Legality should be boolean - either you're following the law or you're not. If guilty, however, the penalty should be proportionate to the harm done. In this p

Legality should be boolean - either you're following the law or you're not. If guilty, however, the penalty should be proportionate to the harm done. In this particular case, Uber is guilty of breaching Lyft ToS's clause around no data mining. However, this seems like an insignificant infraction, there is likely to be zero legal penalty. Lyft's only recourse is to either shut down Uber's accounts or feed them bogus data.