5 ms·
Online adverts 'exploit homeless for sex'
- llukas 10y agoMore inequality -> more shit like this.
- Mz 10y agoThis is a good argument for more actually affordable housing, which has largely disappeared from the world.
- ams6110 10y agoOnly in some places. There are plenty of places in the US where two people can share a (very decent, safe, etc) two-bedroom apartment for $200-$300/month each.
- Mz 10y agoI fundamentally disagree with the idea that a single person should expect to share a two bedroom apartment in order to make housing affordable. Your idea of genuinely affordable and mine are not on the same page here.
- mikekchar 10y agoHas there ever been a time when you could get something similar to a modern one bedroom apartment with amenities for the equivalent of $2-300? Certainly not in my lifetime. That would be something like $30-40 in 1970, $80-100 in 1980 and $100-150 in 1990.
- Mz 10y agoNo, but things like SROs and boarding houses and just renting a room used to be far more common. In the 60s and 70s, something like 80% of SROs were torn down (in the US -- I realize the article is about the UK). In the US, SROs are now mostly slum housing for chronically homeless with addictions and mental health issues. This was not always true. They used to be a common way for a young person starting out to have a space of their own that they could afford. Our expectations for housing these days is very much rooted in norms that grew out of the Baby Boom generation. That generation was a huge anomaly and the way it has shaped policy and assumptions is hugely problematic.
- LyndsySimon 10y agoThese are some of the nicest apartments where I grew up - they're $400 / month for a one bedroom: http://www.lindseymanagement.com/cgi-bin/detail.cgi?type=apt&id=64#fp_499 http://www.lindseymanagement.com/cgi-bin/detail.cgi?type=apt... In terms of amenities... that price includes access to the golf course that they overlook.
- Jabanga 10y agoIf the landlords were just as poor as those desperate for a home, then everyone would be worse off, even though society would be more equal. The solution is to make society richer, so fewer people are desperate. The solution is not to remove one of the options that the desperate resort to. That only deals with the symptom of the problem. The problem is the desperation caused by low-income, and can only be reduced by increasing income.
- chillwaves 10y agoLess inequality does not mean the landlords will be poor. And wealth has been increasing at an accelerating pace, yet inequality continues to rise. The very poorest of the world may be lifted by capitalism, but not far and now those who were solidly middle class in the more successful economies are falling behind. Increasing income does nothing if it is funneled into the hands of the few while the many are forced into prostitution.
- Jabanga 10y agoMy point is that it's the low income of those who can't afford housing that is the problem, not the fact that others have higher income than them (not the fact that there's income inequality). If a causal relationship could be shown between reducing income inequality by way of redistribution by the government, and the lower income subset of the population seeing their income grow faster than it otherwise would, then such programs would be a viable solution to the problems the young people are facing, but only because of the effect it has on their income. I would argue that the evidence overwhelmingly suggests that all that things being held equal, the institution of socialist programs to redistribute income slows wage growth for all segments of society.
- Mz 10y agoIn all seriousness, a much, much bigger problem is the lack of actual affordable housing. In the 60s and 70s, something like 80% of SROs in the US were torn down. This is probably a side effect of the Baby Boom generation growing up awash in relative wealth. There is a global shortage of genuinely affordable, basic housing. With housing prices so insane, even a full time job can be inadequate to support a person. If we do not solve this, no amount of additional income will ever be enough. You can always just build bigger, more insane McMansions etc. until only billionaires can afford housing. The rest of us will be precariously housed at best unless and until we can reverse that trend.
- Jabanga 10y agoThis should be legal.
- Mz 10y agoThe deals, which are legal, are on classified ad sites such as craigslist. It apparently currently is legal. Did you mean illegal?
- Jabanga 10y agoNo I meant legal, as a politician in the article is quoted as saying they will introduce legislation to make it illegal.
- lsiebert 10y agoThis seems potentially exploitative, making it difficult to withdraw consent for sex, and would seem to fail to establish rights as a renter, at least here in the US, meaning they could potentially be kicked out at any time they refuse sex.
- Jabanga 10y agoYes I can definitely see a lot problems that can emerge from it, but making it illegal I think will cause more problems than it solves, and fundamentally goes against the principles of a free society. I do think desperate people are capable of providing informed consent. We shouldn't take their agency away from them (and if we do, we should do it officially, through the state becoming their ward). Also, it's often the case that making it illegal just pushes it further underground, where people have fewer protections.
- gech 10y agoAh, the conservative ilk favors power structures that demean other humans. No surprise.
- Jabanga 10y agoThat shows no faith in me as a human being.
- mason55 10y agoPlenty on the left would agree that this should be legal. And I think most people would agree that it's an undesirable outcome. The argument is usually around what the solution is.
- jliptzin 10y agoFrom the right, it should be legal because we don't need laws restricting what two consenting adults are doing. From the left, it should be legal because this can be interpreted as a kind of sex work, and making it illegal only sends it underground and creates more dangerous situations for sex workers.
- lsiebert 10y agoHmm... I think that the left is split on legalizing prostitution. But most sex positive liberals believe that prostitution and sex work should be legalized in ways that prevents coercion, and this seems to reinforce it. I mean, if you have a live in maid or nanny or cook, you may feed and house her, but you still have to pay her at least minimum wage, right? I think that's the difference between human slavery and a live in employee.
