3 ms·
My tweet from last night is gone. It's not "alleged".
by hdhsbshs 10y ago
My tweet from last night is gone. It's not "alleged".
- danso 10y agoYes, it is still an allegation. Nothing has been proven beyond your assertion.
- bordercases 10y agoYou could settle this by experiment easily if we're trying to prove this to you: go ahead and try posting one, in similar vein to the others. There'd be a false-negative rate if you do it too late so I would try it now.
- 1337biz 10y agoTheir machine learning should be smart enough to not discriminate on a statistically significant scale.
- danso 10y agoI've been posting negative-sentiment tweets about United since yesterday. If we do accept the premise that Twitter would do something like this, we should also assume that they'd be selective in which tweets they've deleted, such as tweets that aren't likely to be noticed when gone. There are too many independent variables and unknowns for there to be an easy experiment. In any case, I'd be happy for other kinds of evidence. If Twitter is silencing tweets about United, is it part of a corporate ad package, in which case, other folks would've heard about this kind of deal for other companies?
- d23 10y agoOf all tweets to delete, why would they choose ones that aren't likely to be seen anyway?
- danso 10y agoThe premise is so unlikely (given what we know of Twitter's past behavior) that if we accept it, we have to accept motives that are beyond our understanding. That said, it's hard to conceptualize even just the metric that they might be optimizing for. I mean, randomly pruning negative sentiment tweets for a given topic might allow Twitter to tell United, "Hey, we removed 12,000 negative tweets about your brand" (leaving out the fact that there are 12,000,000 negative United tweets total). Or maybe by removing these random tweets, Twitter reduces the overall spread and diversity of this negative sentiment, as many people are content to just retweet what the most popular Twitter users have said about United. But...what would that fix? Twitter already has algorithms in place that make it hard for you to see things either outside of your own filter bubble or otherwise not popular content. For example, it's well known that many bots are triggered to auto-reply to Trump tweets, as the space devoted to tweet replies are seen as prime advertising space [0]. But I never see those merch-selling bots. The top replies I see to Trump tweets are either from my network, or are replies from popular (usually political) accounts. I have to dig very far to find those random bot replies. For me, a major argument against Twitter deleting tweets is that it has many other effective ways to suppress content that would be virtually undetectable without wide-scale analysis of their data. [0] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/12/weird-media-ecosystem/510911/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/12/weird...
- bordercases 10y ago> The premise is so unlikely (given what we know of Twitter's past behavior) that if we accept it, we have to accept motives that are beyond our understanding. What you and I both know of Twitter's behavior is unlikely to be shared knowledge between us, unless it's been your job to follow the company for awhile in which case I would have to defer to you. But I still expect you to tell me what it is we should both know. The Twitter I know is happy to shill for political reasons, that puts the possibility of money being given for damage control at corporate as being plausible to me, since there is more money in corporate than politics and Twitter itself is profit-driven with a shit business model. The Twitter you know is not? We could both be wrong. Without clarifying what you mean by "what we know" I wouldn't be so trigger happy with the rhetoric just yet.
- gerbilly 10y ago>If we do accept the premise that Twitter would do something like this, we should also assume that they'd be selective in which tweets they've deleted Maybe twitter has a team of lawyers sending them lists of Ids to remove, citing DMCA or whatever. Of course the hypothetical team of lawyers couldn't keep up, and the whole idea is ludicrous, but twitter might comply. Who knows?
- wnevets 10y agoand mine is still there, so.
- red_hairing 10y agothey also deleted my tweet from this morning, which simply made fun of united airlines ("we seat you, then we beat you! Board as a doctor, leave as a patient! #NewUnitedAirlinesMottos")
- red_hairing 10y agoUAL may be paying twitter and reddit to stifle the fun