6 ms·
> It's hard to say which species was first to become intelligent, but I'm pretty sure humans weren't the first. And yet, somehow Humans are in a completely dif
by ars 10y ago
> It's hard to say which species was first to become intelligent, but I'm pretty sure humans weren't the first.
And yet, somehow Humans are in a completely different category than all other life. It's not just a matter a degree ("more" intelligent), it's a completely different category.
So that means your definition of intelligent is flawed because it is unable to capture that distinction. Perhaps you need a new word.
- Swizec 10y agoHow do you know it's a completely different category? We used to think all animals are incapable of intelligence and everything they do is "instinct". Now we know they can think, organize, have complex social structures, even imagine and form plans. Many show evidence of being self aware. So we're not special enough anymore and we have to come up with a new word? I don't buy it. It's likely that humans' extraordinary achievements stem from our immense ability to communicate and cooperate. A single human on its own isn't all that smart really. Many intelligent animals suffer from limited knowledge transfer between generations and low cooperation between individuals. So each is only as smart as itself. Or maybe as itself and a couple of friends. Whereas every human is able to tap into the intelligence of very many other humans. That's really one of our biggest superpowers.
- losvedir 10y agoHeh, I originally started this comment "oh come on!" as I thought you were being needlessly obtuse. Agriculture, written language, metal smelting, universities, space shuttles, nuclear bombs, radio, computers, etc. It was obvious to me that we're in a whole other category from other species. But then I thought about human tribes in the rain forest that don't have any of those. Are they not as intelligent us? But they are us... Hm, well you've made me think. Thanks!
- Baeocystin 10y agoHuman tribes in the rainforest have levels of social sophistication, technology, and manipulation of their local environment that outstrips any other animal. It's not close. Look at the recent discoveries in the Amazon basin. Layers of dirt thousands of years old, still filled with the charcoal used to improve soil quality. Species of plants that were clearly selected for over time. The list goes on. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_preta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_preta
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoWe used to think all animals are incapable of intelligence and everything they do is "instinct". Whenever I see this written I like to point out that the "we" in this case was only a vocal minority of people throughout history. Anyone who's ever lived or worked with animals, at the very least mammals and birds, would have observed them being intelligent. I'm sure this idea that people used to think animals weren't intelligent is a myth in the same way we think people used to believe the Earth is flat is a myth[1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_flat_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_flat_Earth
- adrianN 10y agoAnimals not being intelligent is also very convenient if the bible teaches that they're made for our use. There are fewer ethical problems if they're soulless automatons without consciousness or intelligent.
- jumanchiss 10y agoSame goes for plants, but i don't see you and all the partisan Vegans (and in this case Anti-christian bigot) care for them, On the contrary, they mock everyone who dare to say that plants are intelligent beings.
- adrianN 10y agoFrom the guidelines: > Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say in a face-to-face conversation. Avoid gratuitous negativity.
- milquetoastaf 10y ago>And yet, somehow Humans are in a completely different category than all other life. Lol no we are not. We share 98 percent of our DNA with various simians. We share 97 percent of our DNA with mice. Are we the only species to communicate? No. Are we the only species to communicate symbolically? No. Great Apes use hand gestures. Are we the only species to recognize themselves? No. Plenty of animals do. In fact, even wasps can perform facial recognition on members of their species. Are we the only species to use technology? No. Corvids and apes use tools all the time. Are we the only species to develop culture? No. Simians teach their young various customs, some of which (such as the washing of food by macaques in Japan [http://alfre.dk/monkeys-washing-potatoes/] http://alfre.dk/monkeys-washing-potatoes/]) are local to the group. Are we the smartest species? Monkeys have been able to naturally memorize a sequence of numbers after looking at it for fractions of a second. It took dedicated teams of research scientists several practice sessions to even come close to the performance of a so-called "lesser animal". Humans are exceptional (I honestly would just say lucky), but are we truly in a different category? Highly recommend the book "Are We Smart Enough To Know How Smart Animals Are?" by Frans de Waal.
- zeroer 10y agoRecursive grammar.
- milquetoastaf 10y agoBeing able to live six years without food. Humans can't even come close to that, yet a tiny tick can outlast the so-called smartest species on earth. See, species tit-for-tat is easy. What's your point?
- zeroer 10y agoYea, point taken, but recursive grammar is a prerequisite for arbitrary cognition or computation.
- ams6110 10y agoBiology notwithstanding, no other species has deliberately transformed its environment and improved it longevity and standard of living like humans have. Not even slightly.