4 ms·
Are you sure it wasn't also overbooked? They pulled passengers to fly crew, but that doesn't mean it wasn't overbooked.
by maxerickson 10y ago
Are you sure it wasn't also overbooked?
They pulled passengers to fly crew, but that doesn't mean it wasn't overbooked.
- jacquesm 10y agoThey claimed it was overbooked but that has not been substantiated with any evidence other than the company making that claim and using it to pre-empt those passengers in favor of their dead-headers. The proof that they are bullshitting is that the passengers were already on board when suddenly the plane was declared overbooked. Which to me sounds like UA using an excuse to bump passengers off a flight they are already confirmed on in order to fix some kind of crew scheduling issue.
- maxerickson 10y agoSure I agree it is just a claim. But they overbook most flights, so it isn't really hard to believe. They could have paid some other passengers already to not board, prior to deciding that they wanted to fly the crew and needing to pull more passengers. That leaves the overbooking claim as misdirection, which isn't any better than a lie that they were overbooked, but it's a different situation. (sorry about the edit crosstalk)
- jacquesm 10y agoOverbooking does not include non-paying passengers that were not confirmed before the flight. Those passengers had confirmed seats and boarding passes and were in fact already on the plane (as was their luggage). In my experience - which is limited, but I've flown quite a bit over the years - overbooking always involved other paying passengers, never crew.
- phil21 10y agoThere are many mechanisms for crew (and just airline employees in general - think mechanics on an emergency call-out to a remote airfield) to pre-empt paying passengers. This case was exceptional in that those crew (presumably) showed up to the gate after boarding, but I've watched a set of mechanics walk up to a gate just as it was boarding with "must fly" company tickets and some of the last folks who had yet to board got denied. I don't think there is a significant difference in calling this flight overbooked due to the 4 extra seats needed were on company tickets - it just typically happens behind the scenes 99% of the time and is invisible unless you're specifically watching for it.
- jacquesm 10y agoIn the age of social media 'must fly' company tickets are likely to become a thing of the past. As is offering minimum compensation and if not accepted forcibly 'volunteering' a couple of passengers. Spectacles like this are the last thing any public facing company can get away with and if they got away with it in the past it was only because there weren't any easy avenues for people to hold them accountable. United seems to be on a roll lately.
- daveguy 10y agoIf it was overbooked those excess passengers weren't on the plane. United wanted to fly 4 of their own employees (who showed up after everyone was boarded and seated) and "asked" for 4 seats from boarded paying customers. Without the employee passengers they were not overbooked or any overbooked passengers were not on the plane and we're irrelevant to the situation. I have flown plenty of times with other airlines when they overbooked and asked for volunteers. They do it in the terminal before boarding starts and generally don't have any problem getting someone to take $800 to hang around for the next flight. In those cases: 1) the terminal attendant can tell you exactly when you'll be able to resume your flight 2) you can know whether or not the delay will have you sleeping in an airport and can negotiate for a hotel if necessary. In this case no one (and why would they) took them up on a game of $800 flight roulette, so they had security drag a random guy off the plane. It was ridiculous when they made some kids have a dress code and refused to let them fly. This, on the other hand, should be illegal.
- maxerickson 10y agoI initially responded to a comment that said What's really bad is that technically this flight wasn't overbooked at all. And I made the perhaps inane point that we don't actually know that. I still haven't decided whether I think the airline should be allowed to deplane a passenger arbitrarily. I'm sure that they should be allowed to deplane someone that is being disruptive (this passenger was not), so it is a matter of what justifications are acceptable, not a matter of whether they can do it at all.
- JCharante 10y agoIn the instance of the kids, the kids that were refused an erection were not following the dress code.
- jacquesm 10y ago/me thinks you have an autocomplete issue.
- tylerjd 10y agoThat's exactly what they did. Someone up the chain made a mistake. Other airlines board must-ride passengers (i.e. crew deadheading to the next destination) before passengers, but this did not happen. Due to FAA regulations, the movement and sleep requirements of crew is enforced big time. In this case, they had a higher priority than a full-fare passenger (Must Ride), and even though it's morally wrong, it is well within the airline's right to remove any passenger at any time for any reason.
- dasil003 10y agoBut they have to pay compensation. The fact that the minimum compensation was not enough to get anyone to volunteer means they are just begging for regulation to push that minimum up. Penny-wise, pound-foolish.
- jacquesm 10y agoYes, they have the right, but then the public has the right to make a stink. The airline had other options, such as finding alternative transportation, or they could have offered more to bump passengers but they did neither and that's where their error lies. To then remove a bunch of passengers by major force in the age of social media is a mistake that will probably be made only once, those days are over.
- charlieflowers 10y agoFuck United. Corporations pull shit like this all the time, but they don't often get caught like this. It's OK with me if United doesn't exist tomorrow. Fuck them.
- cmurf 10y ago"airline's right to remove any passenger at any time for any reason" 1. Absurd. Flight attendant: Sir, you farted, we're going to remove you. Passenger: Umm, we're at 42,000 feet?! Flight attendant: Too bad, we can remove you at any time for any reason. 2. Citation for this "right"? In the airline's contract of carriage I see explicit reasons for being removed from an aircraft, and none of them apply to this case.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]