2 ms·
I scanned the headline and thought "Bet all my fellow HN'ers will defend this guy, no matter what the situation, because of the old bits got to be free bullshit
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I scanned the headline and thought "Bet all my fellow HN'ers will defend this guy, no matter what the situation, because of the old bits got to be free bullshit" (Which I agree with in principle, but I find most folks are not interested that much in the edge cases as much as the slogan)
Then I read your comment and changed my mind. Surely what he did wasn't worth the death penalty.
Then I read the article.
I agree with you, lionhearted. And the reason I agree with you is that there is only a one-in-a-million chance that any particular potentially treasonous crime would actually be treason. But this is that one-in-a-million. If this isn't treason, I don't know what would be. If he is guilty of the things he is charged with, the deterrence factor alone is worth the death penalty.
I would welcome somebody making the case that I am wrong. But I am left with the knowledge that some things -- maybe not these things but some things -- need to be secret, even in democracy. If the people charged with keeping those secrets are playing ego-based games with disclosing them, then they have to face the consequences of their actions. If everybody in service to their country, including the president, is responsible for defending the constitution, and nobody is above the law, then this guy is in serious trouble.
(And it's worse still for him because unlike leaks in the Cold War, there is no enemy power to do a spy trade in a few years. He is well and truly screwed)