7 ms·
Wait, how did they file a false police report? Even if they are breaking the contract, they are allowed to ask the passenger to leave the plane (as the article
by cortesoft 10y ago
Wait, how did they file a false police report? Even if they are breaking the contract, they are allowed to ask the passenger to leave the plane (as the article points out). Once he refuses to leave, he is trespassing (again, doesn't matter that the airline broke its contract by asking him to leave). The airline called the cops and asked them to remove the passenger. Where did they lie or file a false police report?
- mnm1 10y agoBy saying or implying it is within their rights to remove the passenger when it clearly wasn't.
- jdoliner 10y agoThey are within their rights to remove the passenger though, it's just a breach of contract to do so. But they are within their rights to breach the contract, it just gives the other party the right to recoup damages.
- cortesoft 10y agoWhat makes you think it ISN'T within their rights to remove the passenger? The plane is their property, they can ask someone to leave (even if they previously allowed them in). What law did they break? As the article says, they broke the contract, but that is a completely separate issue from being able to ask someone to leave.
- oh_sigh 10y agoIt's within the pilots rights to remove any passenger they want. United should have just asked the pilot to kick the guy off - that is 100% within the pilots rights.
- jeltz 10y agoYes and no. It is within the pilot's right to kick anyone off, but the airline might still be liable for damages for breach of contract if the reason for kicking him off is not covered by the contract or airline regulations. Overbooking and safety concerns are valid reasons, but in this case I have a hard time seeing how they could argue for either.
- cortesoft 10y agoNo one is trying to make the argument in this thread that United doesn't owe money to the passenger for kicking him off. The question is whether they are allowed to ask the police to remove him.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoOnce he refuses to leave, he is trespassing You state that as fact, but is that true? The passenger and airline are bound by a contract of carriage, and the passenger arguably did not violate any of the stipulations in there. The airline had no business asking him to leave. I'd very much like to see this hashed out in court one way or the other, but the fear is that they'll settle without admission of liability and under seal.
- slapshot 10y agoThe article at least claims as much: "And once United in effect told Dao that it was breaching its contract with him and told him to get off, he was probably under a legal duty to comply."
- thrill 10y ago"Probably" is not how laws work.
- greenshackle2 10y agoIt turns out laws are ambiguous and sometimes it's hard to tell what the outcome of a judgment will be in advance (until judges actually interpret the law and make the call.) It can be hard to even tell which specific laws apply to the case. So, yes, 'probably' is how the law works, if you don't have solid precedents. ('Probably' could also just mean that there is solid precedent but the author themselves didn't do the research to figure it out. Legal research is a lot of work. It's, like, an actual job to do that sort of thing.)
- maxerickson 10y agoIsn't it exactly how laws work? Even for the worst of crimes, the perpetrator will only probably get caught and only probably get convicted.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago"Probably" is perhaps one of the better ways for reporters to give their opinions on questions of law that have not yet had their day in court.
- 1024core 10y agoHe is "trespassing" only when he's not legally allowed to be on the plane. He gained the right to be on the plane by paying United for the privilege, and United agreed by issuing him a ticket, a boarding pass and reserving a seat for him. Now, if they want to renege from their part of the agreement, they have to refund him the money. Just 'promising' to refund the money is not sufficient; if he wants, he must get the cash in hand. After all, United issued a ticket only when they had the cash in hand, right? Why should he be obligated to relinquish his half of the contract just based on a promise to pay later?
- self-diversity 10y agoWhat about "logic at a distance" combined with empathy would make reasoning through the legal details of an incident you've only learned about through rabble-rousing reportage a worthwhile exercise?
- SamReidHughes 10y agoAre you a lawyer, or are you making up the law? Somebody who orders a cheeseburger at a fast food joint can still get kicked out for no reason without getting their food. When they call the cops they'll get told it's a civil dispute and to take it to court. You don't just get to decide to stay on someone else's property based on your interpretation of a contract.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoAn airplane is not a McDonald's. That's why the FAA exists.
- SamReidHughes 10y agoIf you've got a specific point of fact about the law in mind, by all means articulate it.
- cortesoft 10y agoWhat are you going on about? That isn't how the law works. 'if he wants, he must get the cash in hand' - says who? You might think that is how things SHOULD be, but they aren't. The only thing that SORT of works the way you describe would be a landlord-tenant situation, where there are legal requirements for evicting someone. However, that is a VERY special case; there are special laws for housing. There are not those sorts of laws for planes. Now, there are laws about refunding money and paying for breaking contracts on plane tickets, but not about REQUIRING that an airliner 'give cash in person' to someone who is kicked off a flight.