3 ms·
It's not an exploit. There was no privilege escalation, denial of service, theft of private data, or anything like that. You can take the technology involved an
by viraptor 10y ago
It's not an exploit. There was no privilege escalation, denial of service, theft of private data, or anything like that. You can take the technology involved and replace it with a human process: multiple people around the city open the app and report back to the HQ the locations they see. Now, would you say this process is illegal?
Simplifying it even more: If you had people on the street, looking for cars with a Lyft sticker and reporting back every one you see - would you say that is illegal?
- bencollier49 10y agoNot sure about this in the US, but I'm pretty sure that in the UK, gathering a database of intelligence on competitors' staff earnings would be a violation of the Data Protection Act.
- viraptor 10y agoIt would be interesting if this came to a trial. DPA protects only information that identifies people. If Uber collected information on cars instead which is anonymous and then correlated it with data it already has access to, so it only deanonymises its drivers, that's... I don't know. IANAL, but I read the DPA a few times and I think it's an edge case. If someone has better idea, I'd love to hear it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- makomk 10y agoThe Data Prrotection Act specifically covers this: "* “personal data” means data which relate to a living individual who can be identified (a) from those data, or (b) from those data and other information which is in the possession of, or is likely to come into the possession of, the data controller" Sorry, but they already thought of that one.
- geocar 10y ago> Simplifying it even more: If you had people on the street, looking for cars with a Lyft sticker and reporting back every one you see - would you say that is illegal? Yes, because trying to "hack" the legal system by finding things that you can argue are "technically legal" is not something that impresses me. I get that beating someone up and throwing a paying customer off a plane, or using a firehose on civil rights marchers, is "legal" if some judge can be persuaded ($$$) to agree, but I'm not going to play that game: I don't want to live someplace where we do what is legal and don't do what is illegal; I want my neighbors to know right from wrong. A Reasonable Person would think that Uber was doing this to wrong Lyft and indeed it turns out, was doing this to wrong Lyft.
- viraptor 10y agoDon't get me wrong. I think they're total assholes and shouldn't be doing this even if it is legal. But at the same time I'm interested in what would happen in case of an actual lawsuit. These don't care what impresses us :-( Also, discussing what changes on Lyft's side would make it definitely illegal is interesting if you ever have some personal data in your own service.
- morganvachon 10y agoThe thing is, it would likely be a civil tort case, not necessarily a criminal case. An action can be legal from a criminal statute point of view, and yet still open the company up to a lawsuit in civil court where the other party can try to prove they were harmed.
- lefstathiou 10y agoI believe it would need to be personally identifiable data. The fact that Uber can personally identify someone with location is unique to them and falls into this gray area.
- bitexploder 10y agoI have decided that location data is PII. It is notoriously hard to anonymize. I have conducted some experiments with customers and even with a a relatively few samples it was possibl to merge address databases and "anonymous" location with ease. Right now there is a data classification fiction in most corporations that location days is not PII because it lets them do all sorts of analytics. I predict this fiction is going to get so excited organization in trouble and not just an Uber being so blatant about it.