4 ms·
It's only talking about religious people; extrapolating religious norms to the whole ethnicity is kind of unfair.
by golergka 10y ago
It's only talking about religious people; extrapolating religious norms to the whole ethnicity is kind of unfair.
- M_Grey 10y ago...Especially when about a fifth of said ethnicity is basically atheistic as well; quite a diverse bunch really, from ultra-orthodox 'Haredi' to a purely cultural identity.
- jimmyk 10y agoquite a diverse bunch really In comparison to who?
- M_Grey 10y agoCompared to the GP's "Jewish men..." notion, as though that were a useful group descriptor when it comes to behaviors. So, I suppose... compared to the often monolithic notions of Judaism that I so often encounter on and offline.
- jimmyk 10y agoas though that were a useful group descriptor when it comes to behaviors. I found it to be useful. In combination with some other comments, it gave me a particular idea about what the article was about.
- gumby 10y agostrict grammarians, for instance, who would only have considered using "whom" in your sentence.
- gwbas1c 10y agoChristianity, where the definition effectively prohibits someone from being both an atheist and a christian.
- jimmyk 10y agoSo the claim then is that there is greater diversity in thought about whether or not a deity exists among an ethnic group than among a group for which membership is contingent on thinking a deity exists? I don't think that conveys very much information, except that there is not perfect uniformity among ethnic Jews on the issue.
- M_Grey 10y agoTo be fair, I'm not sure that Islam is too enthusiastic about atheists proclaiming for it either... to put it mildly.
- mturmon 10y ago"There is no god but God" does seem to offer some wiggle room for atheists, but maybe that's an inadvertent loophole.
- M_Grey 10y agoIt might, but I think the current climate in much of the Islamic world, while not the crazed image many have, is actually pretty brutal to people within the religion who are seen as blasphemous. From what I know, and I have to admit that this isn't as much as I'd like, the process of proclaiming your faith pretty much involves accepting the existence of god, prophets, the "punishment of the grave," that kind of thing. My impression is that if you're seen to have lied about that, you're lucky just to be outcast. tl;dr It really doesn't pay to be seen as an "apostate" in Islam, at least in most places at this time.
- DanBC 10y ago> From what I know, and I have to admit that this isn't as much as I'd like In general when you're talking about a group of a billion people you should avoid generalisations, especially if you also need to say that you don't know what you're talking about.
- dang 10y agoFortunately, since the article is about the 13th and 14th centuries, it's doing nothing of the sort. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14088376 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14088376 and marked it off-topic.