3 ms·
> "Probably" is not how laws work. It totally is. In the sense that you have no way to predict with certainty what a judge or jury will rule. Especially in cas
by jrochkind1 10y ago
> "Probably" is not how laws work.
It totally is. In the sense that you have no way to predict with certainty what a judge or jury will rule. Especially in cases where the law seems ambiguous, and/or where it or the relevant aspect of it not been tested in court much.
- nebabyte 10y agoRight? The entire system is based in 'precedent', which is just a nice way of saying "well this is how we decided we'd interpret it or something similar before, let's do that" And rulings are the reciprocal "okay" "Probably" is exactly how the law works. There's a reason it's called "making your case".
- jrochkind1 10y agoBasing the system on precendent is of course an attempt to increase predictability, and reduce incidence of different judges deciding different things in similar circumstances. The system tries to reduce the "probably" for certainty, but we're still humans.