with reality.
I say that because frankly I know a lot of people his age who don't use the internet directly at all.
I know even recently there was a exec that was being groomed for a major position at a top 5 tech co, who didn't use internet directly and had his secretary print out emails for him, that he would mark up and she would transcribe in response. It's more common than you think in the govt.
- ericcumbee 10y agoActually Not having electricity or water service in a occupied house is considered a building code violation in some municipalities.
- Tloewald 10y agoInternet access is considered a basic necessity in several countries too.
- ericcumbee 10y agoYou misunderstand...in some municipalities if you were to opt to not connect your house to the power grid, or water mains you would cited.
- rdiddly 10y agoNice way of putting it (technically vs. holistically). I wouldn't go so far as to declare anything a basic service, even something I've used almost every day of my life like electricity. I simply view it as "something that's nice to have" and therefore something we shouldn't squat down and take a huge dump on for no reason.
- noonespecial 10y agoHe does not. Most (by far) of the people he represents do. Why isn't he representing them? Fix that and you'll fix far more than just a boneheaded internet policy.
- ouid 10y agothat exec is still using the internet directly. That's like saying you don't drive your car directly, because you are only using the steering wheel and the pedals. He just has a really inconvenient and expensive browser extension.
- jquery 10y agoContext: He said this sarcastically in response to someone saying "nobody has to use Facebook." I'd argue that the number of choices of social-network and search engines choices are about as meaningful as the number of ISP choices. If anything, Facebook/Google have a larger monopoly (by percentage) than most (or all) ISPs.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI watched the video. It didn't sound sarcastic at all.