3 ms·
This article is dreadful. Here's an alternative view: Talented software engineers are sick of 80-hour-week grinds as underpaid salary employees in an industry
by stickfigure 10y ago
This article is dreadful. Here's an alternative view:
Talented software engineers are sick of 80-hour-week grinds as underpaid salary employees in an industry where nine out of ten products fail. By working contract/hourly, they get actual money in liu of their name in a credits list that nobody reads - even in the unlikely event their product ships.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoAre you saying salaried employees don't get paid if the game tanks? I'm not sure what you're going for here.
- robryan 10y agoThey get paid a full time wage, likely no overtime. The parent comment is saying that at least contractors should get paid for every hour worked.
- gambiting 10y agoI work in the games industry. If a contractor works 80 hours a week, they can bill for 80 hours a week. If an employee works unpaid overtime then at least part of it is in hopes for a nice bonus once the game comes out(apart from you know, the satisfaction of working on a game). So in that way, an employee can do loads of extra work and if the game tanks they won't see any extra money.
- snovv_crash 10y agoSalaried employees don't get paid overtime.
- daemin 10y agoThis depends on the company. Where I work now we do get paid for overtime, but we have to organise it with our managers and producers first, and it has to be for a good reason. At the moment we are not in "crunch" so we only do overtime if we think we need to.
- snovv_crash 10y agoYou're incredibly lucky. From everything I've seen and heard this policy is very much the exception, although I hope that changes in the future. I really like a policy that gives management and employees aligned incentives; it puts everyone on the same team and makes sure people value the other side's perspective.
- drewmate 10y agoI believe he's saying that in the past, engineers would take a lower salary and work longer hours due to the prestige of working in the industry, or on a specific game. If they made those sacrifices and the game never even shipped, it would be disheartening. Though to a contractor, all billable hours are created equal.
- cookiecaper 10y agoDepending on the size of the studio, you very well could be out of a job if a major release tanks. As a contractor, this assumption is accounted for and built in.
- TillE 10y ago> nine out of ten products fail Nah, not even close. I mean, not unless you include every random app store game made by some teenager. Obviously the big companies almost always do well, but there are a ton of small and medium-sized companies which have been ticking along for years, releasing game after game with at least modest success. Failure isn't random either. You have good designers and good management, you're probably not going to release a bad game. A company's track record is often surprisingly consistent, in either way.
- ForRealsies 10y agoYou can release a good game and still not have financial success. And vice versa.
- cableshaft 10y agoThat's because publishers tend to take on the risk. Development studios, as long as they can keep finding a new publisher to pay them, can churn out financial failure after financial failure and it won't hurt them beyond possibly making it harder to find a new publisher to fund them. But if they can blame the game's failings on decisions made by the publishers -- and that's often the case, i.e. 'must be free to play!' or 'we don't need to market this game! if we make it, they will come!' or 'let's release it six months before the game is ready!' -- then the developer probably won't be hurt too much by a failed game, as long it wasn't super technically broken. I worked for a small publisher. We put out four games that did okay, and two games that lost a bunch of money (partially due to quality, partially due to misreading the market, partially due to timing, partially due to how the platforms worked), and those failures were enough to put us out of business seven years ago. Meanwhile the developers of those games are still chugging along today. By the way, I'm not saying those developers don't deserve to still be in business, as they did their job to the best of their abilities with the resources available. But that's just the nature of the business.
- cookiecaper 10y agoIf you divide out the years it takes to craft those games, the "modest successes" look a lot less appealing.