3 ms·
My post: > Except lots of eggs get broken today as a matter of course. If a technology saves lives, losing them to get it quicker might be a matter of balance.
by Chris2048 10y ago
My post:
> Except lots of eggs get broken today as a matter of course. If a technology saves lives, losing them to get it quicker might be a matter of balance.
The premise is that losing lives can be offset against saving them. "going out of their way to imperil people" suggests needless harm.
> You're literally, plain as day saying that ethics is merely self interest
No I don't, I give a specific example where I think this is the case; I don't apply this to all situations, or ethics in general.
I also don't "represent doing the right thing as avoiding being linked personally" - I do represent this as the only difference between two examples of doing good, (and hence don't think they are any different), but I don't question the value of doing good, but the relative values of one over another; I see value in saving lives, I don't see value in saving fewer lives because there might be personal liability.
> Saving the girl who was run over does not imperil anyone
This was a real example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Wang_Yue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Wang_Yue
> forcing me to go back and re-state the basic premise
You are wrong about the premise, so accusing me of playing tactics is moot.
> prove that you actually made the claim about ethics being self-interested
I said something about self-interest, in a specific case. You generalized this to "all good behavior.. I don't appreciate that.