3 ms·
The definite way it talks about the herbal section towards the end of the article is unfounded. Some of the herbal has in fact been the key to an attempt to tra
by Nursie 10y ago
The definite way it talks about the herbal section towards the end of the article is unfounded. Some of the herbal has in fact been the key to an attempt to translate a few words in recent years.
It may be hoax, it may not. But declaring "the plants in the book's herbal section never did and never could exist in nature" is nonsense.
Not all pages depict impossible plants and the drawings themselves may be highly derived, second or third hand illustrations.
IMHO it's unlikely to be a hoax due to the expense of such a hoax at the time, and I understand language patterm analysis looks about right - i.e. if it's a hoax it is a damn clever one and seems to defeat methods of analysis far ahead of its time.
Either way I doubt it contains the secret knowledge of the ancients.
--edit-- In fact inconsistency and weirdness in medieval manuscripts is really not evidence of a hoax to me - evidence they got things wrong, evidence of magical and mythical thinking, sure. But not specifically of a hoax.
- DonaldFisk 10y agoI'm not sure that "hoax" is the right word for it. The vellum's been radiocarbon dated to early 15th century, and the illustrations suggest a similar time period. So that rules out a hoax. The question is whether the text contains any meaningful encoded information, or is completely meaningless.
- Nursie 10y agoWell, it rules out a more recent hoax. I would consider a book produced in the early 15th century that deliberately contained.nothing of use to be something of a hoax. A magician's prop, for instance. There's another question of whether, even if information was once encoded in there, it is recoverable. Either because of some sort of hash-like function applied to the data, or just because there's not enough to go on. It's certainly intriguing.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sbierwagen 10y agoSome prominent forgeries have used both old media with old ink. Radiocarbon dating only proves the age of a substance, it doesn't prove when ink was applied to paper.
- DonaldFisk 10y agoIt was referred to in a letter written in 1639: http://www.voynich.nu/letters.html http://www.voynich.nu/letters.html