7 ms·
While going from a blog-to-acquisition in less than a year is an impressive feat, there have been suspicious circumstances around IndieHackers submissions to Ha
by minimaxir 10y ago
While going from a blog-to-acquisition in less than a year is an impressive feat, there have been suspicious circumstances around IndieHackers submissions to Hacker News including clickbait titles that are frequently fixed by HN mods, and in one case, explicit voting manipulation with an attempt to bypass the voting ring detector via linking to /newest: http://i.imgur.com/08pAFOw.jpg http://i.imgur.com/08pAFOw.jpg
This acquisition sends a disappointing message that growth hacking works.
- canistr 10y agoI do recall this submission and commenting on the ridiculous nature of it. But I wouldn't say it was voting manipulation so much as people who may not be familiar with markets voting up something they saw that used neural nets. The disappointing part was that Allen chose to be defensive instead of admitting a mistake on his submission vetting process.
- ag_47 10y agoInteresting. Don't hate the player, hate game, though. welcome to the jungle.
- throwaway88743 10y agoAs long as Stripe knows what they bought. The way I see it, they didn't buy a popular website, but a determined person willing to do anything to get what he wants.
- sanswork 10y agoYou make it sound like he's murdering people to get ahead not that he is targeting a social network with content that is generally relevant and popular. The anything in this case is focused promotion.
- throwaway88744 10y ago> You make it sound like he's murdering people You are putting words into my mouth. He clearly wrote: > I've made a ton of submissions in the past 8 months and experimented with various combinations of stories/titles that the HN audience might like, without always being successful. (Probably one out of every 4-5 submissions turned into an angry mob haha) 20%-25% of his submissions made readers angry. Nevertheless he kept going and tried, by his own admission, to micro-optimise his submissions to get visibility. Maybe my sense of ethics is different than yours, but please don't put words in my mouth.
- holtalanm 10y agoso by your logic he should not do whatever he can to create the most effective submission possible? That seems counter-intuitive since really all HN cares about in the end is quality content.
- minimaxir 10y ago> so by your logic he should not do whatever he can to create the most effective submission possible? Ideally without breaking the HN rules.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sanswork 10y agoGiven the number of posts on HN these days that seem to spur a mob of angry people I'm not even sure 20-25% is a bad figure. You said he's willing to do anything when what you meant was he is willing to work on optimising his work to better appeal to a specific target community. How does that negatively impact there community exactly? My sense of ethics precludes me from creating a temp account to mask my own identity while attacking someone else online so I guess you're right that our ethics differ.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- draw_down 10y agoAnyone else suspect "clickbait" is now the #1 most-used word in HN comments?
- minimaxir 10y agoThis is one of the rare instances where it is correctly used. (In IH's case, submission titles with explicit dollar amounts, which also breaks the HN rule about using original titles) EDIT: Apparently an exception was made in this case.
- sboselli 10y agoIs that rule really enforced though? Should it? I constantly see submissions here that do not use the original title. In fact, I have noticed that some/most of the time (I regularly save links from here in a personal db) the altered titles do a better job of summarizing the article than the original title. It happens to me all the time that I choose to save the link using HN's title instead of the original (better results when using it as tags). If there is such a rule, it might merit more/finer discussion.
- minimaxir 10y agoFrom the guidelines: > If the original title begins with a number or number + gratuitous adjective, we'd appreciate it if you'd crop it. E.g. translate "10 Ways To Do X" to "How To Do X," and "14 Amazing Ys" to "Ys." Exception: when the number is meaningful, e.g. "The 5 Platonic Solids." > Otherwise please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait. The mods have been pretty good about making edits when appropriate.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoI'd like to contact you, but don't see any contact details on your profile. Can i?
- hoschicz 10y agoWhat's the problem with linking to /newest? I'm new to spam and abuse on HN
- minimaxir 10y agoThere isn't a legitimate reason to link to /newest unless it's to promote your submission, which in itself is against the HN rules. (there is the belief that people who vote in a submission via /newest do not trip voting ring detectors like that of direct links, but that is false)
- tedmiston 10y agoIs a voting ring defined by people being friends, in a similar geolocation, voting at a similar time, voting together consistently historically, or what? In other words, what distinguishes a voting ring from simply a group of users with similar interests or a small niche community?
- crazypyro 10y agoLinking to /newest appears to many HN users to just be a way around directly linking to their article. I don't know enough about the voting manipulation detection implementation on HN, but I'd imagine a bunch of accounts hitting a direct link to an article and upvoting it could potentially be more suspicious than having them all click the article from /newest or just upvote from there. FWIW as an anecdote, I've seen HN voting manipulation kick in quite hard when people link directly to submissions.
