4 ms·
> Many of those who would receive help are most concerned in making sure there's still someone else in a worse situation than themselves. This is true and expl
by ryandrake 10y ago
> Many of those who would receive help are most concerned in making sure there's still someone else in a worse situation than themselves.
This is true and explains a lot of situations where people seemingly vote against their own self-interest. The fact that responders choose to reject in the Ultimatum Game[1] shows this in action.
But an even more fascinating example than the ultimatum game (sorry can't find the link) is research that shows subjects are willing to pay money to burn the money of others, just so the other test subject ends up with less. For example, offer to give test subject A $10, tell him that you're giving subject B $20, and then give subject A the option of giving up $2 of those $10 just to reduce the subject B's gift from $20 to $5. It was found that a percentage of people will be willing to accept that choice even though it's not the action of someone with rational economic self-interest.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game
- krapht 10y agoI dislike people who claim it's not in a respondent's self-interest to do this; that it's somehow irrational. Status is relative - as the old saying goes, it is better to rule in Hell than serve in Heaven.
- chc 10y agoThat's literally Satan explaining his MO in a poem.
- kirubakaran 10y agoI have to say I'm happy to call out your ad hominem there, which makes me the devil's advocate. Do you disagree with Mr Satan's point or do you reject it simply because it comes from him?
- thomastjeffery 10y agoTo elaborate, it's Satan's MO as described by a person. Since ipso facto, Satan, conceptually described by a person, acts solely against each individual's well-being, the poem is meant to describe this reasoning as detrimental to the individual. So to respond to your question, I do disagree with "Satan's" point. It is clearly in the interest of an individual to keep all of what they are given, rather than to spend a portion simply to lower the portion given to another. Along the same train of thought, I would say, "The least of us can achieve greater heights when lifting each other up, than the greatest of us can by pushing each other down."
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoBut that saying, authored by Milton in Paradise Lost, is ascribed to Lucifer/Satan. Not exactly a fountain of wisdom and good judgement. Also, Milton wasn't particularly orthodox, but in conventional Christian theology Satan is not said to rule in Hell- he suffers with the rest of us. In an absolute sense, though, it would only be better to rule in Hell than to serve in Heaven if the status of a servant in Heaven was worse than that of a ruler in Hell. Status is relative, but not only relative to the other participants in the study - it's relative to the entire population. I'd prefer to get $10 and have one neighbor get $20 than $8 and $5, because the wealth of millions of people establish the price of goods to me, not one person getting a little more. In a world where a million people get $0, I get $10, and someone else gets $20, I'm relatively wealthier than if a million people still got $0, I got $8, and my neighbor got $5. Yeah, it might be more economically rational to seek to get $8 million if the entire world was going to get $20 million if I didn't take the option, but then there's the old saying "a rising tide lifts all boats..."
- colanderman 10y ago> Not exactly a fountain of wisdom and good judgement. But certainly a font of great insight into base human desire, according to many traditions. It's why "a deal with the Devil" is a trope: the Devil knows exactly what to offer humans in exchange for corruption. So, the GP's quote is apt: an offer to "rule in Hell" vs. "serve in Heaven" is indeed a tempting one for many people.
- sp332 10y agoQuote aside, I think you're right. America was founded on certain principles of equality, because that makes for a better society. For example, titles and aristocracy are banned in the Constitution. It's better to avoid making second-class citizens.
- vkou 10y ago> America was founded on certain principles of equality Very limited principles of equality. Slavery, natives, women, unlanded peasants...
- sp332 10y agoThat's true, but it's also true that we've worked to reduce those inequalities instead of pretending that they don't really hurt anybody.
- purple-again 10y agoWe don't know that its irrational. If you don't like the other person, you get personal satisfaction from hurting them. The satisfaction of hurting them is worth more to you then the utility of the money you are giving up. Perfectly rational.
- abraves10001 10y agoThat and their relative amount of money is greater. Would I rather have 60% more money than someone or half as much as someone? I'm not saying it's the best decision but there are rational explanations.
- enahs-sf 10y agoWhen I read this, I just imagine John Nash spinning in his grave.