4 ms·
I don't think that is the argument the author is trying to make. Obviously, the 'aggregated' performance of the managers will match the index, minus the fees (a
by cortesoft 10y ago
I don't think that is the argument the author is trying to make. Obviously, the 'aggregated' performance of the managers will match the index, minus the fees (assuming every stock is in the index, and there is no adverse selection).
So basically, the argument is that having an active fund manager is increasing your risk while also increasing your potential reward. The expected value is average, while the volatility is higher. While you might think this is an insignificant conclusion, I don't think this fact is obvious; most people aren't expecting that choosing an actively managed fund is increasing their risk.
- OJRbberg 10y agoKnucklehead author here -- happy to see all the smart discussion on this thread here. Your point here is indeed one of the main takeaways. For all practical purposes the sum of active manager performance = the index. But given the probability that the active manager you pick won't beat the index (in large part determined by skewness, the academics cited would argue), is indeed the risk you introduce by taking this route. Thanks to all for reading and arguing. O