4 ms·
Do you think it's OK for violating the T&Cs of an app to be illegal? I don't think determining legality and harm should be a boolean operation. There are layer
by onion2k 10y ago
Do you think it's OK for violating the T&Cs of an app to be illegal?
I don't think determining legality and harm should be a boolean operation. There are layers of subtly and nuance in most things, and the law is one of them. I don't think posting the F word on a forum where the owner doesn't want you to post it should be treated as an equal violation of the law as deliberately abusing your competition as a billion dollar business. The amount of damage, and perhaps potential damage should be considered. When I swear a reasonable person would think the harm is minimal. When I try to sabotage another company where the damage could result in billions of dollars of lost investment and thousands of jobs vanishing a reasonable person would think that's pretty bad. They're technically the same 'crime', but they're obviously not the same in scale.
- mifeng 10y agoGreat answer - I completely agree.
- sebleon 10y agoLegality should be boolean - either you're following the law or you're not. If guilty, however, the penalty should be proportionate to the harm done. In this particular case, Uber is guilty of breaching Lyft ToS's clause around no data mining. However, this seems like an insignificant infraction, there is likely to be zero legal penalty. Lyft's only recourse is to either shut down Uber's accounts or feed them bogus data.