5 ms·
While we have thousands of years of cultural belief that mind and body are distinct, I'm not aware of any scientific evidence for that. And there is a lot of ev
by snowwrestler 10y ago
While we have thousands of years of cultural belief that mind and body are distinct, I'm not aware of any scientific evidence for that. And there is a lot of evidence that the mind is directly dependent on the state of the body--change the body (drugs, injury, etc) and inevitably the state of mind changes too.
So I don't know of any reason to think that it's even possible to separate a mind from a body, let alone move one to a new one.
- WalterBright 10y agoI'm not sure I'd even want to exist inside a computer. Much of the pleasure in life is having a body.
- Razengan 10y agoJust copy everything then. There's no reason to roll over and just accept death from aging, accident or violence, any more than we accept death by flu or any other curable disease. Things which would've outright killed people 200 years ago merely cause a few days of a runny nose to us, so to speak. You cannot deny that medicine is, after all, basically the quest for immortality, and that is where it's going to end up.
- scythe 10y agoYou cannot copy "all" of the information stored in the human body. Briefly, this happens because the physical limitations of information storage require cooling (Landauer's principle) which requires kT×log(2) energy per bit, or about 2.5 zJ at room temperature. The brain's memory capacity is about 2.5 * 10^15 bytes (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-is-the-memory-capacity/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-is-the-memor...), but the amount of information which can be retrieved is much smaller than the amount of information required to fully describe the system -- in the same way that knowing the contents of my hard disk will not help you recreate my laptop. The brain weighs about 1300 grams, of which maybe 5%, or 65 grams, is protein, composed of amino acids which weigh about 0.25 zeptograms, so contains about 2.6 * 10^23 amino acids. If we assume that we need a kilobit of information per amino acid, which seems like a lowball, it would require about 650 kilojoules of energy at the absolute thermodynamic minimum (vastly more efficient than real computers) just to store the information in the human brain. The electrical power required to simulate its dynamics would be tectonic, and that's assuming perfect efficiency. Therefore, no computer that is composed of components which interact with the electromagnetic field and which operates at a temperature comparable to Earth temperatures will ever simulate a human mind to complete accuracy. It will always be an approximation.
- cyan_atrus 10y agothis is a really cool comment -- thank you! -- do you have any more reading you can link to?
- selestify 10y agoSame, would love to read more about this!
- Razengan 10y agoCopying a disk does in no way require simulating each atom of the disk, though? • We can already clone mammalian bodies. • I'll assume that "growing" an adult human body, with a "blank" or "default" brain, isn't too inconceivable. • Your real, natural brain can access the information within itself. • At the moment of "copying", we figure some way to biologically link the two brains together, and write some biological software to pull data from the source brain to the destination brain.
- JetSpiegel 10y agoWhile the information stored in the disk is stored in the "analog" world (magnetic potential of parts of the platters), there's an infinite amount of states that lead to the same digital disk contents. You can't take the digital representation and reconstruct the analog state that leads to it, since by doing the analog-to-digital conversion there was information loss. And growing a body with a "blank" brain, what does that mean? Your conscience is absolutely intertwined with your body. If you take my mind and put it in Usain Bolt's body, that Frankenthing won't run 100m in <10s.
- scythe 10y agoThe disk is designed to be copyable. The brain is not. See e.g. this evolved circuit: https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ The brain is, as far as we can tell, more like that circuit than a disk. Information is encoded within the structure of the processor itself, rather than being one of 2^N easily defined conformations of a memory device. As such, there is no way to copy the memories of brain A into brain B -- it simply isn't a thing. It would be like saying: copy all of the stains on this shirt, but the stains are integrated into the fibers and are unique to the stitching. In particular, this statement is false: >Your real, natural brain can access the information within itself. It cannot, for example, I cannot fully describe how to walk, given a pair of human legs and a butt. My brain can only encode information into language in the particular ways in which it is "designed" to do so. There is no way at all for the brain to report, e.g., the number of synapses within it, even if the firings of some neurons are recorded electronically. I say "design" in this sense because the structure of my brain is contingent on its fitness-for-purpose in a way that affected its formation, via biological evolution, similar to the way that the structure of an intentionally designed object is contingent on its fitness-for-purpose, which affected its formation as it was constructed by the entity which made it.
- aoner 10y agoLet's do a though experiment, and say that it is possible to 'copy' a person. We live in the future where we all use fancy teleporters. You happily live in Amsterdam and commute to the Bay Area every morning. The way the teleporter actually works is by making a quick copy, deconstructing the object and the recreating the exact copy some place else. One day you go to the teleporter and realize it's broken. You contact customer service and are totally missing that 9 o clock meeting. Customer support says: "We're sorry but there has been a malfunctioning. You were teleported but not deconstructed properly. Could you please step back in the teleporter so we can deconstruct you?". Body and self are intertwined in ways we don't yet fully understand. But it will be verry difficult to transfer consciousness. In the case of copying, you are for sure just dying and a new copy of you will be born. A scarier thought even: Perhaps this is the case when we go to sleep and your consciousness dies and a new one wakes up every morning. Sure would explains why I always have a hard time falling asleep ;)
- Razengan 10y agoOther commenters brought this up too. :) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14082961 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14082961 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14082866 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14082866
- LoSboccacc 10y agoThere's an head transplant scheduled for this year with some major luck we'll soon know more about what's consciousness.