4 ms·
> In the US, before the iPhone, the carriers (Verizon, AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile) had an ironclad grip on the rest of the value chain – particularly, handset make
by wvenable 16y ago
> In the US, before the iPhone, the carriers (Verizon, AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile) had an ironclad grip on the rest of the value chain – particularly, handset makers and app makers.
This is like one of those myths where if you say it enough time, people start to believe it. There were tons of smartphones available before the iPhone that let you install any software that you wanted. My first smartphone was the Sony Ericsson P800 and it was released in 2002! I had to change carriers to use to, too.
The original iPhone was a great device with a wonderful interface, but it wasn't the invention of the smartphone. It did, however, sell the mainstream consumer market on smartphones. (The business market was long sold on the Blackberry).
The author isn't completely wrong -- the explosive growth of smartphones (and not just iPhones) has completely changed the equation. Before, everyone was trying to get on the carriers dumb phones but even if they succeeded it would mostly be a waste of time -- the phones were just too dumb and nobody cared about the crappy experience they provided.
There is way too much credit to Apple and Steve Jobs here.
- dieterrams 16y agoYou might be able to install any software you want, but the on-phone app stores and what they carry have been controlled by the carriers. That's the primary distribution channel, and the one largely responsible for providing app makers with the financial incentive to make apps.
- wvenable 16y agoBefore the iPhone, smartphones didn't have on-phone app stores. You downloaded/purchased your applications off the web just like you do on your desktop. There was a good market for software for smartphones with lots of developers and distributors. The article would have us believe that none of that existed before Steve Jobs but that's just not true. Dumb phones had carrier stores (and their firmware heavily customized). However, nobody I know has ever bought app for their regular 'dumb' mobile phone. Even the apps that were for free (like music players) were so horrible that they usually went unused.
- dieterrams 16y agoReally? Granted, I never paid much attention to smart phones before the iPhone, but I find it hard to believe that none of them had on-phone app stores. At any rate, games on dumb phones were definitely making money (I remember reading plenty of articles about how mobile phone gaming was getting huge pre-iPhone), and if you wanted to sell your dumb phone game, you had to go through the carriers.
- wvenable 16y ago> but I find it hard to believe that none of them had on-phone app stores. They didn't. Carriers didn't really do too much to smartphones -- there was some customization (theme, background picture, etc) but that was it. Software is (and was) sold just as it is on the desktop. > if you wanted to sell your dumb phone game, you had to go through the carriers. There were tons of high quality games available for smartphones (including from big firms like EA) years before the iPhone was released. There was no on-phone store and you didn't have to go through the carrier. The iPhone popularized the smartphone, changing the equation from the dumb phone to the smartphone. But if Apple didn't do it, someone else would have -- Android was in development (and already purchased by Google) years before the iPhone was released, for example.
- dieterrams 16y agoIt's doubtful Android would have had the same impact as the iPhone if the iPhone hadn't existed. I can no longer find the source, but Android's interface pre-iPhone was just as uninspired as all the other smartphones around at the time. It would've taken considerably longer for other companies to hit on a genuinely good touch screen interface if they hadn't had Apple's example to follow.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoEven I knew about the potential of multi-touch interfaces 18 months before the iPhone was released due to this TED talk. I'm guessing people who actually work with touch displays are well aware of the decades of published research on this topic. http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/jeff_han_demos_his_breakthrough_touchscreen.html http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/jeff_han_demos_his_breakth... Note that when Steve Jobs demos the pinch zoom nearly two years later he claims it as an Apple invention, while this guy as nearly his first comment is to name people who have worked on this technology for decades but says that the big difference now is that it's ready for production use.
- clark-kent 16y agoYes I remember handango.com was the popular appstore for my HP ipaq smartphone. Anyone could develop Windows Mobile or Java apps and sell it there.