5 ms·
I read lots of research papers and books. I used to think that once I get big and high contrast e-paper tablet with ability to annotate I don't need paper anymo
by nabla9 10y ago
I read lots of research papers and books. I used to think that once I get big and high contrast e-paper tablet with ability to annotate I don't need paper anymore.
Then I noticed that e-paper is window to knowledge that allows me to look in but never allows my mind to enter. There is cognitive wall between myself and the things I read.
Reading physical papers and books and storing them is concrete memory palace technique. Writing notes on them, underlying, leaving coffee stains and folding corners, adding sticky notes etc. is concrete physical creation of of a memory palace. It helps to arrange, retain and absorb knowledge with spatial associations.
When I store paper I have just read into a stack of papers, or put it into a folder in a bookshelf, it's stored in a spatial space that helps with remembering and recollection just like memory palace memorization technique. If I look at the paper years later, just quick glance brings in the associations. E-paper tablet is just the same tablet every time.
I still use tablets and computer to read fiction and skim abstracts. If I have to fully learn and think what I read, I print it out.
---
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_loci https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_loci
- romaniv 10y agoTrying to replace paper with eInk isn't wise. However, those devices could have other, entirely new usages. For example, digital blackboard that consumes little power and can be remotely updated would be extremely useful. This isn't something that is possible with normal monitors because of power consumption and the annoying glow. That's just one possibility.
- jedimastert 10y ago> digital blackboard that consumes little power and can be remotely updated would be extremely useful. This is what I've been looking at them for. I would consider them an electronic notebook.
- icantdrive55 10y agoYea--I noticed the same thing. I'm wondering if it would be different if I had a device I could write on, but not buying anymore readers, at least for awhile. I can bring up parts of a book page in my mind, but I don't think I can do it with electronic readers. I'm not sure, because I haven't been in school for awhile, or needed to bring up something for a test. When I was in school, I had a hard time memorizing. I started taking notes differently, my recall increased dramatically. I would doodle on every page. Every page of notes was only written once, and I never re-copied. I tried to make every page a picture. My text books were filled with doodles, and pictures in the margins. It really helped me. Now--my books are just taking up too much room. I hate to get rid of them, but might have too. There was a time where I could get any book on the Internet. Those days are gone. I'm not a big reader either. My books are just reference, but have value to me. I know it's crazy.
- dade_ 10y agoI replaced books with my Kobo and iPad years ago, but replaced the iPad with a Surface since. I don't have any memory palace issues, but a bookshelf is a must. To solve my bookshelf issue I use Calibre and keep all of books, including technical manuals in it. I store all of the files and the Calibre database on a folder in DropBox. It suits me fine. I standardized on PDF and ePub files for maximum compatibility, but Calibre will also convert the files on the fly for me.
- abhgh 10y agoI have a very similar problem. I bought a Kindle years ago because I thought it will solve all my reading problems - I wasn't even thinking about annotating stuff, so my use-case is weaker/easier than yours. Now, I tend to do two kinds of reading - (1) research papers - often with multicolumnar writing, tables, diagrams and mathematical notation (2) "normal" books. I realized that kindle is very bad for (1) ---- I could load a PDF but then I don't get to use flow, and given the screen size, this can be annoying. Converters (like calibre) don't always work. Math symbols (which can show up mangled), diagrams and tables can get displaced from the "region" of discussion. Eventually I just moved to read stuff of type (2) on my Kindle. For (1), I still use printouts.
- hackpert 10y agoFor (1), you might want to look into http://dontprint.net http://dontprint.net. Of course it doesn't solve annotation issues but for reading it works well enough.
- mkesper 10y agoI always wondered how my parents were able to learn by writing with their pencil on their slate, wiping it off afterwards and writing the next thing on it. Seems comparable to me. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schreibtafel#Schiefertafel https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schreibtafel#Schiefertafel