5 ms·
Goodbye Things, Hello Minimalism
- angersock 10y agoI really can't shake the feeling that a lot of the minimalism drive is just exceptionally clever advertising that promotes consumption for a group whose income is small enough that they won't fall prey to the normal consumerism memes.
- CuriouslyC 10y agoI don't think so. While the new economic reality is probably a big driver of the current trends towards minimalism, it actually works. The hedonic treadmill is real - having more stuff doesn't permanently make you more happy. In fact, it has the opposite effect, to the degree that you have to use up valuable free time to clean/organize/maintain that stuff.
- mikestew 10y agoMy conspiracy theory is that if I sell you a thing, I can sell it to you once. However, if I can get you to buy into minimalism and instead spend your money on "experiences" (the current trend, AFAICT), I can sell you experiences over and over and...
- behnamoh 10y agoApple does get you into "experiencing" their products. The trick is, once you're in, you're most probably going to stay. This is clever strategy.
- coldtea 10y ago>However, if I can get you to buy into minimalism and instead spend your money on "experiences" (the current trend, AFAICT), I can sell you experiences over and over and... First of all, those 2 sellers are not the same companies/persons. Second, minimalists buy fewer things in general -- including not buying experiences, except if you mean something like e.g. travelling. But it's not airline companies that promote minimalism. Experience is indeed a selling point in modern markets -- but it's not targeted to minimalists, but to people who consume anyway (they now can add experiences to their consumption).
- Delmania 10y agoHere's a good critique of it: http://www.artofmanliness.com/2014/07/31/the-problem-with-minimalism/ http://www.artofmanliness.com/2014/07/31/the-problem-with-mi... Minimalism makes the same attribution of wealth and possessions to happiness as consumerism does. The difference is that minimalists eschew possessions in favor of experiences. For them, saying they don't have a lot of possessions is the same as someone bragging about their new car and tv.
- coldtea 10y agoI've learned from a much wiser person this, and it has been proven super illuminating: it's not the similarities that matter between two things, it's the differences. For some things it might not hold, but it's not like everything and its inverse are basically the same just because they share a common domain (e.g. racism and anti-racism both are focused on race). It's what they get from there, and how they differ that defines their value. Applied in this case, that "Minimalism makes the same attribution of wealth and possessions to happiness as consumerism does" is irrelevant. It's whether it's a positive or a negative attribution that matters.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lolsal 10y agoI do not understand minimalism or minimalist culture. When I see rationalizations about getting rid of 'stuff', I can understand some of those things, but at some point for me there is a line where minimalism becomes some sort of self-congratulatory narcissism. I enjoy having friends over - playing board games, video games, cooking meals together, watching movies together, etc. All of that requires some sort of 'stuff': the board game, the television, the kitchen with more than 1 plate. I have more 'stuff', but I am not unhappier for it. The stuff enriches my life through experiences that I have with that stuff. The author seems pre-occupied with financial concerns - rent for his apartment, cost of cars and clothes - it seems he may be getting more benefit out of the financial security that this minimalism has afforded him than any sort of actual enlightenment through lack of 'stuff'.
- Delmania 10y agoThis was a telling quote from the article: >I broke up with my girlfriend, telling her I couldn’t see a future for us in my sad financial state. Minimalism holds the same attachment to physical possessions that consumerism does, but it associates negatives feelings as opposed to positive ones. It's like love and hate. Hate is not the opposite of love, but the other end of the spectrum. Rather than getting a sense of self worth from having things, he's getting a sense of self worth from NOT having things. The opposite of consumerism is a person who's happy with the stuff he has. When the opportunity arises to get something nicer, he takes advantage of it, but he doesn't actively go out and buy something new. Sure, that person may feel a twinge of jealously at people having nicer things, but he simply lets those emotions pass without acting on them. Acceptance and detachment.
- amalag 10y agoStill accumulating many things. Many yen in the bank.
- mikhailfranco 10y agoPaper financial assets are not a good store of wealth, especially a fiat currency of a bankrupt country facing demographic collapse, which is printing cash to monetize and inflate both the equity and bond markets (i.e. most 'western' countries). I think your Yen may have a minimalist future. Buy gold instead.
- k__ 10y agoI threw out many things last month and my friends were like "Ah, so you are into this whole Minimalism stuff now?" Didn't even know about this. But yes, I have the feeling that things own me and not the other way around...
- pbnjay 10y agoI don't know - he's just changed perspective. It's still about how few things he has compared to others. This was a fault in his mind before, but he's turned it into a strength. In the end, it's the same psychology though. He's still comparing himself to others, only now he can justify feeling good about where he is in the comparison. Seems like it'd be better psychologically to just stop comparing yourself to others. You get to enjoy your "stuff" without restricting the activities you can do or putting the onus on others... Renting or borrowing things has an additional cost that will bear itself out in the long-term.
- tutufan 10y agoContra here. I've been whittling down my physical possessions over the years, and during a messy LTR split last year, rather than try to deal with all of my possessions, I ditched pretty much everything that was replaceable or not regularly used. Everything I have left fits in a couple of suitcases, maybe less. It does feel like a great weight has been lifted. I don't think of myself as hardcore particularly. I rent a furnished place, and "rent" my transportation. (I even rent my primary dev CPUs and storage, in the cloud.) There's nothing wrong with having a lot of stuff, but there is a mental cost to it. It's somewhat difficult to imagine putting up with a lot of possessions now. YMMV.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]