3 ms·
Copying a disk does in no way require simulating each atom of the disk, though? • We can already clone mammalian bodies. • I'll assume that "growing" an adult
by Razengan 10y ago
Copying a disk does in no way require simulating each atom of the disk, though?
• We can already clone mammalian bodies.
• I'll assume that "growing" an adult human body, with a "blank" or "default" brain, isn't too inconceivable.
• Your real, natural brain can access the information within itself.
• At the moment of "copying", we figure some way to biologically link the two brains together, and write some biological software to pull data from the source brain to the destination brain.
- JetSpiegel 10y agoWhile the information stored in the disk is stored in the "analog" world (magnetic potential of parts of the platters), there's an infinite amount of states that lead to the same digital disk contents. You can't take the digital representation and reconstruct the analog state that leads to it, since by doing the analog-to-digital conversion there was information loss. And growing a body with a "blank" brain, what does that mean? Your conscience is absolutely intertwined with your body. If you take my mind and put it in Usain Bolt's body, that Frankenthing won't run 100m in <10s.
- scythe 10y agoThe disk is designed to be copyable. The brain is not. See e.g. this evolved circuit: https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ The brain is, as far as we can tell, more like that circuit than a disk. Information is encoded within the structure of the processor itself, rather than being one of 2^N easily defined conformations of a memory device. As such, there is no way to copy the memories of brain A into brain B -- it simply isn't a thing. It would be like saying: copy all of the stains on this shirt, but the stains are integrated into the fibers and are unique to the stitching. In particular, this statement is false: >Your real, natural brain can access the information within itself. It cannot, for example, I cannot fully describe how to walk, given a pair of human legs and a butt. My brain can only encode information into language in the particular ways in which it is "designed" to do so. There is no way at all for the brain to report, e.g., the number of synapses within it, even if the firings of some neurons are recorded electronically. I say "design" in this sense because the structure of my brain is contingent on its fitness-for-purpose in a way that affected its formation, via biological evolution, similar to the way that the structure of an intentionally designed object is contingent on its fitness-for-purpose, which affected its formation as it was constructed by the entity which made it.
- Razengan 10y agoWell then. If copying's out of the question (for now), then I propose Plan B: A single brain, in a secure location, remotely controlling multiple bodies (one at a time, but able to switch between them.) • Identify all the points of contact – the I/O pins – between the brain and body. • Identify the medium and format of communication between brain/body/senses. I think most of this has already been achieved. • Grow a body, a shell, without a brain. • Take your brain out and keep it alive in a vat. • Put wireless transceivers at each I/O point on the controlling brain and the shell body/bodies. Will anything like this be remotely (<pun) possible? You'd have to get used to lag but in the case of a fatal accident/violence* and most diseases your brain would be safe and able to switch to a new body.. I expect something like that would be very valuable to soldiers and workers in hazardous environments, like space.
- mcguire 10y agoGiven the focus of other responders on copying, I'd just like to point out that "I'll assume that "growing" an adult human body, with a "blank" or "default" brain, isn't too inconceivable." is problematic as well.
- cyanotic 10y agoOkay, come on, Razengan. This thought experiment is not a difficult one. I invent a machine that "scans" your body in such a way that I'm able to create a perfect replica of the state your body was in, nearly to the atom. Molecule, by molecule, the machine can rebuild your body, within a near infinitesimal margin of error. I put you inside this machine, and scan your replica file, and then I save it to a massive storage device, and, when called upon I can rebuild that version of you whenever I want. Now, after being successfully scanned, you exit the device. I blow your head off with a shotgun, and your headless corpse slumps on the floor. No witnesses. Do you really think you'll come back to life, if I print out your replica from the file?
- Razengan 10y agoThere is some fiction that touches on exactly that dilemma, and I love it. SOMA [0] being a prominent example. As I said in other comments, once such technology is available, our laws and ethics will have to adapt to it one way or the other. [0] http://store.steampowered.com/app/282140/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/282140/