- rhapsodic 10y agoI think I recall reading somewhere that the upvotes a story gets on the /newest page weigh more heavily in promoting the story to the top main pages, than the upvotes a story will invariably get when its on one of the first few main pages. I don't have a reference for that, however, and I don't know if it is true or not.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- csallen 10y agoThe HN community has been a big part of Indie Hackers, even helping me come up with the idea for the site in the first place. I've made a ton of submissions in the past 8 months and experimented with various combinations of stories/titles that the HN audience might like, without always being successful. (Probably one out of every 4-5 submissions turned into an angry mob haha) To speak specifically to your point about the titles, an essential element of Indie Hackers is that I require companies to share revenue numbers, because it really adds context to their stories (although it is certainly clickbaity, too). The mods actually okay'd me adding revenue numbers to submission titles[1], but I've mostly avoided it with recent submissions. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13074125 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13074125
- pc86 10y agoOne has to wonder if 20-25% of your submissions make people angry if you're doing the right thing. But hey you're the one with the acquisition, not me. So great job!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Denzel 10y agoWhen the win column is bigger than the loss column, you're a winning team.
- OJFord 10y agoGetting shutout 25% doesn't mean you're winning 75%.
- woodrowbarlow 10y agoThe thing about Arsenal is, they always try and walk it in!
- 10y ago
- par 10y agoLooks like the end justifies the means.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- geofft 10y agoSpeaking as a random HN user (but I suspect I am not alone in this opinion), I rather dislike HN's approach to anti-vote-manipulation, and so I don't see the message as disappointing. (If anything, vote manipulation / growth hacking is perfectly within the HN mindset: there's this entrenched organization that controls access for no other reason than that they got entrenched, and people are finding innovative technical means to get past the policies.)
- pault 10y agoWhat? No, the "entrenched organization" that regulates voting rings exists to keep HN from turning into a morass of marketing puff. The quality of the submissions and comments are literally the only thing of value here.
- geofft 10y agoYou can do that by restricting voting to established users with nonzero karma, which HN already does. If a bunch of people who are providing the high-quality submissions and comments say a particular submission is high-quality, what are the grounds for doubting them?
- pault 10y agoIt is not difficult to farm accounts for voting rings, and there is a significant financial incentive to do so. It's true that there may be some false positives, but without these protections the floodgates would be opened to startup marketing goons.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- throwaway88743 10y agoI am glad to see that I wasn't the only one who felt that IH were gaming the system and was treating their stories as spam. It does make me suspicious as to if HN admins treat YC alumni more equal than others.
- throw_this_away 10y agoModeration on HN is very strict. If Indie Hackers were 'gaming' the system, they'd be banned. That hasn't happened. The posts consistently end up on the front page because people like the site...
- throwaway88743 10y ago> Moderation on HN is very strict. If Indie Hackers were 'gaming' the system, they'd be banned. If the voting data were available, one of us could prove the other wrong. As they are not, it is my opinion vs yours.
- throw_this_away 10y agoIt's HN's opinion vs yours.
- dang 10y agoBanning on HN doesn't quite work in so off-with-their-heads a way. There are many forms of gaming HN; the spectrum runs from outright evil all the way to accidental. We try to make the punishment fit the crime, so in general a site not being banned doesn't mean they didn't try to game the system.
- dang 10y agoWe try hard not to do that. But it's tricky because many YC alumni do interesting work and/or are valued HN contributors and we certainly don't want to penalize them either.
- throwaway88775 10y ago
- wheelerwj 10y ago> disappointing message that growth hacking works. 1) its not disappointing that growth hacking works. Growth hacking is supposed to work. Growth hacking is just marketing 2.0. 2) it is disappointing that spam tactics get rewarded. But that has nothing to do with Stripe... mostly. I also think IndieHackers is lite on legitimate content, but its a great content marketing play by Stripe. Anything to suggest otherwise is just jealousy induced bitterness. Well done Stripe, congrats Courtland and Courtland's brother.
- pryelluw 10y agoWould you define legitimate content? Super interested.
- wheelerwj 10y agonon-sensationalized, technical accurate accounts of entrepreneurship. not, "it was built it in 3 months." while conveniently leaving off that it was springboarded from a previous veture that took 3 years to develop a base for.
- pryelluw 10y agoThat last part seems very specific. Any particular example you are thinking about?
- gspetr 10y agoCheck Ministry of Testing story on IH.
- pryelluw 10y agoThx :)
- wheelerwj 10y agothere were a few, i think park.io and then another having do with music, submithub i think? those are the two that came to mind. there was another, machine learning for company logos, the title was something like "50k monthly run rate after 3 months" but it was based off of sales after running a promotion which amounted to a couple grand in a few days. the shitty part is that all the stories are great, they don't need to be sensationalized, but he over sells them and then your left feeling let down.
- holtalanm 10y agoor, you know, the HN submissions from IndieHackers are actually popular. God forbid. I find myself actually _liking_ the IndieHackers posts, because they are inspiring. I know; there's no way I could be a real individual because all of the IndieHackers popularity is falsified. /s
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"I find myself actually _liking_ the IndieHackers posts, because they are inspiring." Same here. Good stories with specific details that might give me ideas. I originally saw it on Barnacl.es: a site for bootstrappers regularly posting stuff like marketing strategies with low noise in comments. Then I saw it on HN.
- daveheq 10y agoAre you saying IndieHackers is "hacking" the HackerNews forums?