3 ms·
"If you put the hardware addresses in the lower address space you'd have to decode the entire address to see if the access is on your card." That is incorrect.
by Someone 10y ago
"If you put the hardware addresses in the lower address space you'd have to decode the entire address to see if the access is on your card."
That is incorrect. If your card has a block of 2^n bytes of memory, you need to check the (in this case) 20-n uppercut bits of an address to check whether it is in 'your' address range, whatever block your card is assigned to. Checking whether that is all zeroes isn't easier than checking whether it is, say, 42.
And I don't think people were attached to DOS; they were attached to their (expensive!) programs and those required DOS.
OS/2 tried to support those programs, but wasn't perfect, and even if it,did, it didn't give those programs more memory.
- zwieback 10y agoYeah, I guess that's true. You always have to decode all the "other" address lines regardless.
- astrodust 10y agoThe real flaw was not where they put it, but that it was immobile, the whole block was "reserved". If they made a few tweaks that allowed peripherals to slot into different spots using some kind of negotiation over the ISA bus this could have been avoided, but that was also way too sophisticated for what was a quick prototype.