- bostik 10y ago> Hmm... I think that the left is split on legalizing prostitution. I remember arguing the complexity back in junior high - and my opinions on the matter have changed and become even more nuanced since then. 1) I personally believe that sex work should be decriminalised, with the caveat that: 2) Sex work cannot become an expected option for a profession The reason for my second point is that there is a very short and very steep slippery slope from that to the stage where job centres will turn into de facto brothel funnels. One ugly aspect of being an unemployed job seeker is that turning down job offers, even those where you don't have the matching qualifications, risks cutting off job seeker's allowance. I do not want to live in a world where such qualifications can be callously reduced to "breathes, has useful orifice(s)".
- TillE 10y agoIt's rare to see the exploitative nature of capitalism being expressed in terms so stark. This is not a stable system. We're spiraling towards ever-increasing inequality; things are bad, and they're only getting worse. You can make a law against this specific thing, but it doesn't really fix the problem. You have to change the path you're on.
- Terr_ 10y agoIn similar vein, you know those "happy rats don't become addicts" experiments? I wouldn't be surprised if future generations look back on our current drug-problems as an issue with how our socioeconomic system provides (or removes) a sense of agency, security, and belonging among different groups of humans.
- loeg 10y agoRat Park (the "happy rats don't become addicts" experiment) doesn't replicate.
- matthewmarkus 10y agoThis phenomenon has nothing to do with capitalism. It has to do with the fact that some human beings are incapable of forming healthy, loving relationships. Heck, even Karl Marx exploited his maid for sex [1]. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/1983/03/14/opinion/what-marx-hid.html http://www.nytimes.com/1983/03/14/opinion/what-marx-hid.html
- LyndsySimon 10y agoMy instinct is that this is not a bad thing. I don't imagine there are many people who would be willing to trade sex for housing now who wouldn't be willing to do so if it were illegal. I would not anticipate that a law would have a significant impact on the rate at which these arrangements occur. Assuming a law would have an impact, that impact would be to eliminate an option for housing for people who would by definition have very few others. I certainly find this sort of thing distasteful, but the bottom line for me is that people own their own bodies and third parties have no business interfering with voluntary exchange no matter how they feel about it personally.
- paulftw 10y agoI wonder what would Amnesty International say - they support decriminalization of sex work [1], this article seems to pull in the opposite direction. [1] https://www.amnesty.org/en/qa-policy-to-protect-the-human-rights-of-sex-workers/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/qa-policy-to-protect-the-human-ri...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chillwaves 10y agoThe aspect of victimization that comes with sex work is really embedded into capitalist society. If people were not compelled to work (basics like housing, food and medical taken care of) then sex work would truly become a choice and not an expression of oppression. Not to say it's never a choice, but we have to acknowledge the underlying struggle that often comes with it (homelessness, drug abuse, broken homes, no viable source of income).
- Mz 10y ago... but we have to acknowledge the underlying struggle that often comes with it (homelessness, drug abuse, broken homes, no viable source of income). Being a woman. (I wasn't actually joking. Men typically make vastly more than women and housing is crazy expensive...etc. Anyone care to explain the downvote? Poverty has been well documented as being an overwhelmingly female issue.)
- chillwaves 10y agoThank you for helping me understand. I did not think from that perspective.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoI don't know if I agree that it does. There's a difference between being in control of sex work, and entering into a situation that is potentially exploitative, difficult to exit, and might become unwilling in time. The article has one case, and I have personal familiarity of helping with another. Like I said though, I don't know. The legal response from the article is a gray area to me.
- ksikka 10y agoHow is this legal? It's just one step away from prostitution. The payment here is not $ but a penny saved is a penny earned. Maybe this is technically legal but it seems against the spirit of the law.
- cperciva 10y agoIs this really all that different from when women would select partners largely based on whether they were "good providers"? Humans have been trading sex for food and shelter for thousands of years. It might be slightly more explicit now, but I don't see that any fundamental change has occurred.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nvr219 10y agoYes it is different.
- Mz 10y agoI could argue both sides of this. I was a homemaker and full time mom for a lot of years. I am currently homeless. I have turned down multiple offers to move in with some guy or similar, in part due to my concerns about how that can lead to loss of agency and can lead to someone being trapped. I think the real issue is, as I have said twice elsewhere here, that housing prices are insane and this is fueling a general rise in homelessness. Things like that always impact the most vulnerable the worst. I am for the decriminalization of sex work. If I were not medically handicapped and if I thought I could make it work, I would seriously consider moving to Nevada and taking up sex work to pay off my debts and come up with a down payment for a house. I don't think that would work for me personally and I do understand why there is a great hue and cry about putting people in positions where they are de facto forced into sex work. I get why this is click bait, but it is hard to have a reasoned discussion about such subjects, for a lot of reasons.
- rabboRubble 10y agoThank you for sharing details about your life. Sending positive thoughts in your direction. Good luck~
- cjcenizal 10y agoThis article describes how some people's best survival option is to give control of their body to someone else. I think anyone with empathy would agree that's a bad thing.
- ams6110 10y agoWhatever happened to self-respect?
- Analemma_ 10y agoSelf-respect is an abstract concept, and abstract concepts quickly become devalued when, for example, it's below freezing at night in winter and you don't have a roof over your head.
- mistermann 10y agoRendered powerless by self-esteem and practicality perhaps?
- LyndsySimon 10y agoSelf-respect is a luxury. I'm a man in my 30s with a wife and kids. If my best option to keep a roof over their heads was to have sex with the landlord, I would absolutely choose that over their being homeless.