4 ms·
1. Thanks for engaging, rather than down voting. 2. It is, indeed, hard to judge without having established the facts. But resisting a captain's (or, by extens
by FabHK 10y ago
1. Thanks for engaging, rather than down voting.
2. It is, indeed, hard to judge without having established the facts. But resisting a captain's (or, by extension, flight crew's) order, or the orders of the owner of the airplane, is in itself illegal and, frankly, immature. Running onto the plane again after having been "dragged off" and muttering "Just kill me" seems to point to possible mental issues, but again, it's hard to tell without further information.
More measured pieces, such as this one [1], state "It appears from the evidence that the law was broken – by him, not by the airline."
[1] http://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/united-airlines-flight-3411-video-overbooking-chicago-louisville-security-passenger-denied-boarding-a7677601.html http://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/united-a...
- bdhe 10y ago> Running onto the plane again after having been "dragged off" and muttering "Just kill me" seems to point to possible mental issues, You realize this could be because of the concussion he might have suffered earlier, don't you? Rather cruel thing to throw out there as an accusation after reviewing the video of the incident.
- FabHK 10y agoCould be, yes. But again, the whole thing would not have happened if he had just disembarked as told.
- coralreef 10y agoHaha. And everyone who ever got their ass beat by the police should have just did as they were told. Even if they were in the legal right, or racially profiled, or whatever.
- FabHK 10y agoBut the crew was legally right. And at any rate, the airplane is not the place to have that dispute, legal or otherwise - you follow the captain's (and by extension, crew's) orders, and then you review it later.
- coralreef 10y agoThe crew was legally right only inasmuch so as the captain can order anyone off his/her plane, legally. If you're brown and a passenger doesn't like you, they can report you to the crew with some trumped up reason and the captain will order you off (which has happened). What's your legal recourse? None.
- gus_massa 10y agoIn a similar situation, if someone is pointing at you with a gun in a dark alley and ask nicely for you wallet, then the more sensible reaction is to give your wallet. Sometimes it's not the same sensible, legal and right.
- openasocket 10y agoAccording to witnesses, he said he was a doctor who had patients he had to see the following day, and there wasn't another flight to Louisville for 36 hours. The crew is supposed to make an informed decision about these things, and clearly made a random and arbitrary choice and refused to back down. They may have been in the right legally, but certainly not morally.
- FabHK 10y agoThe whole point was that the decision is random, in the name of justice. They have some criteria to exclude people from the bad lottery (disabled people and their care takers, unaccompanied minors), and then may apply a ranking based on booking class, frequent flyer status, and check-in time. But here, the claim is that pax were chosen randomly. Many people have good reasons to be on a plane, and this passenger being a doctor should not have any bearing on the resolution of the problem at hand (except insofar as it should've compelled other pax to take the 800 USD and hotel room and volunteer for disembarkation).
- gotothedoctor 10y agoWhy shouldn't the passenger's role as a doctor have any bearing? If an airline must choose passengers to disembark, shouldn't doctors (& nurses) be the last people you'd remove?
- FabHK 10y agoBecause the check-in area or airplane is not the place to argue about the relative merits of different professions or importance of appointments. The airline has its criteria (which might include random choice) and is entitled to use them.
- vacri 10y ago> and is entitled to use them. And we're entitled to roast them for doing so when we think they've done wrong.
- newman314 10y agoMuttering "Just kill me" does not immediately mean a conclusion of possible mental issues. After all, the guy just had his face smashed against an armrest so it's not beyond the realm of imagination that he would a) be traumatized and b) have a concussion. So rather than us armchair quarterbacking it, why not let more of the facts solidify before passing judgement? PS. I'm not sure if I would say that the article you linked to counts as "measured". Here's a different article (comes with citation of United's Contract of Carriage): https://thefederalist.com/2017/04/11/did-united-airlines-violate-its-own-contract-by-forcing-that-passenger-off-the-plane/ https://thefederalist.com/2017/04/11/did-united-airlines-vio...
