4 ms·
Given the choice between algorithms that work and algorithms that crudely mimic the brain but don't work, I'll choose algorithms that work every time. Why wast
by modeless 10y ago
Given the choice between algorithms that work and algorithms that crudely mimic the brain but don't work, I'll choose algorithms that work every time.
Why waste millions of dollars fabbing chips for algorithms that we know don't work very well? It's cargo cult science, thinking that if we just build brain imitations without even understanding how the brain works then it will magically produce AI.
Spiking proponents should focus on simulation and brain measurement until they figure out how to simulate something that works. At that point we can start making chips to improve efficiency. Meanwhile, the machine learning people may end up arriving at an AI that works as well as the brain or better despite operating on different principles, and that would be just fine!
- threeseed 10y ago> Given the choice Why do we have to choose ? Surely it is better to attempt both. Throughout the history of science knowing when something does not work is just as important as knowing when something does work.
- modeless 10y agoOf course we should investigate both. But when spending finite research dollars, we do have to choose. Should we fab chips for both? No, fabbing chips is very expensive. We should only fab chips for the one that works. The other can be investigated just fine in simulation.