5 ms·
This is a pretty interesting perspective. I'm someone who was 'diagnosed' with severe depression not that long ago. Treatment in the USA is drugs and talk thera
by mentalprivacy 10y ago
This is a pretty interesting perspective. I'm someone who was 'diagnosed' with severe depression not that long ago. Treatment in the USA is drugs and talk therapy, but this is an interesting perspective. Maybe depression is a call from a higher being to wake up in your life and make big changes on your path, to adopt a different mindshift. That could be evolutionary adaptive, and it's more inspiring than the medical communities approaches.
- throwaway2048 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Night_of_the_Soul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Night_of_the_Soul https://rightabsorption.wordpress.com/2009/02/21/dark-night-of-the-soul/ https://rightabsorption.wordpress.com/2009/02/21/dark-night-...
- robotresearcher 10y ago> Maybe depression is a call from a higher being What's the more likely explanation: (1) various different conditions including depression and psychosis are calls from a higher being, not thus far sensible to science; or (2) the brain, a vastly complex organ with significant structure and dynamics, grown out of meat from a tiny unique egg and trained over decades of unique experience, works a bit differently to the norm in some people, in ways that can be distressing. Occam's Razor is tingling.
- pmoriarty 10y agoThis reminds me of a story by Wynette Barton: "When my son was four or five years old, he asked one of those interminable questions that children ask: 'Why does the sky get dark at night?' "Eager to increase his understanding, I put a lamp in the middle of the floor to act as the sun, got down the world globe, and used a tennis ball for the moon. Then I walked around the "sun", carrying the globe and turning it, explaining how we are suspended in space, constantly moving. It was the universe in a nutshell - sun, earth, moon, stars, seasons. "My son watched the production with silent, squint-eyed attention. When I finished, he said to me, 'You don't expect me to believe that, do you?'" For a lot of people, the supernatural explanation is the simpler explanation. The so-called "scientific" (or more properly Scientistic[1] or maybe Naturalistic[2]) world view rests on explanation after explanation that takes years and years of education to even understand, much less accept. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_%28philosophy%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_%28philosophy%29
- mikelyons 10y agoPeople don't understand the mechanics of belief and don't realize that they're being just as dogmatic in their rationalism and scientism as the most fundamentalist religions.
- vertex-four 10y agoEspecially some of the actual practices surrounding it - I've had some really bad experiences with e.g. the Less Wrong crowd tending towards assuming there is no value to human emotion, and so failing to even make a basic attempt of integrating into a community rather than dominating it with debate-is-the-only-form-of-conversation, attacks on people's identities under the guise of "you asked a question, that means you want me to tear you apart", and more.
- corey_moncure 10y agoMost people don't understand the mechanics of electromagnetism but that doesn't diminish its predictive power.
- ikeyany 10y agoDoes it really take years and years of education to comprehend that the Earth is spinning around the sun?
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoIt might take years to really understand it. It only takes a few minutes to hear something and decide to believe it without truly understanding, but is that really what we want people to do?
- averagewall 10y agoIt's not obvious that the sun isn't spinning around the earth instead. You could use coordinate acceleration in an earth-centered frame and the sun would be spinning around the earth. That's equally as correct as the conventional view. So I think a test can be that if someone doesn't understand that the sun is spinning around the earth, then they probably don't actually understand at the earth is spinning around the sun - they just believe it. I'm a physics teacher, and most teenagers don't have a clue about this at all. They think astronauts float around in space because there's no gravity there. If there's no gravity, then how does the earth stay in orbit around the sun? That shows they really don't understand it at all. It's difficult and you have to actually think hard over a long time to make all the pieces fit together.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoAre you sure the two models aren't equivalent, with features of the one being intractably complicated to express in the other?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- robotresearcher 10y agoPretty sure, yes. So it seems that people in this thread are taking the position that depression is a calling from a higher being. Not just metaphorically, but some version of actually true. Have you spent some time with depressed people, or been depressed? This posited higher being is pretty weird. I am constantly suprised by my fellows.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI have both been depressed and spent time with depressed people. The problem with this conversation is that the idea you unpack from the phrase "higher being" isn't really like the idea they compiled to that phrase. There's a fundamental translation problem in that things which are simple structures in one framework are hard or impossible to express in the other. You have to understand what the reverse image of that phrase is in their model, not what the reverse image is in your model (ie, the idea they were trying to convey, not what you would have been trying to convey using those words). This is obviously extremely hard, as we only have access to our own model, not theirs. For places where the models are similar, this is less of an issue, because the two reverse images are then similar. However, when the models substantially diverge, it leads to one of the most common breakdowns in communication we see (and we see it a lot, across topics). I mean, modern mathematics happened because people had different internal models for what "function" meant, but you seem to think a concept like "higher power" is easy to translate. For what it's worth, I don't think the two ideas are incompatible -- could you elaborate on why you do?
- robotresearcher 10y ago
- metaphorm 10y agoyou're presenting these as if they are diametrically opposed or mutually exclusive. I would describe them as complimentary parts of a complete explanation.
- lutusp 10y ago> I would describe them as complimentary parts of a complete explanation. s/complimentary/complementary/ https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/complementary https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/complementary
- foldr 10y ago(1) and (2) aren't mutually exclusive.
- hutzlibu 10y ago> Maybe depression is a call from a higher being to wake up in your life and make big changes on your path Less esoteric explanation: Or it is a call from deep within, the subconscious. But with the same implications. And that medications might not be that helpfull for that purpose.
- metaphorm 10y ago"deep within, the subconscious" is a very esoteric thing.
- Sone7 10y agoLol. Go on a ten day meditation retreat and tell me that. Your subconscious will be jumping out at you after 3 days of simply not talking to people.
- metaphorm 10y agoEsoteric doesn't mean "non-existent" or "spiritual". It means "understood only be those with specialized knowledge". I meditate daily and have a made a study of my own consciousness for years. I have some esoteric knowledge about the subject. That doesn't make it any less esoteric.
- hutzlibu 10y agoI would disagree, afaik the concept of a subconscious is quite accepted in science. And the concept of a higher beeing... and in general esoteric things, and least in the common understanding of the word, not so much. That beeing said, I am quite open and interested in esoteric things(even though I prefer the word spiritual), I just wanted to point out a more likely explanation to the op. Not ridiculing his version.
- metaphorm 10y agoI'll point out to you, as I did another poster, that the word esoteric doesn't mean "mysterious" or "spiritual". it means "only understood by those with specialized knowledge". additionally I would refute your claim that the subconscious (or really anything to do with consciousness) is well understood by science. it is acknowledged as being a thing that exists and just as readily acknowledged as being a thing that is poorly understood, at least from a materialist science perspective. the models of consciousness that produce more thorough and well-explored theories tend to come from spiritual traditions, such as Buddhism, rather than materialist traditions.