- FabHK 10y agoAgreed, we need more facts. But until then the uncritical condemnation of United is as unjustified as condemnation of the passenger (which I might have engaged in, to an extent - but for now I still think he should have just disembarked, or possibly pleaded with the other pax to volunteer, but not refuse). In my view, the Independent article gives the "received wisdom", while the article you linked is from a (self-professed) non-expert reading the conditions of carriage and doing some hairsplitting there. Edit: Independent, not Telegraph
- newman314 10y agoThat makes no sense. From what I can tell, The Independent article was not sourced from an expert either so your attempt to show that the Independent article has more "weight" does not back things up. Here's an article quoting an aviation attorney: http://www.philly.com/philly/columnists/stu_bykofsky/United-Airlines-right-is-wrong-for-passengers-.html http://www.philly.com/philly/columnists/stu_bykofsky/United-... "Under certain conditions, airlines can bar passengers from boarding - if the passenger is unruly or intoxicated or on a terrorist watch list - but United had no right to remove Dao, says aviation law expert Arthur Wolk, a Center City attorney who read the 45-page “contract of carriage.” Wolk says Dao “absolutely” had the right to the seat, and this was not a case of “overbooking,” he says, because all the passengers had seats. What happened to Dao was “assault and battery,” he says. “There’s absolutely no humanity left in the airline business,” Wolk says, adding that United routinely finishes low in surveys of passenger satisfaction. “I would sue their asses off.” Is there any question that Dao is going to sue? John Banzhaf, a professor at the George Washington University Law School, agrees with Wolk’s analysis. He says United is “citing the wrong federal rule to justify its illegal request to force a passenger already boarded and seated to disembark.”" Regardless of the outcome, I would hope that people will agree that injury in a case like this is not deserved and not just "too bad, he didn't behave himself".
- joshuamorton 10y agoSo, I'm a nonexpert, not going to source this, and am repeating hearsay. Salt this comment to taste, but: While I won't dispute that the moment he refused to deplane, he violated the law (you're required to follow the instructions of flight crew), the request that he be removed was also a violation of UA policy from what I've seen. Here's some things that I've read - He had previously volunteered to deboard, until he learned that it would be such a long delay - This was not a case of overbooking, the 4 people added to the flight were United Employees, not overbooked passengers. - UA policy states that airline employees will be the first people bumped from a flight in the case that it is overbooked - (According to someone on reddit, so extra salt:) All of the overbooking regulations have to do with seat assignments. You shouldn't get bumped once you're assigned a seat, much less seated, and doing so may be a breach of regulations by United. If that's the case, then the crew were absolutely breaching UA policy when he was removed, and they may have been breaching federal regulations when they asked him to deplane. To be clear, that's no excuse for refusing to deplane (even if he knew he was in the right), but it's not as simple as "he was disruptive" if the request for him to leave was illegal.
- FabHK 10y agoGood points. Hadn't heard half of them. As for the 4 employees - there is staff travel for personal reasons (ID travel, interline discount, heavily discounted, stand-by), where you have lower priority than paying pax. There is booked staff travel, where you have intermediate priority. But then there is travel for operational reasons (positioning), where you have higher priority, because if you don't get there, a whole planeload of pax (and more, due to knock-on effects) won't fly. So, the number of available seats was reduced, and insofar it was overbooking. And certainly all this should have been sorted out before boarding, no doubt, and normally is. (Apparently only 6 in 100,000 pax or so are IDB, by the way.) But imagine a seatbelt turns out to be broken, or the wind is so strong that they have to load more fuel and reduce weight, or whatever. Then there's a seat less, for operational reasons, and someone has to leave, even if they had boarded already.
- vacri 10y ago> This was not a case of overbooking, the 4 people added to the flight were United Employees, not overbooked passengers. If a plane has X seats, but the carrier has assigned X+4 bums for those seats, then it's a case of overbooking.
- fatal510 10y agoWhen did he say "Just kill me" must have missed that clip. The one of him running back on to the plane clearly concussed and not in a normal state of mind has him saying "I need to go home".