4 ms·
Blog author here. Thats a fair criticism. I wanted to pick on Spotify and Atom more in my blog post, but both Spotify and Atom have cleaned up their act. I coul
by josephg 10y ago
Blog author here. Thats a fair criticism. I wanted to pick on Spotify and Atom more in my blog post, but both Spotify and Atom have cleaned up their act. I couldn't get either one to reproducibly use lots of CPU. Props to everyone involved in fixing that.
But I'd also argue that Flash could always be written to be efficient too. The problem with flash was never the little games people made. The problem was that one tab with a stupid punch-the-monkey banner add playing somewhere that would sit on 20% cpu even when the tab was in the background. I think Electron is similar, except in the desktop space. Well written apps seem to be able to keep CPU load down (although they still have a huge download and a huge RAM footprint). But there's been a running trend of noticing some dumb software running somewhere on my machine eating all my CPU. And in the last year or two its been an electron app, every time. Just like flash before it.
- apo 10y ago> ... I couldn't get either one [Spotify or Atom] to reproducibly use lots of CPU. Props to everyone involved in fixing that. It seems deceiving to conceal that information when your call to action is to ditch Electron for the sake of performance.
- david-cako 10y ago>I wanted to pick on Spotify and Atom more in my blog post, but both Spotify and Atom have cleaned up their act. I couldn't get either one to reproducibly use lots of CPU. Props to everyone involved in fixing that. Gotta agree with the other response here. If you have shown that what would seem to be much larger and more CPU intensive applications have been able to reliably perform well, why suggest moving away from electron instead of suggesting that users learn how to use it correctly, or perhaps suggesting that electron better educate users on how to use it correctly?
- vmasto 10y ago> I wanted to pick on Spotify and Atom more in my blog post, but both Spotify and Atom have cleaned up their act Can you please share how you came to the conclusion that Spotify is made with Electron? (hint: it's not)