5 ms·
This is the classic downside of open source that's supported by a "pro" edition: it encourages maintainers to actively avoid adding features that would compete
by simonw 10y ago
This is the classic downside of open source that's supported by a "pro" edition: it encourages maintainers to actively avoid adding features that would compete with the paid product.
- inopinatus 10y agoThis is similar to the classic blunder by service product strategists who tier pricing by both capability and scale, rather than one or the other. This results in nonselection of the product rather than the hoped-for upsell.
- exhilaration 10y ago"Nonselection"? Did you see the HN post a few days ago [1] about Nginx reaching 33% market share? They seem to be doing very well. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14078589 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14078589
- user5994461 10y agoIt's simply replacing Apache that is old and deprecated. Nothing fancy.
- inopinatus 10y agoMarkets are measured in dollars, not usage. The last press release I read from Nginx* says they have barely more than 1,000 paying customers, and shied away from real revenue numbers, but I doubt anyone would place a bet that it is on the order of magnitude of revenues due to e.g. IIS on Windows Server, or even the revenues that Oracle & IBM collect for their rebadged Apache. * https://www.nginx.com/press/nginx-carries-strong-business-momentum-2017/ https://www.nginx.com/press/nginx-carries-strong-business-mo...
- toufka 10y agoCurious - for us non-strategists could you give another sentence explaining your thought here. I don't quite get why scaling both would prevent a sale - but it appears like hard-earned insight.
- inopinatus 10y agoSure. And yes it is. Bear in mind my perspective is mostly SaaS B2B. Two perspectives on this: 1. Some of my smallest customers are actually lighthouse customers for the rest of their industry. When they can't afford a price-segmented "enterprise" feature then I miss out on their super valuable product feedback and word-of-mouth. I've seen this pattern in sport, telecoms, public transport, k-12 education. About the only place I haven't seen it is the financial sector. I have been both the customer missing out and the provider in this scenario. 2. If a large enterprise is prepared to buy many units, but won't use your high end features, they can just pay for the cheaper end unit. You likely just missed out on revenue. They may well have been interested in later adoption of your more sophisticated stuff, but because they bought the cheap product it'll never happen because at scale the cost step function of going up a tier is perceived super negatively. So you also miss out on feature adoption and product feedback. I have only been the customer in this scenario. I have seen it in both the financial sector and government. It almost happens in healthcare, but they are easily manipulated into higher price segments by placing HIPAA compliance stuff there. NB: Personally I find that kind of manipulation to be toxically abhorrent and when I've been the customer used it as a red flag against doing business. Nonetheless it is common. Overall- To me, business strategy is all about the creation and capture of value. When you find a product model that creates a virtuous cycle between those two aspects of value, you likely have a winner. The best example I can give validating my experience is AWS, where everyone can use everything on a pay-as-you-go basis. I have been both a customer and on the inside with AWS. The model is incredibly empowering for startups having access to this massive box of capability, and moreover enables enterprises to do long-term planning of feature adoption with price stability. The only time I recommend charging more for an enterprise feature is because it costs you significantly more to deliver it and there is no other way to capture your share of the value created or use scale to drive down the marginal cost of delivery. A wise PM will want to separate that out into a separate product. A classic example is providing a TAM over and above your hopefully already universally excellent support desk. The counter-example to this point of view might be Slack. I cannot fathom why they both tier their capabilities and then charge per seat. Hard to see how SSO and AD sync adds to marginal cost per customer seat, and the storage and uptime promises are similarly paper thin value adds. It is one of the reasons I never recommend them. Yet they are apparently successful, perhaps because their product is crack for dev teams. So execution certainly still matters. And no doubt other counter-examples can be easily found. But if you want to maximise your market engagement, it is essential to know how your customers behave in the product selection process in response to the signals you give them. Sorry that was more than one sentence. I was waiting for a compile.
- MichaelGG 10y agoAny citations or info on tiering by features and scale being wrong? Do you mean as two independent axis? Most services I see combine both features and scale. "Enterprise" features (like logging, RBAC, etc.) are available along with the highest volume plans.
- inopinatus 10y agoI'd say they're correlated, which is part of the reason the fallacy arises. But the coefficient is different for every customer, so unless you're in a market with homogeneous buyers, any segmentation you devise is very likely to be wrong for almost everyone. See my longer answer nearby for some pathological examples.
- frik 10y agoTrue. Nginx got very popular when it was open source, without a company-face behind it. It's a classic example, how some company do it. If Nginx would have been Pro-supported from the start Nginx would never got that much traction. It's just sad, as server status is a bare essential feature, that all competitors offer for free, yet with Nginx one would have to pay $2,500/year/server to get it (plus running a binary blob with useless additional features instead open source edition). I don't get why parent got down-voted. He is absolutely right. What's wrong with the confused downvoters?
- izietto 10y agoNginx Pro enthusiasts / company owners I guess
- scrollaway 10y agonginx pro has been around for longer than nginx has been popular, so no.
- frik 10y agoWrong. First the company only offered professional support. Nginx was completely open source. Look at the website how it looked like in 2012: https://web-beta.archive.org/web/20120603095936/http://nginx.com:80/prod.html https://web-beta.archive.org/web/20120603095936/http://nginx...
- scrollaway 10y agoNGINX Plus has been around since at least 2014 if not longer. Your theory makes no sense, the server has been rising in popularity even faster since. AFAIK the Plus version is just not something people care about but its also never had any impact on the open source one. And as a strong advocate of open source I find it extremely annoying when users find reasons to complain about friendly models for monetization of such software. :/
- thresh 10y agoIt's not like nginx-the-company and nginx-the-opensource-project are different people. It's not that "some company" just overtook the project and now is milking the users.