3 ms·
I was expecting Stallman-style advocacy against closed-source as a principle; pleasantly surprised by the arguments. Synchronous communication, indeed, is bad
by golergka 10y ago
I was expecting Stallman-style advocacy against closed-source as a principle; pleasantly surprised by the arguments.
Synchronous communication, indeed, is bad for the main communication channel. However, as a secondary communication channel, it can serve important needs.
When people are looking not to just get a single issue resolved, but to form a community, this community is often based on informal communication and emotions. Seeing the same people in the member list every day, exchanging little inside jokes, getting to know individual members of the community on a personal basis — this is something completely irrelevant for the user of the open-source product, but can be an important emotional component that motivates people to stay in the community and continue to put in effort into the project.
And, of course, a synchronous channel, where you can get more lax on moderation, is a much more suitable tool for this purpose.
- cat199 10y ago> I was expecting Stallman-style advocacy against closed-source as a principle; pleasantly surprised by the arguments. Is this a problem? Ostensibly one should hope to be able to communicate online in the same manner that one does offline: without paying an intermediary Further, if the 'natural trend' of economics is towards commoditization of products, why then are we abandoning those things which facillitated decentralization in order to support another entities profit motives?
- golergka 10y agoIf you're communicating with someone from a dicferent continent offline, get ready for a bill from your landline. We're gravitating towards better products. Sorry, but having used IRC a lot, Slack is just better.
- cat199 10y ago> Further, if the 'natural trend' of economics is towards commoditization of products, why then are we abandoning those things which facillitated decentralization in order to support another entities profit motives? your point fails to address this point; similarly 'better' has varying metrics.
- vorg 10y ago> Seeing the same people in the member list every day, exchanging little inside jokes ...about what other people are writing in the main communication channel, creating precedents about what should be discussed with "individual members of the community on a personal basis" and deciding the content that should be written on the main channel for the benefit of outsiders asleep in other time zones, ...
- aeorgnoieang 10y agoHow can you generally prevent a subgroup "deciding the content that should be written on the main channel for the benefit of outsiders asleep in other time zones" even in an 'asynchronous' communication channel? There's nothing stopping them from responding to each other quickly enough to effectively communicate 'synchronously'. I've intended to reply to communications before only to discover that someone else replied first while I was asleep in my other time zone.
- ravenstine 10y agoStallman only really cares about free software and not really OSS. But I get what you're saying.
- milesrout 10y agoFree software and open source software are synonyms. Even Stallman agrees on this. He cares about the use of the terms because of their other implications.
- ravenstine 10y agoOk, that's interesting. My impression from watching his talks is that he does not consider the two ideas as synonymous, in that a software can technically be closed-source but have licensing that is libre-free so that it can be used by whomever however. But perhaps I got it wrong.
- joejev 10y agoIt is the other way around: just because the source is available free of charge does not make the software free as in freedom. For example, there are licenses that prohibit you from running the software for commercial use even though you have access to the source. This would not fit the FSF's definition of free software because the user should have the right to use the software as they wish.
- milesrout 10y agoThose licenses also aren't open source. 'Open source' doesn't mean 'you can view the source', it means you can view, run, compile, modify and distribute the source, and distribute modified copies.