6 ms·
While you complied and everything worked out for you, it doesn't mean that everyone should do the same. I just don't understand this line of reasoning at all. Y
by pm90 10y ago
While you complied and everything worked out for you, it doesn't mean that everyone should do the same. I just don't understand this line of reasoning at all. Yes, its well within their legal rights to request a passenger to deplane, but if he refuses, while they do have the right to forcibly deplane the person, they would have done much better if they had found alternatives.
- ghaff 10y agoAs I said "United should have done anything reasonable to get a volunteer to get out of their seat and leave the flight." However, once the flight crew directly asked him to leave, they had three choices. What they did, sit at the gate until he changes his mind, or cancel the flight. If I'm flight crew and there's someone on board who is not following crew instructions, I'm not flying with them on board.
- tyingq 10y agoFWIW, "not following crew instructions" isn't necessarily illegal. The specific law is "interfering with a flight crew", applies after the doors are shut, and isn't broadly just "not following instructions".
- ghaff 10y agoI'm not commenting on legality which I have no opinion on. But if I'm responsible for safety of any group and someone ignores requests even if they're no safety-related, I don't really want any responsibility for that person.
- tyingq 10y agoOk. Confused, as I didn't feel either of the two publicized United incidents involved passengers doing anything that would jeopardize safety. On the contrary, actually...the airline and the police were the only parties doing that.
- ghaff 10y agoI am saying that if I am responsible for a group and someone refuses to follow instructions, even instructions not related to safety, I have no confidence that they will be any more cooperative with respect to safety-related matters. And therefore, if I have an option not to take responsibility for that person I will exercise that option by either removing that person or just canceling the entire activity.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Anechoic 10y agothey had three choices. Four choices - they could have upped their incentive until the doctor, or someone else decided to take. I'd bet someone would have gladly taken a $1,350 voucher.
- ghaff 10y agoWell, yes. That's what I meant by "United should have done anything reasonable to get a volunteer." To be clear, I absolutely fault United for letting the situation get to the point where there were no reasonable options.
- s73ver 10y agoOr cash. If you're involuntarily bumped, they have to offer you cash, not a voucher that can only be used on certain days and expires in a year.
- ajmurmann 10y agoThere was a fourth choice: offer more money. They were the ones who created the situation to begin with by overbooking the flight. So they should be there ones paying the cost of their optimization. Like Delta does. Edit: other passengers even offered to get off for more money. But they were just laughed at by the crew.
- ScottBurson 10y agoLegally and ethically, passengers are obliged to follow crew instructions only when those instructions are for safety. Safety was clearly not an issue here.
- zeveb 10y agoThere was a fourth choice: they could have ejected another passenger, and then had him arrested for trespass on arrival at the flight's destination.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]